22 Surprising Oscar Snubs

We look at some of the Academy's most noteworthy recent snubs... and the less noteworthy films that were nominated instead.

by | January 30, 2014 | Comments

Oscar Noms and Snubs

It’s an immutable law of Hollywood that there are just never enough Oscar nominations to go around. With this year’s Academy Awards mere weeks away, we decided now would be a perfect time to take our annual look back at some of the many quality movies that missed an opportunity to take home one of the little gold guys — and some that overcame seemingly insurmountable odds to become some of history’s most surprising nominees. Obviously, this is meant to be a conversation starter rather than a complete list, but hey — that’s what the comments are for. What other films undeservedly escaped the Academy’s attention?

The Clan of the Cave Bear

Oscar Nominee for Best Makeup

10%

1986: Sexy cave people club punks and one percenters

Oh Academy, where to start with 1986? You nominated two middling sequels (The Karate Kid, Part II, Poltergeist II), a notorious box-office dud (Pirates), and a goofy caveman movie (The Clan of the Cave Bear). Meanwhile, you snubbed a well-reviewed box office hit with an all star cast (Down and Out in Beverly Hills, starring Nick Nolte, Richard Dreyfuss, and Bette Midler) and a film that made Siskel and Ebert’s list of the best movies of the decade, one that marked the arrival of Gary Oldman as one of cinema’s most dependable actors (Sid & Nancy). But hey, when you get the chance to give some love to Peter Cetera, you’ve got to do it.

NOT NOMINATED FOR A SINGLE OSCAR:


 

Toys

Oscar Nominee for Best Art Direction, Best Costume Design

30%

1992: Chatty crooks, lady ballplayers, and undercover cops get snubbed

Base your movie’s visual aesthetic around the work of Rene Magritte, and you’ve kind of earned yourself a shot at Academy Award nominations for art direction and costume design — so negative reviews notwithstanding, it’s hard to begrudge Barry Levinson’s notorious Robin Williams-led flop Toys its pair of Oscar noms. Along similar lines, while Jean-Jacques Annaud’s adaptation of the Marguerite Duras novel The Lover was critically savaged, it’s certainly lovely to look at, so we don’t have a major problem with its nomination for Best Cinematography. All the same, it’s hard to swallow those honors when some of the year’s best movies — heck, some of the decade’s — were snubbed in 1992, including a cult classic (Reservoir Dogs), a powerfully acted crime thriller with an instant-classic theme song from Dr. Dre and Snoop Dogg (Deep Cover), and a crowd-pleasing smash dramedy with a hit soundtrack (A League of Their Own).

NOT NOMINATED FOR A SINGLE OSCAR:


 

Beethoven’s 2nd

Oscar Nominee for Best Original Song

23%

1993: Bill Murray helps redefine the romantic comedy. Oscar prefers big dogs.

For the most part, the 66th Academy Awards were bereft of egregiously silly nominees, with the exception of the schmaltzy ballad “The Day I Fall in Love,” the love theme from the barely-remembered doggie-com Beethoven’s 2nd. Still, it’s not unfair to ask what the Academy was thinking when it failed to nominate Robert De Niro’s critically acclaimed directorial debut A Bronx Tale, a coming-of-age drama loaded with standout performances. It was a box office flop, you say? Fine: what about Groundhog Day, then? Not only is it a near-perfect romantic comedy, it also features one of Bill Murray’s finest performances, and was a decent-sized hit to boot. (Oh, right. Comedies never get nominated.)

NOT NOMINATED FOR A SINGLE OSCAR:


 

Waterworld

Oscar Nominee for Best Sound Mixing

46%

1995: Mutant fish guy tops bank robbers, Hollywood hooligans

Though it was an infamous flop upon its release, Waterworld has its retroactive defenders, who value the sheer audacity of Kevin Costner’s expensive, expansive sci-fi epic. Still, it’s kind of shocking in retrospect that Waterworld got a nod from the Academy, while both Get Shorty and Heat were sidelined come Oscar time. The former is a deft Hollywood satire featuring sharp performances from such old pros as John Travolta, Gene Hackman, and Danny DeVito, while the latter contains riveting set pieces and a much-ballyhooed showdown between Robert De Niro and Al Pacino. You’d think either of these movies would have been nominated for something, but you’d be wrong.

NOT NOMINATED FOR A SINGLE OSCAR:


 

Patch Adams

Oscar Nominee for Best Original Musical or Comedy Score

22%

1998: Max Fisher and the Dude: non. A doctor in a clown nose: oui.

