6 Horror Legends That Inspired Feature Films

Whether you like your men Wicker or Slender, these terrifying tall tales and urban legends have made the leap into Hollywood pop culture.

by | April 18, 2019 | Comments

The Curse of La Llorona hits theaters this week, giving us our first major studio adaptation of the eponymous Mexican folktale also known as “the weeping woman.” Horror master Guillermo del Toro borrowed heavily from the Mexican legend for his 2013 film Mama, but this James Wan-produced scare-fest centers solely on the spirit who, it is said, tragically killed her children, committed suicide, and vowed to terrorize mothers as her eternal retribution.

The movie joins a long list of horror films based on legends (among them, one literally called Urban Legends… don’t pretend you don’t remember it). If you like your horror based on a kinda-maybe-sort-coulda-been true story – or at least the story your buddies and grandma used to scare you with – look no further than these wicked legend-based horror movies that came before La Llorona. 


The Wicker Man

Origin: Pagan Mythology

Adaptations: The Wicker Man (1973), The Wicker Man (2006)

Which Wicker Man should you watch? The original 1973 film starring the late Christopher Lee – that treasure trove of haunting imagery with its dagger-to-your-heart ending? Or the Nicolas Cage “not the bees!” version? Either or, depending on whether you’ve got a hunger for shivers or… for munchies. Both films relied heavily on the Druid (Celtic Pagan) practice of burning a Wicker statue in effigy – which might not have actually been a practice at all. The idea of making a sacrifice by burning a giant effigy was first documented in a single sentence by Julius Caesar circa 50 BC, but modern scholars have become increasingly skeptical. Still, the image remains scary AF.

Origin: Irish Folklore

Memorable Adaptations: The Leprechaun Franchise

The 20th-century leprechaun, as seen on a box of Lucky Charms, is a far cry from the devilish and sometimes benevolent creature you will find in Irish folklore. Tricksters and hoarders of jewels, leprechauns are the supposed offspring of demon (evil spirit) and fairy (angelic spirit) couplings. Because of their equal capacity for good and evil, Celtic mythology is littered with examples of both just and wicked deeds committed by the magical creatures. Warwick Davis originated the role in the legendary B-movie Leprechaun series and continued with it until the franchise rebooted in 2014. According to Davis, the In the Hood installments were the most successful of the direct-to-video efforts. If you’ve witnessed Davis rapping in the finale of Leprechaun in the Hood, you will understand why.

La Llorona (The Weeping Woman)

Origin: Mexican Folklore

Memorable Adaptations: Mama, The Curse of La Llorona

At some point in every mythology, there’s a tale of female, particularly maternal, vengeance — think Dionysus or Medea (the Greek myth, not the Tyler Perry version). Even the original Friday the 13th can be traced back to a mother scorned. In The Curse of La Llorona, a mother drowns her children in a jealous rage to seek revenge on her cheating husband. Reckoning with what she did, she commits suicide, only to be denied entry to the afterlife, cursed to roam the earth weeping, drowning children, and tormenting mothers for all her days. It’s a true word-of-mouth legend, unable to be traced back to any known story or event, and director Michael Chaves told us, “It can be difficult to manage the nuances of it being an oral tradition. It’s hard to pin down what is the right version. So you [go] through all of it to find [the] core experience that so many people grew up on, [what was] told to them as kids. That’s what we wanted to bring on screen.”

The Bell Witch

Origin: Southern American Folklore

Memorable Adaptations: The Blair Witch Project, Book of Shadows – Blair Witch 2Blair Witch

As the legend goes, the Bell family was visited by a spirit in early 1817, bringing reports of spooky black dogs and shadowy figures. If the strangeness stopped there, we might not have included it on our list, but after the first Bell Witch hauntings, there have been countless reported reappearances with similar details often coming from unrelated parties miles apart. What to do with such a creepy story? Make a movie, of course – and cheaply. The makers of The Blair Witch Project used the spooky lore, low-budget scares, and perhaps the savviest early internet marketing campaign to create one of the most lucrative movies ever.

