Showdowns

Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher: Who Makes Better Mindbending Blockbusters?

Is it the director who gave us Fight Club, The Game, Seven, and Zodiac? Or the one who gave us Memento, Inception, Interstellar, and the upcoming Tenet?

by | July 9, 2020 | Comments

OK, fanboys, we’re getting ready to dodge and duck and block your furious comments as we pit favorites Christopher Nolan and David Fincher against each other in our second director-focused episode of VS. Who is the better mind-bending auteur: The man who delivered the big WTFs with Memento and redefined the superhero movie with the Dark Knight Trilogy? Or the man who laid Mark Zuckerberg out on the table in one of the smartest and most enjoyable dramas of the last 20 years – and also gave us the iconic Fight Club? We’re comparing their performance on the Tomatometer and at the box office, and looking at their characters and biggest moments to decide who comes out on top of the modern directors’ heap.

Of course, if you don’t agree with our choice of winner, let us have it in the comments.


Thumbnail images by ©20th Century Fox Film Corp., Stephen Vaughan/©Warner Bros courtesy Everett Collection

Tag Cloud

Pride Month Watching Series robots Sci-Fi anthology based on movie TV renewals romance Turner Classic Movies mcc social media debate Epix nbcuniversal rotten movies we love razzies stop motion Comics on TV parents mutant king arthur Amazon Prime Video BBC 94th Oscars Apple TV Plus Legendary Discovery Channel Family screen actors guild Polls and Games The Walt Disney Company tv talk crossover Spring TV Tarantino streaming movies YA genre Fox News hollywood Star Wars Arrowverse what to watch mission: impossible jurassic park The Walking Dead independent elevated horror dexter Valentine's Day archives Instagram Live true crime Broadway blockbuster Film Western Masterpiece unscripted nature Exclusive Video politics Binge Guide AMC Plus Image Comics YouTube Premium Rocketman zero dark thirty police drama Crunchyroll Ovation PlayStation comiccon free movies SDCC dark TIFF 2021 Peacock Hear Us Out french television spanish scary movies singing competition South by Southwest Film Festival streamig zombies Anna Paquin 72 Emmy Awards prank 2020 sequels finale Columbia Pictures LGBT halloween ratings HBO Quiz 21st Century Fox Song of Ice and Fire foreign Tags: Comedy Alien anime Emmys space stoner Pet Sematary TV Land stand-up comedy USA Network Drama toy story theme song australia aliens spinoff Teen emmy awards AMC breaking bad Amazon Prime Hallmark Lifetime Christmas movies witnail DC streaming service universal monsters classics canceled TV shows crime thriller Avengers miniseries Tomatazos 2017 cancelled TV shows Animation posters comics strong female leads quibi BET Awards PaleyFest diversity disaster binge Neflix franchise crime movie New York Comic Con italian slashers Hallmark Christmas movies Toys twilight worst telelvision revenge Infographic adventure Fantasy golden globe awards video on demand thriller heist movie TV movies black comedy NBC sports History reviews YouTube Red President dc cancelled television IMDb TV spider-verse Paramount Network scene in color Trailer Television Critics Association superhero Amazon justice league Bravo CBS All Access BBC One Super Bowl Tokyo Olympics zombie sitcom royal family comic books hidden camera feel good laika black target VOD cults game of thrones Martial Arts war biography international Christmas crime drama Reality Competition TCA 2017 Set visit OneApp SundanceTV japanese 90s festival A24 serial killer basketball 1990s popular Best and Worst criterion book adaptation HBO Go Disney+ Disney Plus cinemax fresh king kong HBO Max Best Actress dragons remakes Musicals Winter TV rt archives indiana jones nfl comic book movie Oscars transformers BET Mystery kids all-time SXSW fast and furious Winners vampires olympics VICE discovery wonder woman