Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug is on Solid Ground

Plus, Tyler Perry's A Madea Christmas wasn't screened for critics, and American Hustle and Saving Mr. Banks are Certified Fresh.

by | December 13, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a journey through Middle-earth (The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug, starring Martin Freeman and Ian McKellen) and some yuletide shenanigans (Tyler Perry’s A Madea Christmas, starring Tyler Perry and Kathy Najimy). What do the critics have to say?

The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug

74%

OK, so here’s the bad news: critics say The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug is overlong and overstuffed with characters and subplots that are likely to mean little to all but the most devoted of Tolkien fans. The good news? They also say it’s a step up from An Unexpected Journey, in that it’s better paced and more action-packed. This time, our heroes Bilbo Baggins (Martin Freeman) and Gandalf (Ian McKellen) are on a journey to Lonely Mountain, encountering giant spiders, elves, and a human/bear hybrid as part of their mission to wrest control of a lost Dwarf kingdom from Smaug, a terrifying dragon. The pundits say the first two Hobbit movies have yet to approach the depth and sweep of the Lord of the Rings films, but Smaug mostly succeeds as both a middle chapter and a rousing fantasy adventure in its own right. (For lots more on The Desolation Of Smaug and the LOTR films, check out Hobbit Headquarters.)

Tyler Perry’s A Madea Christmas

20%

A Madea Christmas, like most of Tyler Perry’s output, was not screened for critics prior to its release in theaters. When an old friend decides to pay a surprise visit to her daughter, she talks Madea (Perry) into tagging along; soon our irrepressible heroine is shaking up a small town’s Christmas carnival. Time to guess the Tomatometer!