The Amityville Horror

Origin: American folklore 

Memorable Adaptations: The Amityville Horror Franchise

Amityville lies somewhere between folklore and urban legend, but the inexplicable twists and turns surrounding the early ’70s supernatural events that inspired the Amityville movies have cemented them as the granddaddy of lore-based horror cinema. Spanning 23 films over 40 years, The Amityville Horror series chronicles the 1974 haunting first investigated by famed paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren, though many debate the accuracy of the Warrens’ story. As the original story goes, Ronald DeFeo Jr. shot and killed six members of his family at home in Amityville, New York, and since then, strange occurrences – mostly focused around the Lutz family that hired the Warrens – have plagued the house where it all went down.

Slender man

Origin: Creepy-pasta/American folklore

Memorable Adaptations: Beware the Slenderman, Slender Man

This one might be a stretch (forgive us), but Slender Man has morphed into modern-day folklore. The Slender Man is a work of pure fiction about a tall and, well, slender spirit that calls others to murder in his name. One of the first documented instances of digital folklore, originating in online message boards, the Slender Man was blamed for directing teenagers to commit suicide, murder, and commit assault on each other indiscriminately. The most notorious incident was the Waukesha, Wisconsin stabbing, in which a pair of 12-year-olds meticulously planned the murder of a friend by stabbing; the victim did thankfully survive, but the incident made national headlines. Of all the tales on our list, the legend of Slender Man is the only one accused in court of turning pre-teens into murderers.

The Curse of La Llorona is in theaters April 22.

