Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Lorax is Good, But Not Tree-mendous

Plus, Project X is a bummer of a party.

by | March 1, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an animated eco-parable (The Lorax, with voice work from Zac Efron and Taylor Swift) and a wild party (Project X, starring Thomas Mann and Oliver Cooper). What do the critics have to say?

The Lorax


Delightful as Dr. Seuss’ books are, they aren’t all that long, so it can’t be easy to adapt them to the big screen. The critics say The Lorax sometimes feels padded with action and musical numbers, but on the whole, it’s bright and colorful, and it delivers a solid message about protecting the planet. Ted (Zac Efron) is a youngster who ventures beyond the seemingly idyllic confines of Thneedville and discovers that greed has led to deforestation, despite the warnings of the diminutive orange tree defender the Lorax (Danny DeVito). The pundits say The Lorax does a nice job of capturing the visual style of Seuss’ book, and it contains some solid gags, but it’s also so busy and action-packed that it mostly forgoes the whimsy (and the message) of its source. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down DeVito’s best-reviewed movies).

Project X


Just when you think every idea for a teen party comedy has been exhausted, along comes the mockumetary Project X, which purports to capture the wild goings-on of a particularly raging kegger. Unfortunately, critics say the film is mostly a mean-spirited wallow into areas better explored in Animal House and Superbad. A trio of nerds decides to throw a birthday party in order to increase their social standing; bedlam (and would-be hilarity) ensues. The pundits say Project X might have merited some laughs if it bothered developing its characters, but as it stands, it’s essentially just a string of “outrageous” incidents that test the bounds of good taste.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Finally, props to Zach K for guessing Tyler Perry’s Good Deeds‘ 31 percent Tomatometer, and to Ben C for guessing Gone‘s 11 percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

independent dramedy Interview 71st Emmy Awards TCM Marvel Television BBC America Superheroes Martial Arts Rock 24 frames mission: impossible justice league DirecTV MSNBC Red Carpet Paramount italian Brie Larson Paramount Network LGBTQ renewed TV shows Heroines Black History Month TCA 2017 Musicals Mary Tyler Moore DC streaming service 20th Century Fox james bond CNN hist criterion parents Christmas witnail Calendar Ghostbusters YA Action Showtime Lucasfilm rotten movies we love Spectrum Originals true crime Pride Month Tomatazos Discovery Channel 2015 Fox News Certified Fresh Quiz adventure 72 Emmy Awards Creative Arts Emmys cartoon dogs FX on Hulu reboot Rocketman Apple TV+ A24 Mary poppins strong female leads Film Festival DGA game show Kids & Family Britbox Video Games VOD USA E! TNT Crackle Syfy Sundance psycho batman serial killer HBO cancelled TV shows Year in Review stand-up comedy christmas movies The Witch NYCC toronto See It Skip It President ABC Comics on TV football Comedy Central Comic Book The Purge transformers talk show CMT movie GoT Fantasy Walt Disney Pictures stop motion twilight cars binge Emmy Nominations news sequel Warner Bros. nature Lifetime obituary BET DC Universe El Rey Super Bowl halloween Character Guide a nightmare on elm street Amazon Studios Sony Pictures psychological thriller Trophy Talk Writers Guild of America Funimation CBS Lifetime Christmas movies anime supernatural Binge Guide biography Disney+ Disney Plus harry potter PaleyFest Lionsgate Sneak Peek Photos festival versus halloween tv Comedy dark Apple Winners anthology Holiday Freeform best Oscars Acorn TV spanish language mockumentary Disney streaming service RT History sitcom cancelled TV series Turner Classic Movies MTV kids adaptation vampires The CW Reality Competition worst Schedule Cannes space medical drama concert Thanksgiving Turner based on movie Shudder Star Wars screen actors guild TCA Winter 2020 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt FOX Marvel mutant Dark Horse Comics hispanic Amazon PBS Pop IFC Films Mystery composers OneApp Film Premiere Dates Drama french First Look YouTube Red worst movies disaster remakes Mary Poppins Returns E3 Travel Channel zombies BAFTA GIFs what to watch teaser die hard IFC book NBC screenings Ellie Kemper Set visit BBC One Sundance Now diversity Nat Geo Epix crime Hallmark zero dark thirty facebook Spring TV Trailer foreign politics Netflix spain toy story nbcuniversal cancelled X-Men fast and furious romance rt archives Adult Swim Black Mirror Masterpiece USA Network SXSW Marvel Studios free movies Arrowverse animated indie TV tv talk Fox Searchlight OWN 2017 critics crossover Teen scorecard Fall TV FX breaking bad AMC Apple TV Plus jamie lee curtis cats Esquire Reality Pixar Television Academy zombie Crunchyroll series Spike theme song Countdown Winter TV superhero Food Network Logo Summer war stoner BBC sports political drama doctor who Vudu robots canceled TV shows Television Critics Association Universal ABC Family WarnerMedia singing competition TLC Bravo period drama HBO Max documentaries 2018 comic blockbuster 007 New York Comic Con award winner indiana jones Tubi science fiction cinemax Rocky 21st Century Fox Emmys SundanceTV Endgame archives unscripted reviews documentary VICE cults docudrama universal monsters romantic comedy Captain marvel Musical Watching Series crime drama spy thriller chucky comedies Marathons franchise deadpool BET Awards video Nickelodeon Music Pet Sematary golden globes Sci-Fi boxoffice nfl films richard e. Grant black TCA ratings APB Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Disney Plus rotten streaming spider-man Cartoon Network TV renewals Trivia TCA Awards Toys ITV Grammys Netflix Christmas movies child's play Opinion Tarantino discovery Shondaland YouTube TBS game of thrones Hulu sag awards A&E Mindy Kaling south america 45 name the review travel ghosts Election social media Pop TV slashers spanish Women's History Month television crime thriller technology Ovation Western latino Amazon Prime Video Awards Tour PlayStation canceled festivals Amazon Prime comics video on demand emmy awards The Academy Academy Awards First Reviews Hallmark Christmas movies blaxploitation San Diego Comic-Con cops 2019 Mudbound dragons YouTube Premium TIFF CW Seed miniseries scary movies spinoff GLAAD police drama Columbia Pictures Family Infographic SDCC historical drama The Arrangement Disney Channel Star Trek 2016 comic books joker 4/20 asian-american Peacock Tumblr Animation green book Nominations MCU TV Land Cosplay Chernobyl Extras 2020 cancelled television History movies children's TV RT21 FXX natural history Biopics Box Office satire DC Comics Awards Sundance TV venice aliens VH1 The Walking Dead Classic Film TruTV Avengers quibi Rom-Com Hear Us Out LGBT ESPN dc Holidays directors dceu comiccon Anna Paquin australia Stephen King all-time Horror Valentine's Day CBS All Access Best and Worst classics Disney Podcast casting elevated horror National Geographic thriller Pirates finale japanese hollywood Polls and Games ID Elton John sequels American Society of Cinematographers WGN Superheroe Baby Yoda cooking Song of Ice and Fire HBO Go revenge laika Country Starz werewolf