Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug is on Solid Ground

Plus, Tyler Perry's A Madea Christmas wasn't screened for critics, and American Hustle and Saving Mr. Banks are Certified Fresh.

by | December 13, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a journey through Middle-earth (The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug, starring Martin Freeman and Ian McKellen) and some yuletide shenanigans (Tyler Perry’s A Madea Christmas, starring Tyler Perry and Kathy Najimy). What do the critics have to say?

The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug


OK, so here’s the bad news: critics say The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug is overlong and overstuffed with characters and subplots that are likely to mean little to all but the most devoted of Tolkien fans. The good news? They also say it’s a step up from An Unexpected Journey, in that it’s better paced and more action-packed. This time, our heroes Bilbo Baggins (Martin Freeman) and Gandalf (Ian McKellen) are on a journey to Lonely Mountain, encountering giant spiders, elves, and a human/bear hybrid as part of their mission to wrest control of a lost Dwarf kingdom from Smaug, a terrifying dragon. The pundits say the first two Hobbit movies have yet to approach the depth and sweep of the Lord of the Rings films, but Smaug mostly succeeds as both a middle chapter and a rousing fantasy adventure in its own right. (For lots more on The Desolation Of Smaug and the LOTR films, check out Hobbit Headquarters.)

Tyler Perry’s A Madea Christmas


A Madea Christmas, like most of Tyler Perry’s output, was not screened for critics prior to its release in theaters. When an old friend decides to pay a surprise visit to her daughter, she talks Madea (Perry) into tagging along; soon our irrepressible heroine is shaking up a small town’s Christmas carnival. Time to guess the Tomatometer!