Disney streaming service Warner Bros. movies critics Star Trek comic psycho high school Paramount Country First Look TBS San Diego Comic-Con ghosts streaming Acorn TV WGN Pop TV Syfy Academy Awards Pixar Elton John rt labs Walt Disney Pictures canceled Netflix Comic-Con@Home 2021 spider-man E! Shondaland Showtime boxing PBS Brie Larson slasher Crackle TCA Winter 2020 chucky X-Men 2016 Horror Pacific Islander MTV 20th Century Fox hist Comedy Central richard e. Grant Musical saw Marvel Television Captain marvel spain MGM monster movies godzilla BAFTA Creative Arts Emmys Biopics trailers DC Universe new york Rocky batman renewed TV shows Sony Pictures cars The Arrangement die hard SXSW 2022 Film Festival rt labs critics edition 99% art house legend Red Carpet 24 frames comic book movies composers Emmy Nominations scorecard DirecTV Sundance See It Skip It Marathons deadpool ABC Family DC Comics 2019 93rd Oscars Trivia CBS OWN Sundance Now worst movies Certified Fresh spy thriller halloween tv Fox Searchlight The CW ABC Signature RT History werewolf Schedule TNT Writers Guild of America ABC Oscar Best Actor 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Sundance TV The Witch Mary poppins Chernobyl adaptation TCA Calendar Vudu Kids & Family sopranos blaxploitation new zealand NBA aapi Mudbound green book spanish language TCM Opinion IFC christmas movies rom-coms ESPN series marvel cinematic universe Summer Amazon Studios BBC America Awards The Academy young adult Thanksgiving hispanic heritage month Starz Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cartoon MSNBC action-comedy concert Esquire E3 kong TruTV video Universal Pictures historical drama APB Universal Turner Holidays Grammys NYCC Tubi suspense lord of the rings 73rd Emmy Awards Cosplay mob LGBTQ Awards Tour Superheroes Best Director Reality Britbox james bond romantic comedy Marvel 71st Emmy Awards Apple documentaries travel marvel comics Lionsgate 79th Golden Globes Awards Logo live action Action Dark Horse Comics Rock supernatural Disney Nickelodeon directors Photos Lifetime child's play women WarnerMedia Mary Poppins Returns Podcast HFPA pirates of the caribbean dogs Cartoon Network dramedy GLAAD Lucasfilm Ellie Kemper 45 scary award winner Prime Video Tumblr ID 2018 japan children's TV live event DGA Stephen King FX on Hulu dceu Mindy Kaling FXX news Holiday reboot Black Mirror versus kaiju boxoffice cops Baby Yoda Interview Music Fall TV USA animated Funimation cancelled TV series 4/20 Sneak Peek documentary south america comedies Travel Channel Election science fiction joker critic resources golden globes Shudder American Society of Cinematographers cooking National Geographic know your critic Freeform Trophy Talk GoT Women's History Month hispanic a nightmare on elm street cats talk show Rom-Com obituary Pirates leaderboard medical drama Nat Geo docudrama Heroines new star wars movies satire TLC FOX Food Network A&E toronto Spectrum Originals TV YouTube mockumentary Black History Month TCA Awards football cancelled technology adenture blockbusters Netflix Christmas movies venice El Rey Extras casting 007 MCU doctor who facebook rotten Paramount Plus ITV Apple TV+ The Purge CW Seed docuseries festivals Hollywood Foreign Press Association Spike trophy political drama screenings Pop biopic Superheroe Comedy dreamworks Mary Tyler Moore ViacomCBS Marvel Studios vs. sag awards Character Guide natural history harry potter Nominations IFC Films Wes Anderson Hulu superman Fargo Ghostbusters name the review VH1 obi wan best films book jamie lee curtis First Reviews Video Games Adult Swim teaser sequel FX Premiere Dates CNN 2015 GIFs Endgame asian-american Classic Film Best Picture Countdown Comic Book Cannes psychological thriller indie Disney Channel game show latino CMT gangster period drama Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Disney Plus RT21 Year in Review Box Office TV One Television Academy