Okay, sure, we all remember the chorus of that Aerosmith song from Armageddon, and we’re willing to concede the sound and visual effects nominations the movie earned. We can even sort of understand the Academy’s nod to Patch Adams for its score; after all, it’s a big part of the movie’s decidedly saccharine aftertaste. That said, was there really no room for any recognition for Rushmore‘s script or production design, or for The Big Lebowski‘s fantastic ensemble cast? Fine, we get it: Wes Anderson wasn’t as a big a name yet, the Coens had Fargo to live up to, and the Academy has never been particularly generous to comedies.

NOT NOMINATED FOR A SINGLE OSCAR:


 

Hollow Man

Oscar Nominee for Best Visual Effects

27%

2000: Awesome mutants! Music nerds! Invisible pervs?

Alright, we’ll admit it: the visual effects in Hollow Man were pretty cool. You know what other movie had good visual effects? A little flick called X-Men, which was a much bigger hit with audiences and critics. And while the Oscar-nominated 102 Dalmations is dimly remembered in the minds of movie buffs, High Fidelity is as adored now as it was in 2000. And given its endlessly quotable dialogue, you’re telling us High Fidelity didn’t deserve a Best Adapted Screenplay nod?

NOT NOMINATED FOR A SINGLE OSCAR:


 

Click

Oscar Nominee for Best Makeup

34%

2006: The Sandman bests 007, Denzel, and the Wachowskis

Action-packed and surprisingly weighty, Casino Royale reignited the James Bond franchise and was one of the best-received 007 flicks in years. So naturally, the Academy took no notice. Likewise, Inside Man was a strong thriller with several eminently nominatable actors (Denzel Washington, Jodie Foster, and Christopher Plummer among them), and V for Vendetta was a feast for the eyes and ears. Instead, the Academy gave nods to a so-so Adam Sandler film (Click) and a forgettable disaster movie remake (Poseidon).

NOT NOMINATED FOR A SINGLE OSCAR:


 

Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen

Oscar Nominee for Best Visual Effects

20%

2009: A Transformers movie gets nominated. Let that sink in.

Effects-heavy sci-fi adventures are pretty commonly honored in the technical categories, so Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen‘s nomination for Sound Mixing wasn’t a big shock to anyone. What’s probably more surprising is that Sam Rockwell’s thoughtful performance in another sci-fi film, Duncan Jones’s critically acclaimed debut Moon, went overlooked, especially in a year that proved — with the nomination of District 9 for Best Picture — that the Academy wasn’t averse to modestly budgeted films of the genre. Then there’s The Damned United, which could have easily replaced a couple of entries in the Best Adapted Screenplay category. Throw in the curiously absent Studio Ghibli film Ponyo, and you’ve got yourself a solid list of potential nominees that would have given their competition a run for their money. Alas, we’re left with the “Oscar-nominated Transformers franchise.”

NOT NOMINATED FOR A SINGLE OSCAR:


 

Jackass Presents: Bad Grandpa

Oscar Nominee for Best Makeup and Hairstyling

61%

2013: We’re still stunned that Bad Grandpa got nominated

Nothing against Johnny Knoxville or his frequently funny Jackass series, but it does seem unfair that this year’s franchise spinoff Bad Grandpa gets to put “Oscar nominee” after its name while critically esteemed releases such as Blue Is the Warmest Color, The Butler, and Enough Said came away empty-handed. And sure, Grandpa‘s nomination comes in the critic-proof Best Makeup and Hairstyling category, which also includes room for the widely reviled The Lone Ranger — but one of Ranger‘s nominations came in the Best Visual Effects category, which somehow excluded the often jaw-droppingly cool Pacific Rim.

NOT NOMINATED FOR A SINGLE OSCAR:


 

Take a look through the rest of our Awards Tour coverage for the latest news and photo galleries leading up to this weekend’s Academy Awards.

Finally, here’s the trailer for one of the most memorable Oscar nominees from recent years — 2007 Best Makeup contender Norbit:

Written by Ryan Fujitani, Jeff Giles, and Tim Ryan.

