Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: It's Not Easy Being Green Lantern

Plus, Mr. Popper's Penguins never takes flight.

by | June 17, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a hero with a power ring (Green Lantern, starring Ryan Reynolds and Blake Lively) and some wacky waddlers (Mr. Popper’s Penguins, starring Jim Carrey and Carla Gugino). What do the critics have to say?

Green Lantern

26%

With the towering exceptions of Batman and Superman, DC’s stable of superheroes haven’t fared as well on the big screen as Marvel’s. And critics say the publisher’s latest adaptation, Green Lantern won’t reverse the trend – it’s a generic, special effects-heavy effort that lacks interesting characters and a compelling script. Ryan Reynolds plays Hal Jordan, a brash test pilot who’s recruited by the Green Lantern Corps to join their crusade against evil in the universe. With the help of a power ring, Jordan is granted a number of superpowers – but can he overcome his fears in time to defeat a marauding army of evil? The pundits say Green Lantern has a few decent set pieces and moments of loony humor, but mostly, it gets bogged down in a too-complicated backstory and never exhibits enough of a singular personality to be truly compelling.

Mr. Popper’s Penguins

47%

It’s summer, so spending time in an air-conditioned theater in the company of some Antarctic residents seems like a decent idea, right? Unfortunately, critics say Mr. Popper’s Penguins is mostly lukewarm stuff; it’s got a committed performance from Jim Carrey that’s undone by a lot of mediocre physical comedy. Based upon the Newbury Award-winning children’s classic, Mr Popper’s Penguins stars Carrey as a divorced businessman who inherits six penguins; soon after turning his apartment into a polar playground, he comes to learn a thing or two about responsibility and family. The pundits say Carrey gives it his all, and the birds are cute, but Mr. Popper’s Penguins is mostly a formulaic family comedy with some so-so slapstick and an overdone message.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Buck, a documentary portrait of real-life horse whisperer Buck Brannaman, is a 90 percent.

  • My Afternoons with Marguerite, starring Gérard Depardieu in a drama about a friendship between a simple man and a frail old lady, is at 85 percent.

  • R, a drama about a man serving time in Denmark’s toughest prison, is at 80 percent.

  • Page One: Inside the New York Times, a doc about a year in the life of the nation’s paper of record, is at 78 percent.

  • Jig, a doc that follows many of the participants in the Irish Dancing World Championships, is at 65 percent.

  • Angel of Evil, a biopic of one of Italy’s most notorious criminals, is at 61 percent.

  • Kidnapped, a drama about a family held captive by a trio of robbers, is at 36 percent.

  • The Art of Getting By, starring Freddie Highmore and Emma Roberts as a pair of troubled teens who find common ground, is at 20 percent.