Tag Cloud

Marvel Hear Us Out binge cats 71st Emmy Awards witnail stop motion ghosts Schedule Amazon BBC America Apple TV+ DC Comics Columbia Pictures cancelled TV shows war Western 73rd Emmy Awards TCA Winter 2020 cancelled TV series Nickelodeon Amazon Studios anime golden globes miniseries reboot Pacific Islander mission: impossible godzilla true crime superhero obituary New York Comic Con OWN Ghostbusters mockumentary WarnerMedia Marvel Studios Universal Freeform CMT Character Guide Netflix Christmas movies PlayStation YA TV Summer football olympics comiccon Tomatazos Brie Larson nature joker Syfy Ovation critics Discovery Channel diversity unscripted NBC halloween tv IFC Films American Society of Cinematographers classics thriller zombies mob halloween international The CW Image Comics Trophy Talk ViacomCBS ITV Winners Black History Month Video Games monster movies Nat Geo asian-american TLC Interview E3 Pixar The Academy GoT 2015 Paramount Plus green book vs. fresh San Diego Comic-Con dark Mary Tyler Moore canceled natural history archives robots psychological thriller razzies Extras young adult cinemax hispanic MCU sitcom Pirates X-Men Stephen King telelvision italian Musical rotten trailers free movies Broadway 90s BBC One golden globe awards Teen SDCC cooking FOX movie indie cops Animation 2017 criterion slasher boxoffice suspense Fall TV gangster VOD spanish Horror based on movie Endgame political drama Super Bowl supernatural The Arrangement CNN Rocketman women Holidays boxing GLAAD legend DC streaming service cancelled comic book movies TCA 2017 casting ABC Signature Elton John Television Academy children's TV twilight richard e. Grant travel south america Fox News Box Office renewed TV shows festival what to watch Esquire black The Walt Disney Company aapi kids Legendary hollywood Shondaland hidden camera comic streaming Mudbound kaiju Mary Poppins Returns Peacock Starz dceu rotten movies we love Country spain aliens Podcast Awards Tour President tv talk satire Marathons 45 Thanksgiving scary TV Land 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards space Masterpiece reviews Britbox canceled TV shows blockbuster independent screen actors guild Disney streaming service comic book movie BBC latino all-time saw Binge Guide sequels Turner Classic Movies Action versus Comedy jurassic park Opinion Acorn TV king kong sag awards docudrama ratings jamie lee curtis Ellie Kemper dexter Calendar Disney king arthur See It Skip It award winner Crackle hispanic heritage month First Reviews TV movies Kids & Family SXSW marvel comics The Purge book adaptation facebook OneApp new zealand romance FX Comic-Con@Home 2021 know your critic Family FXX batman Creative Arts Emmys biography name the review critic resources die hard films comics Chernobyl Film wonder woman slashers Sony Pictures breaking bad GIFs Film Festival transformers Certified Fresh RT21 Travel Channel Cartoon Network Song of Ice and Fire DGA WGN Fantasy IFC spy thriller revenge 99% Lifetime Avengers Turner E! fast and furious french Apple The Walking Dead teaser Paramount royal family A24 kong new star wars movies Women's History Month IMDb TV NBA elevated horror concert Disney Channel adventure Holiday Food Network Tumblr period drama dragons 21st Century Fox spider-verse scorecard cults technology TruTV Alien TBS PBS werewolf Comic Book Countdown Paramount Network stoner singing competition scary movies TV One toronto historical drama Oscars serial killer sports worst movies 2021 rom-coms directors Grammys Amazon Prime Video target quibi YouTube Premium Universal Pictures christmas movies Warner Bros. Walt Disney Pictures universal monsters politics HBO Max Comedy Central documentaries A&E medical drama Sundance Now Tarantino ESPN cancelled television 007 Amazon Prime science fiction franchise mutant Funimation Mary poppins social media cartoon Tubi Sundance TV USA Network Superheroe television Trivia Disney Plus Premiere Dates TCA Awards 93rd Oscars Sci-Fi comedies AMC Plus ABC Family rt labs critics edition movies Reality Competition Tokyo Olympics Mindy Kaling feel good cars Pride Month Adult Swim Fox Searchlight Academy Awards VICE Valentine's Day Best and Worst dc spider-man National Geographic basketball Photos Christmas book Cannes Set visit strong female leads discovery heist movie Crunchyroll Black Mirror crossover Dark Horse Comics SundanceTV Logo Pop Lionsgate lord of the rings 2018 2020 remakes Rock Netflix anthology DC Universe laika composers live event Disney+ Disney Plus TIFF Writers Guild of America nfl harry potter AMC Music Watching Series History crime art house japanese stand-up comedy psycho Neflix Shudder dramedy Television Critics Association australia TNT sopranos CW Seed foreign Spectrum Originals worst Election doctor who Emmy Nominations Sneak Peek spanish language BET Hallmark Christmas movies new york CBS Heroines FX on Hulu theme song high school USA Apple TV Plus best animated news Star Trek crime drama 20th Century Fox Captain marvel BET Awards genre Lucasfilm TCM CBS All Access documentary venice 1990s TCA ABC deadpool posters Epix police drama james bond HBO Go spinoff zombie Marvel Television 2016 prank APB zero dark thirty Showtime Musicals Hulu 72 Emmy Awards Classic Film adaptation MTV LGBT pirates of the caribbean Rom-Com blockbusters Pop TV series YouTube Arrowverse Biopics comic books Instagram Live PaleyFest First Look black comedy Drama Spring TV Nominations YouTube Red Cosplay dogs festivals talk show 24 frames hist RT History mcc Bravo Martial Arts BAFTA ID Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Star Wars 2019 Wes Anderson Trailer NYCC toy story screenings 4/20 superman indiana jones marvel cinematic universe Infographic Winter TV Lifetime Christmas movies Hallmark Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt docuseries LGBTQ justice league popular Toys HBO crime thriller scene in color vampires game show blaxploitation Mystery disaster Anna Paquin debate dreamworks Polls and Games game of thrones sequel Pet Sematary Sundance Reality video Red Carpet streaming movies MSNBC Comics on TV emmy awards Spike El Rey biopic live action child's play adenture Rocky Baby Yoda TV renewals rt archives action-comedy Awards The Witch Year in Review DirecTV video on demand Vudu Superheroes Exclusive Video VH1 finale chucky nbcuniversal Emmys Quiz japan rt labs romantic comedy parents a nightmare on elm street