Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Lorax is Good, But Not Tree-mendous

Plus, Project X is a bummer of a party.

by | March 1, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an animated eco-parable (The Lorax, with voice work from Zac Efron and Taylor Swift) and a wild party (Project X, starring Thomas Mann and Oliver Cooper). What do the critics have to say?

The Lorax


Delightful as Dr. Seuss’ books are, they aren’t all that long, so it can’t be easy to adapt them to the big screen. The critics say The Lorax sometimes feels padded with action and musical numbers, but on the whole, it’s bright and colorful, and it delivers a solid message about protecting the planet. Ted (Zac Efron) is a youngster who ventures beyond the seemingly idyllic confines of Thneedville and discovers that greed has led to deforestation, despite the warnings of the diminutive orange tree defender the Lorax (Danny DeVito). The pundits say The Lorax does a nice job of capturing the visual style of Seuss’ book, and it contains some solid gags, but it’s also so busy and action-packed that it mostly forgoes the whimsy (and the message) of its source. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down DeVito’s best-reviewed movies).

Project X


Just when you think every idea for a teen party comedy has been exhausted, along comes the mockumetary Project X, which purports to capture the wild goings-on of a particularly raging kegger. Unfortunately, critics say the film is mostly a mean-spirited wallow into areas better explored in Animal House and Superbad. A trio of nerds decides to throw a birthday party in order to increase their social standing; bedlam (and would-be hilarity) ensues. The pundits say Project X might have merited some laughs if it bothered developing its characters, but as it stands, it’s essentially just a string of “outrageous” incidents that test the bounds of good taste.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Finally, props to Zach K for guessing Tyler Perry’s Good Deeds‘ 31 percent Tomatometer, and to Ben C for guessing Gone‘s 11 percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

TNT Awards Musicals Star Trek TruTV Action harry potter Spring TV LGBTQ talk show Acorn TV IFC X-Men war Disney Channel 2015 Mary Poppins Returns Paramount Sci-Fi 2016 crime BET jamie lee curtis Reality Competition Freeform Pop Mindy Kaling crime thriller Calendar FXX Superheroes golden globes cinemax adventure Netflix Best and Worst psycho VH1 TCA 2017 technology Walt Disney Pictures green book Warner Bros. Writers Guild of America Rom-Com Lifetime festivals Premiere Dates social media El Rey San Diego Comic-Con Biopics Shudder TIFF Christmas Mystery Disney Red Carpet Martial Arts GLAAD Food Network Tumblr serial killer Rocky Certified Fresh BBC America PBS Toys Sundance Now Pirates Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Nominations Teen NBC 20th Century Fox Sundance Paramount Network Marathons robots Animation Universal Crackle zombies Infographic TCM GIFs OWN IFC Films medical drama Video Games finale FOX DC Universe crime drama Cosplay Holidays Box Office New York Comic Con Set visit comiccon Winter TV Podcast A&E PaleyFest Reality dc Esquire romance transformers award winner politics 2019 Western Rock boxoffice facebook supernatural TV Land Song of Ice and Fire TLC Apple aliens Mary Tyler Moore USA Network NYCC The Arrangement DC streaming service sitcom YouTube Premium SDCC Shondaland Polls and Games Ovation RT History First Look Election Epix Character Guide Columbia Pictures Comic Book Interview Logo Nickelodeon Dark Horse Comics AMC Sony Pictures TBS MSNBC Oscars Superheroe Pixar Britbox sports dceu Awards Tour YA Schedule cooking Tomatazos ITV vampires Mary poppins E! Marvel APB Cartoon Network 24 frames SXSW Watching Series diversity Hulu dramedy Star Wars Syfy television Starz based on movie Kids & Family Fall TV FX Grammys Fox News MTV docudrama discovery SundanceTV cults Photos President Countdown Comedy cops Super Bowl Ellie Kemper ABC Family Adult Swim Amazon CNN streaming HBO Lionsgate doctor who Creative Arts Emmys ABC Opinion TV CMT spider-man Trailer political drama 2018 WGN binge Trophy Talk Masterpiece what to watch Thanksgiving singing competition 45 period drama See It Skip It DC Comics 007 Black Mirror Quiz CW Seed police drama Winners Bravo DirecTV Year in Review USA Comics on TV Showtime CBS mutant comic spy thriller Trivia E3 Lucasfilm anime Spike Sneak Peek 21st Century Fox hist crossover blaxploitation composers National Geographic science fiction Summer Fantasy Comedy Central BBC VICE thriller GoT ESPN historical drama 2017 TCA CBS All Access Emmys biography Valentine's Day Extras travel Horror American Society of Cinematographers Drama miniseries Music Country unscripted Ghostbusters The CW Musical Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt YouTube Red Nat Geo ratings justice league zombie cats History