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

ABC women Creative Arts Emmys comics Best Picture Turner TV One The Walt Disney Company Countdown Alien Film docudrama crime thriller trophy scene in color film series Acorn TV slashers Best Director based on movie Marvel The Arrangement 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards cinemax doctor who jamie lee curtis TIFF Interview Spectrum Originals adaptation scary movies heist movie BBC One action-comedy scene in color Film Festival indie black comedy genre Hollywood Foreign Press Association Infographic king arthur Mindy Kaling space worst movies comic adventure vs. TV Superheroes italian CBS All Access NBA First Reviews batman toronto know your critic Photos DC Comics classics OWN Pixar critics period drama Rom-Com justice league Pacific Islander 2018 Super Bowl Musicals Showtime Toys obituary Red Carpet deadpool movie Pop New York Comic Con President medical drama streamig WarnerMedia gangster all-time interviews Black Mirror SXSW 2022 Food Network TV movies screen actors guild wonder woman target franchise PlayStation Reality Competition HBO Max strong female leads true crime disaster Neflix festivals streaming movies ViacomCBS trailers Heroines FXX Schedule The Witch reviews Cartoon Network Reality ESPN Paramount Network hispanic quibi Family Epix Trophy Talk james bond witnail Paramount Pictures Universal Pictures remakes 94th Oscars Nominations IMDb TV dragons fresh NBC sports IFC Films Rock Cannes BAFTA Captain marvel streaming scorecard spinoff SXSW directors blockbusters japan Awards blockbuster BET stand-up comedy 20th Century Fox GoT MSNBC Song of Ice and Fire Trailer 007 Mystery BBC Freeform TCA Winter 2020 children's TV Hallmark joker Pop TV Summer crime spanish language slasher latino Comic-Con@Home 2021 Sundance Now Instagram Live independent nature 45 TruTV Endgame criterion casting comedies Awards Tour LGBTQ A&E french 73rd Emmy Awards Election docuseries Amazon science fiction Disney Plus Music police drama Nat Geo composers AMC Plus Elton John sitcom Opinion Arrowverse Exclusive Video Peacock Podcast Walt Disney Pictures TV renewals Stephen King The Purge pirates of the caribbean Biopics rt archives Paramount international concert FOX young adult Bravo harry potter crossover free movies art house transformers Marvel Television lord of the rings Spring TV Academy Awards Starz USA Network Hallmark Christmas movies Legendary Winners live action First Look TBS TCA 2017 Holidays 99% mutant Holiday cops critic resources comic books aapi Christmas kong IFC war legend halloween tv TCA Awards cults ABC Signature serial killer Columbia Pictures dreamworks Disney streaming service Brie Larson Comics on TV DirecTV golden globes Video Games Country Sundance TV Watching Series GLAAD Wes Anderson Animation Netflix Christmas movies Hear Us Out Marvel Studios American Society of Cinematographers zero dark thirty Winter TV Warner Bros. summer TV rt labs Rocky Amazon Studios Hulu LGBT live event Fantasy Spike canceled Baby Yoda psycho Apple TV+ ratings Sony Pictures Star Wars Rocketman Pet Sematary award winner Binge Guide versus Shudder thriller festival anime Chernobyl sopranos marvel cinematic universe superman Crackle Focus Features laika 93rd Oscars natural history Emmy Nominations MTV screenings television Broadway Premiere Dates robots ABC Family biography black Ovation stop motion Comedy vampires Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Year in Review HBO Go series San Diego Comic-Con video on demand 71st Emmy Awards rt labs critics edition SundanceTV suspense Prime Video foreign comic book movies Emmys ITV binge social media summer TV preview OneApp Paramount Plus parents golden globe awards theme song chucky emmy awards Sony debate Disney+ Disney Plus worst reboot scary Apple DC streaming service spider-man godzilla basketball singing competition Adult Swim Sundance E3 rotten Nickelodeon cancelled TV series Television Academy Vudu Best Actress 2017 mcc Star Wars Celebration Black History Month Pirates leaderboard high school Ghostbusters cancelled TV shows new zealand Mudbound broadcast cancelled tv talk superhero cars Writers Guild of America new star wars movies 72 Emmy Awards unscripted toy story WGN crime drama boxoffice films stoner 24 frames Kids & Family Geeked Week YouTube Premium MGM indiana jones jurassic park Action VOD NYCC Lifetime Christmas movies Tokyo Olympics TV Land Tags: Comedy 2015 DC Universe YA Horror discovery hist posters Lifetime 2019 book adaptation razzies TCM South by Southwest Film Festival Oscars VICE spain TNT Turner Classic Movies political drama canceled TV shows Fall TV werewolf Dark Horse Comics Travel Channel Trivia twilight BET Awards El Rey dceu Drama richard e. Grant National Geographic USA Disney Channel a nightmare on elm street MCU best DGA Marathons FX on Hulu The Academy hollywood biopic Mary poppins Best Actor Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Best and Worst scene in color series mission: impossible nbcuniversal spanish zombies revenge YouTube 2021 Shondaland Lucasfilm Esquire CNN Sci-Fi Image Comics talk show nfl name the review cooking Ellie Kemper politics comiccon Extras book 21st Century Fox X-Men supernatural summer preview spider-verse facebook Musical BBC America historical drama fast and furious TLC 1990s obi wan Mary Poppins Returns The CW Netflix news Syfy FX Fargo miniseries rotten movies we love dexter Tomatazos Mary Tyler Moore telelvision universal monsters Amazon Prime football CMT halloween teaser hidden camera TCA Crunchyroll cartoon Women's History Month VH1 Apple TV Plus PBS dramedy ID 90s comic book movie japanese Funimation Sneak Peek dogs ghosts Discovery Channel asian-american Star Trek new york Britbox Universal APB PaleyFest royal family 4/20 aliens adenture elevated horror Calendar feel good documentary travel Comedy Central A24 Indigenous Avengers Box Office rom-coms archives Polls and Games documentaries Fox Searchlight CBS renewed TV shows sag awards Martial Arts Oscar australia Fox News CW Seed child's play technology hispanic heritage month animated cancelled television marvel comics mob 79th Golden Globes Awards saw romantic comedy green book breaking bad Lionsgate Anna Paquin anthology sequel venice spy thriller prank mockumentary 2016 Television Critics Association HBO Western game of thrones satire RT21 video Comic Book E! Teen SDCC blaxploitation Grammys Disney cats 2020 The Walking Dead Logo olympics Pride Month kids south america GIFs See It Skip It dc Masterpiece Amazon Prime Video AMC christmas movies movies Quiz Valentine's Day Character Guide History YouTube Red Superheroe diversity Cosplay Native target scene in color dark Tubi zombie Tarantino Tumblr psychological thriller kaiju what to watch Certified Fresh RT History romance HFPA popular Classic Film boxing Set visit game show sequels die hard king kong monster movies finale Thanksgiving