Tag Cloud

Infographic Thanksgiving Teen stand-up comedy Lifetime Trailer Summer TLC Warner Bros. The Walking Dead Comedy Central latino Turner cancelled TV shows superhero reviews Podcast CBS sequels sitcom Sundance Now GIFs Drama Kids & Family italian HBO Go fast and furious A24 Winter TV Nickelodeon crime Superheroes Cannes documentary 71st Emmy Awards hispanic Mary Poppins Returns FXX emmy awards The Witch IFC werewolf FOX halloween mutant worst discovery free movies Horror spanish mission: impossible VICE Emmy Nominations Hallmark Marathons football Mary Tyler Moore cartoon cooking Christmas LGBT dc See It Skip It LGBTQ concert jamie lee curtis joker crossover biography theme song Calendar Crackle science fiction VH1 Oscars Sneak Peek best GoT news SundanceTV adaptation Paramount Ovation Esquire directors kids Extras cancelled Starz Peacock Polls and Games Mary poppins sequel remakes elevated horror Best and Worst spain Marvel Studios Shudder natural history doctor who Stephen King Trophy Talk American Society of Cinematographers DC streaming service National Geographic Writers Guild of America Nominations Grammys diversity satire 45 Vudu child's play crime thriller TNT Sundance TV spider-man RT21 OneApp Country Pride Month teaser thriller Comedy dramedy E3 politics WarnerMedia HBO chucky Emmys franchise blockbuster Disney Tumblr TV renewals NBC based on movie Rocky Martial Arts Music Spring TV History Walt Disney Pictures First Reviews Marvel Television Disney Channel APB Quiz Hear Us Out war renewed TV shows streaming TruTV Family Sony Pictures hollywood 21st Century Fox Super Bowl comiccon Amazon Prime Video Syfy documentaries Cosplay Travel Channel Pop TV films Cartoon Network Mystery Shondaland game of thrones Disney Plus YouTube Red 72 Emmy Awards Film Festival Winners twilight travel scorecard VOD Classic Film BET Avengers Reality The CW Fox Searchlight RT History Sundance Lifetime Christmas movies Universal independent ESPN ITV golden globes Holidays stoner venice PlayStation Biopics book laika comic crime drama cinemax zombies technology 4/20 Photos PaleyFest blaxploitation E! Hallmark Christmas movies obituary composers DGA slashers BBC One cancelled TV series children's TV Spectrum Originals CNN New York Comic Con Amazon Prime nbcuniversal TV Pixar Freeform canceled Watching Series space MTV festival robots Fall TV Tarantino Spike 24 frames medical drama Tomatazos San Diego Comic-Con classics DC Comics scary movies Creative Arts Emmys dragons Funimation Valentine's Day Netflix Christmas movies asian-american Marvel Captain marvel BBC America 20th Century Fox spy thriller TCA halloween tv anthology Interview X-Men finale psycho binge Tubi Columbia Pictures all-time President Mindy Kaling TIFF Showtime Apple TV Plus singing competition Heroines Certified Fresh game show tv talk critics Acorn TV psychological thriller 2015 Britbox revenge what to watch MSNBC Arrowverse green book movies video MCU cults HBO Max versus AMC dceu cars Pop romance batman disaster facebook 2018 Academy Awards reboot Awards Tour Crunchyroll Turner Classic Movies parents Disney+ Disney Plus die hard sports Box Office Holiday period drama political drama Amazon Studios french El Rey The Academy anime transformers NYCC stop motion Song of Ice and Fire The Arrangement Dark Horse Comics SXSW name the review FX on Hulu TV Land Endgame a nightmare on elm street strong female leads BBC 2016 YouTube Premium historical drama Chernobyl OWN TCA Winter 2020 nfl Red Carpet DC Universe miniseries Musicals quibi TCA Awards movie Rock Chilling Adventures of Sabrina universal monsters television BAFTA Ghostbusters animated ghosts Star Trek Apple spinoff Set visit Food Network Year in Review 007 2017 CBS All Access Countdown Adult Swim CW Seed south america Star Wars Reality Competition zombie aliens Nat Geo Mudbound Brie Larson rotten movies we love christmas movies First Look TCA 2017 Epix Black History Month breaking bad casting foreign docudrama Anna Paquin YA Lucasfilm A&E Hulu Television Critics Association SDCC Logo justice league Apple TV+ Disney streaming service USA Lionsgate indiana jones Film toy story Rom-Com 2019 unscripted supernatural richard e. Grant Comics on TV zero dark thirty talk show toronto worst movies Pet Sematary Schedule Binge Guide indie The Purge Elton John FX nature Election YouTube Rocketman festivals criterion Ellie Kemper boxoffice harry potter screenings hist Opinion Pirates Sci-Fi video on demand Toys Baby Yoda ABC 2020 USA Network Masterpiece Premiere Dates canceled TV shows TCM mockumentary Musical sag awards Discovery Channel TBS GLAAD rotten Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt spanish language screen actors guild Action cancelled television cats Superheroe IFC Films Comic Book Paramount Network archives BET Awards Amazon Character Guide witnail police drama romantic comedy Trivia dogs comedies ratings comics true crime Awards Bravo Animation cops Fox News vampires award winner WGN Television Academy dark Western PBS social media Netflix serial killer Black Mirror CMT series adventure Women's History Month ABC Family Video Games DirecTV Fantasy