New DC Joker Movie in the Works - What Critics Are Saying

by | August 23, 2017 | Comments

(Photo by Warner Bros.)

Another movie based on a DC Comics property was announced this week, and it caught a lot of people by surprise: Batman villain the Joker will be the focus of an origin story set in the early 1980s. Martin Scorsese is producing, Todd Phillips is directing, and a new actor will portray the young evildoer.

Throughout the history of DC Comics adaptations, the Joker has been a favorite element, not just in Batman movies, including The Dark Knight and the animated Batman: The Killing Joke, but also the bad-guy bonanza Suicide Squad. And critics tend to agree with the fans for the most part.

Average Tomatometer score for Batman-based movies featuring the Joker: 78.2%

Average Tomatometer score for Batman-based movies without the Joker: 69.1%


Yet there were uniformly negative reactions to the news of the new Joker movie, which probably won’t feature Batman. Here’s what the critics are saying:

Of all the characters who should NOT have an origin story, like, EVER.
Helen O’Hara, Empire

I can not wait for the Joker origin, because everyone’s childhood is so f—ing interesting.
Mike Ryan, Uproxx

The best way to combat hate is by drowning it out. So let’s all get out there and make movies that AREN’T Joker origin stories.
Eric D. Snider,

I hope the Joker movie is so gritty that it feels like having 400 pounds of gravel shot into my eyes with a firehose.
Scott Wampler, Birth.Movies.Death

Honestly? It feels extremely ill-advised, at least while the current iteration of the DCEU is going…it makes little sense and could lead to a lot of confusion among non-hardcore fans.
Rodrigo Perez, The Playlist

They need to give the Joker a rest..just like Green Goblin over in the Spider-verse.
Edward Douglas, The Tracking Board

Is Todd Phillips perfect for this or terrible for this, I can’t tell I don’t know anything anymore.
Alison Willmore, Buzzfeed

That ‘Joker origin movie produced by Martin Scorsese’ story feels like the end of all things.
Scott Mendelson, Forbes

I’m a busy man, so I’m just going to get my gigantic eye roll out of the way now for when “Sympathy for the Devil” plays in the Joker movie.
Matt Goldberg, Collider

How about we just call SHUTTER ISLAND Scorsese’s Joker movie instead?
Sam Adams, Slate

Tag Cloud

animated cults Superheroes sports Box Office Mindy Kaling zero dark thirty ITV Countdown zombies Election based on movie game show Marathons Comedy Central dc Christmas Winter TV nature National Geographic romance dceu Amazon Polls and Games History The CW Showtime Holidays GIFs 21st Century Fox boxoffice miniseries TV justice league Ghostbusters Kids & Family YouTube Premium Film Festival cooking docudrama transformers diversity space MCU Sundance Toys NYCC San Diego Comic-Con period drama ESPN FX natural history Mudbound Video Games Comics on TV Star Trek anime Disney Channel Spike Summer medical drama talk show Stephen King politics Song of Ice and Fire Best and Worst television Chernobyl spinoff Walt Disney Pictures spider-man streaming The Witch Starz See It Skip It Extras TNT NBC green book Red Carpet Comedy strong female leads Rocketman Quiz Lifetime OWN Crackle teaser thriller 007 A&E casting MTV USA richard e. Grant IFC Films Rock serial killer golden globes historical drama E! Syfy cats Creative Arts Emmys Pride Month Trailer Food Network Sundance Now Musical Shondaland YA Nickelodeon CBS Set visit FXX Brie Larson supernatural doctor who CBS All Access DGA Black Mirror Epix Ovation Netflix PaleyFest festivals true crime Podcast TCA AMC Country technology VH1 PBS E3 zombie vampires spy thriller Pop Captain marvel adventure HBO CW Seed LGBT Vudu harry potter Animation Nominations Reality Competition Nat Geo Mary Tyler Moore Trophy Talk Emmys DC Comics Pixar Columbia Pictures Fall TV Disney Pet Sematary SundanceTV biography facebook Cannes ABC Family MSNBC Spring TV Pirates Winners SXSW Premiere Dates Paramount Network Shudder hist travel toy story GLAAD VICE Watching Series Chilling Adventures of Sabrina crime composers Bravo political drama TV Land Character Guide El Rey science fiction comiccon police drama Paramount CNN Tomatazos Awards Marvel Heroines crime thriller Photos Super Bowl IFC GoT TLC binge blaxploitation Writers Guild of America Spectrum Originals war cinemax sitcom Elton John Reality Lionsgate adaptation Acorn TV 2015 finale psycho First Look Anna Paquin Emmy Nominations singing competition The Arrangement aliens Biopics Hulu Interview DC Universe Rom-Com Adult Swim Drama 20th Century Fox Calendar psychological thriller Universal cops YouTube Red witnail crossover Lucasfilm Sneak Peek mutant Tumblr 24 frames Comic Book Opinion RT21 2019 RT History dramedy disaster Mystery Year in Review Fantasy DC streaming service Teen ratings Logo 2017 Dark Horse Comics BET CMT Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Grammys TruTV Trivia Masterpiece Western comic sequel Awards Tour Infographic Britbox Ellie Kemper WGN TBS award winner American Society of Cinematographers ABC Oscars Horror TCA 2017 Mary Poppins Returns Thanksgiving Cosplay unscripted discovery TCM dragons robots anthology Certified Fresh Sci-Fi social media Action New York Comic Con Fox News Superheroe SDCC USA Network Sony Pictures LGBTQ BBC Apple FOX Musicals Schedule theme song Rocky Martial Arts Music 2018 BBC America mockumentary 2016 jamie lee curtis Women's History Month APB 45 Freeform what to watch Mary poppins Esquire Amazon Prime elevated horror crime drama Warner Bros. X-Men Valentine's Day Tarantino President Star Wars TIFF Cartoon Network DirecTV