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

dark worst movies Spectrum Originals social media Starz blockbuster Avengers Vudu cars a nightmare on elm street rom-coms BET Awards lord of the rings HBO Go Mystery CW Seed Rocketman BBC America toy story TCA Awards Netflix Thanksgiving prank rotten Rocky DC Comics Sundance Now television political drama Comics on TV TCA Winter 2020 Superheroes facebook Disney Channel spinoff Wes Anderson Summer composers video game of thrones USA ABC Signature Emmys Christmas Star Wars Fox Searchlight WGN jurassic park Action TCM sequel Tubi live action Exclusive Video BBC One GLAAD Paramount Plus Turner Premiere Dates book Walt Disney Pictures Lucasfilm Heroines Comedy Central 20th Century Fox zombie Nickelodeon Sci-Fi Freeform adaptation Shudder christmas movies Classic Film emmy awards Musical The Arrangement Set visit The Academy CNN LGBTQ Musicals ITV Film supernatural Music TV Land Amazon Studios Creative Arts Emmys Amazon Prime Video Discovery Channel New York Comic Con parents docuseries 90s Baby Yoda reboot Logo laika Hear Us Out south america olympics NBC Comedy politics 2017 Anna Paquin ABC YA HBO FX on Hulu Arrowverse Valentine's Day halloween tv Adult Swim fast and furious worst Ellie Kemper golden globe awards RT21 historical drama The CW Crunchyroll name the review Family australia revenge what to watch Crackle Marvel Television documentary biography canceled thriller The Walking Dead hollywood space VH1 news SXSW sitcom Mary Tyler Moore TV Trivia superhero Dark Horse Comics archives Super Bowl NYCC 99% Photos cancelled television TLC President free movies Lifetime BET foreign HBO Max sports travel breaking bad Spring TV Amazon football theme song black Mindy Kaling Year in Review spanish language cancelled TV shows SundanceTV elevated horror Syfy Chilling Adventures of Sabrina ViacomCBS Reality Competition PaleyFest Nominations Apple TV+ trailers DC streaming service Nat Geo Grammys finale Disney+ Disney Plus monster movies universal monsters tv talk Sundance independent werewolf sag awards nfl FOX jamie lee curtis Animation Acorn TV Box Office japan Trophy Talk Television Critics Association San Diego Comic-Con Black Mirror The Witch international Polls and Games cooking Oscars 45 rotten movies we love best APB History king kong Mudbound Fantasy comiccon twilight hidden camera versus joker godzilla Travel Channel dogs child's play 007 docudrama high school science fiction ID reviews comic books blaxploitation police drama Mary poppins PBS doctor who slashers Paramount cancelled TV series VICE Video Games richard e. Grant book adaptation 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Holidays crime cats Black History Month witnail period drama deadpool Tumblr concert YouTube streaming movies Brie Larson Sneak Peek Western El Rey cancelled Sundance TV basketball TCA films disaster anime spanish hist mission: impossible TV movies sequels Rom-Com Elton John Britbox Hallmark Pop A&E Tomatazos Captain marvel Lifetime Christmas movies Reality romantic comedy crime drama The Walt Disney Company spain Extras BBC USA Network National Geographic rt archives Rock james bond spy thriller X-Men Hulu See It Skip It comedies criterion new york casting TNT Election LGBT Film Festival screen actors guild DGA Star Trek Turner Classic Movies fresh marvel cinematic universe kong target 21st Century Fox 93rd Oscars Disney Plus Epix stand-up comedy telelvision Peacock crime thriller IFC Films Cannes die hard MCU Tokyo Olympics boxing Pacific Islander Countdown First Look 2019 TV One Biopics Columbia Pictures Television Academy Pop TV new star wars movies screenings E3 stop motion zombies italian Legendary war Kids & Family Masterpiece adventure Mary Poppins Returns venice Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 2021 SDCC renewed TV shows Pet Sematary festival satire Endgame YouTube Premium TIFF spider-man Quiz Lionsgate PlayStation Cosplay A24 kids Disney Infographic Winter TV Tarantino Teen justice league razzies kaiju mutant 71st Emmy Awards movie 4/20 Cartoon Network serial killer E! remakes psychological thriller Horror streaming romance classics miniseries Toys nbcuniversal technology french Awards batman transformers ratings dragons 72 Emmy Awards superman Universal scene in color popular japanese 2020 comic GoT DirecTV Schedule singing competition 1990s Showtime Writers Guild of America 2015 harry potter Martial Arts blockbusters NBA crossover aapi dc nature MTV medical drama Broadway 2016 Comic Book indie Fox News strong female leads Podcast Drama halloween Red Carpet Winners TCA 2017 canceled TV shows TV renewals Funimation 24 frames golden globes festivals zero dark thirty heist movie Trailer RT History Calendar vampires ABC Family IFC Hallmark Christmas movies critics award winner CBS All Access chucky Food Network Paramount Network American Society of Cinematographers latino natural history unscripted FX Song of Ice and Fire Apple comics dceu Marvel know your critic cults series hispanic Pixar animated all-time scary movies CMT Certified Fresh TBS Spike Marvel Studios ghosts suspense indiana jones green book Sony Pictures Alien stoner obituary OneApp Interview VOD Comic-Con@Home 2021 Ghostbusters children's TV ESPN Character Guide 2018 Marathons Watching Series robots teaser boxoffice women asian-american Chernobyl based on movie new zealand Country TruTV FXX Women's History Month Best and Worst adenture Amazon Prime video on demand movies Emmy Nominations documentaries Image Comics binge quibi AMC YouTube Red Apple TV Plus Academy Awards Superheroe Pirates Disney streaming service true crime Shondaland The Purge cops Pride Month First Reviews MSNBC CBS GIFs pirates of the caribbean Netflix Christmas movies Opinion Binge Guide discovery DC Universe psycho saw Bravo Fall TV Stephen King cinemax diversity dramedy OWN BAFTA cartoon toronto Ovation franchise Esquire WarnerMedia scorecard mockumentary Warner Bros. Awards Tour anthology aliens game show Holiday directors talk show