Tag Cloud

DGA New York Comic Con Song of Ice and Fire blockbuster Turner Classic Movies Rock dc DC Comics nfl social media name the review President 24 frames IFC latino indie Rom-Com TCM award winner American Society of Cinematographers CW Seed chucky cooking rom-coms Paramount Universal Pictures Women's History Month worst natural history crime drama BAFTA toy story Anna Paquin royal family WarnerMedia mockumentary ABC Signature dreamworks genre 2016 Creative Arts Emmys Tokyo Olympics Sundance TV Classic Film telelvision Pet Sematary Binge Guide Country stop motion NYCC godzilla hispanic heritage month The Arrangement 79th Golden Globes Awards talk show The Walking Dead DC Universe 2018 Sci-Fi Travel Channel Winter TV The Witch 73rd Emmy Awards live event gangster Trailer scary slashers true crime directors Emmy Nominations prank comic book movies Masterpiece Fall TV Comedy Nickelodeon Legendary robots Hallmark TCA 2017 leaderboard Tags: Comedy OneApp VOD Stephen King comedies obi wan Fox News ITV vs. monster movies Kids & Family FOX news mob MCU boxoffice Teen Winners Pop TV spider-man heist movie emmy awards best richard e. Grant jamie lee curtis rt labs Shondaland spinoff PBS Apple cancelled TV shows Musical Countdown TCA Winter 2020 Bravo Academy Awards target medical drama festival video on demand Amazon Prime Summer TIFF OWN doctor who based on movie Endgame Extras dexter Ovation Comic-Con@Home 2021 VH1 sequels Arrowverse japanese obituary ratings Year in Review sopranos Superheroe laika Tarantino book Logo documentaries Video Games docudrama Adult Swim DirecTV Thanksgiving Interview Brie Larson Hulu target scene in color GLAAD political drama golden globe awards renewed TV shows Television Academy scene in color film series dramedy live action scary movies theme song Premiere Dates 71st Emmy Awards Horror FX venice Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Elton John series Funimation video IFC Films Infographic LGBT SundanceTV Freeform TCA zombie Character Guide SDCC finale Walt Disney Pictures Oscar halloween tv hollywood breaking bad deadpool Trophy Talk Turner Avengers psychological thriller trophy scene in color Focus Features summer TV know your critic Disney streaming service Marvel Television sports Native ID AMC Plus teaser space Disney Plus game show composers Spike canceled marvel comics scorecard aapi Reality festivals joker USA Network blaxploitation Baby Yoda toronto Cannes rt labs critics edition concert kids Image Comics Nominations fast and furious Tumblr science fiction diversity cancelled TV series Netflix Christmas movies cancelled television australia Biopics Calendar Star Trek ESPN CMT LGBTQ Showtime Watching Series strong female leads spanish language Animation dragons Mindy Kaling Peacock Alien The Walt Disney Company cars cartoon art house USA book adaptation RT21 comic book movie Acorn TV DC streaming service psycho The Academy Certified Fresh Wes Anderson BBC rotten HFPA Awards Tour elevated horror GoT First Reviews christmas movies black comedy stoner WGN TruTV pirates of the caribbean football YouTube Premium Holiday First Look adventure Black History Month movies Red Carpet legend FXX Apple TV+ facebook 1990s IMDb TV VICE Marvel Studios Sony Pictures BBC One BBC America summer TV preview documentary Paramount Pictures cults MSNBC archives mcc twilight TV Land PaleyFest comics Chernobyl Super Bowl green book The CW Polls and Games batman 99% sequel superman anthology reboot streaming Sundance Sneak Peek A&E women Lifetime Christmas movies dceu casting japan 2019 Cosplay Heroines HBO james bond international CNN Geeked Week Britbox crime ViacomCBS anime Cartoon Network Trivia Valentine's Day spy thriller Paramount Network El Rey Nat Geo Starz romance Syfy Set visit foreign hispanic independent Spring TV 72 Emmy Awards justice league kaiju feel good children's TV Superheroes saw halloween Vudu TV renewals TV Ellie Kemper reviews Best and Worst Martial Arts new york Mystery Emmys quibi TNT San Diego Comic-Con satire razzies 93rd Oscars 2020 Dark Horse Comics streamig Toys Instagram Live discovery vampires Spectrum Originals Columbia Pictures indiana jones new star wars movies History broadcast nature classics 20th Century Fox remakes Rocky Marathons dark rotten movies we love Comedy Central Crunchyroll witnail Mudbound comiccon Awards critics south america Lifetime Photos comic Disney screen actors guild Oscars adenture movie BET Awards wonder woman Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Hear Us Out mission: impossible Best Picture CBS superhero tv talk Quiz Ghostbusters Action Western Lucasfilm Podcast 90s SXSW romantic comedy MTV Drama BET binge olympics AMC Box Office Epix X-Men Prime Video mutant all-time Captain marvel Amazon Studios Television Critics Association Tomatazos Sundance Now Grammys king arthur asian-american Hollywood Foreign Press Association scene in color series Crackle child's play Pirates action-comedy Tubi Mary Tyler Moore Star Wars Celebration Comic Book kong transformers Apple TV Plus politics young adult Shudder YouTube Fargo TV One singing competition films Film spain Schedule FX on Hulu crime thriller Warner Bros. television black Lionsgate NBA spider-verse italian 2017 jurassic park docuseries Neflix Food Network ABC 007 boxing Mary poppins Holidays die hard Exclusive Video popular franchise 21st Century Fox a nightmare on elm street The Purge South by Southwest Film Festival revenge unscripted adaptation Fantasy TV movies Star Wars animated golden globes criterion historical drama Election Indigenous Amazon hidden camera aliens biography 2015 zombies Disney Channel Pop Rocketman trailers travel what to watch Family RT History E3 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards hist new zealand police drama debate serial killer stand-up comedy rt archives french posters Netflix comic books marvel cinematic universe SXSW 2022 TCA Awards suspense technology werewolf Writers Guild of America ghosts YA 2021 Fox Searchlight versus A24 Best Actor Esquire MGM Opinion Broadway CBS All Access sag awards Sony free movies Reality Competition universal monsters game of thrones canceled TV shows TBS period drama HBO Go supernatural crossover cats fresh Pixar NBC blockbusters cancelled HBO Max Hallmark Christmas movies miniseries king kong YouTube Red Best Director Best Actress E! worst movies streaming movies Mary Poppins Returns slasher Amazon Prime Video disaster Universal Music cinemax thriller summer preview Pacific Islander high school zero dark thirty lord of the rings basketball ABC Family Christmas Musicals screenings National Geographic PlayStation biopic See It Skip It APB Discovery Channel 94th Oscars war sitcom GIFs harry potter Black Mirror dogs 4/20 Disney+ Disney Plus critic resources 45 nbcuniversal Paramount Plus parents TLC Marvel Pride Month Film Festival spanish Comics on TV cops interviews