Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Cars 2 is Stuck in Neutral

Plus, Bad Teacher doesn't quite pass the test.

by | June 24, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got animated autos (Cars 2, with voice work from Owen Wilson and Larry the Cable Guy) and execrable educators (Bad Teacher, starring Cameron Diaz and Justin Timberlake). What do the critics have to say?

Cars 2


Pixar’s output has been so good for so long that it seemed unfathomable that one of the studio’s films would get a less-than-rapturous response from critics. Well, all good things must come to an end, and that now includes Pixar’s streak of Certified Fresh releases; critics say Cars 2 looks fantastic, but the studio’s trademark storytelling prowess and character development is MIA here, and the result is a decent animated feature that must count as a big disappointment, given the standards that Pixar has set for itself. This time out, Lightning McQueen (voiced by Owen Wilson) is off to a big international race with his best buddy Mater (Larry the Cable Guy) in, ahem, tow. Soon, though Mater finds himself in the middle of a secret espionage mission. Will he still be able to help Lightning in his quest to be the fastest car in the world? The pundits say Cars 2 is visually delightful, but its plot is uninspired, and it’s over reliant on gags and shtick instead of an interesting story. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run though Pixar’s filmography in chronological order.)

Bad Teacher


There’s no shortage of tasteless Hollywood comedies in the world, but it’s rare that a movie gets criticized for not being tasteless enough. However, such is the case with Bad Teacher, which critics say has moments of raunchy hilarity but doesn’t quite fulfill its outrageous premise. Cameron Diaz stars as Elizabeth, a boozy, wildly inappropriate middle school teacher who’s looking for a sugar daddy so she can leave her job behind. Elizabeth falls for a hunky substitute teacher (Justin Timberlake), but she’s got a rival for his affections, and soon, her scheming and bad behavior starts to affect the whole school. The pundits say Bad Teacher benefits from a sharp performance from Diaz, but it sags in spots, and it’s never quite as wild and transgressive as it should be.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Video Games Star Trek Awards Box Office Thanksgiving vampires Crackle BET Year in Review American Society of Cinematographers Election TIFF Superheroes Disney Channel Winners zombie Marvel 21st Century Fox Ghostbusters Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt ABC Family 24 frames Photos based on movie Nominations docudrama Warner Bros. Pirates Teen Premiere Dates Martial Arts DC Universe romance Set visit Winter TV science fiction HBO IFC FOX Musical Pop cops Podcast Mystery Adult Swim Certified Fresh The CW Nat Geo Best and Worst Schedule USA Interview Comic Book political drama dceu Fox News Music RT History Syfy technology Ellie Kemper medical drama Horror travel Extras Calendar Oscars FX Opinion Nickelodeon transformers CNN SDCC Polls and Games Fantasy thriller Countdown X-Men TCM TCA PaleyFest Freeform TNT Writers Guild of America comiccon El Rey Mary Tyler Moore Cosplay talk show Hulu what to watch Biopics sitcom Musicals Action Western Fall TV BBC America Spring TV discovery psycho Tumblr Toys CBS All Access GLAAD Reality Mindy Kaling 007 Red Carpet Rom-Com 2015 ABC Esquire VICE President TV Land crime TLC dramedy LGBTQ Rocky GIFs Netflix TCA 2017 Tomatazos Comedy Central social media OWN APB Character Guide BBC crime drama NBC harry potter politics police drama TBS Summer MTV Amazon Lionsgate DC Comics Sneak Peek Reality Competition Comedy Showtime History Trailer 45 E3 period drama PBS Sundance Valentine's Day VH1 Emmys biography GoT sports cooking serial killer boxoffice TruTV singing competition TV 2016 The Arrangement diversity Holidays Lifetime ITV crime thriller MSNBC Disney Starz CBS AMC justice league Bravo Kids & Family Rock Country war E! cats Drama Paramount Super Bowl 2017 ESPN NYCC Watching Series Star Wars historical drama binge FXX dc DirecTV CMT adventure Logo Food Network Infographic composers cinemax Sci-Fi Masterpiece Animation Cartoon Network Grammys WGN A&E aliens supernatural Marathons Universal First Look YA Dark Horse Comics SundanceTV Trivia