Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Narnia Looks Great, but Lacks Magic

Plus, The Tourist isn't worth the trip, and The Fighter is Certified Fresh.

by | December 10, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a spiritual journey (The Chronicles of Narnia: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, starring Georgie Henley and Skandar Keynes) and some European intrigue (The Tourist, starring Johnny Depp and Angelina Jolie). What do the critics have to say?


The Chronicles of Narnia: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader

Thus far, the Chronicles of Narnia movies have generated respectful enthusiasm from audiences and critics – in contrast to the rabid culthood surrounding the Lord of the Rings or Harry Potter movies. And critics say that’s not likely to change with the franchise’s latest outing, (The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, which they say is visually striking but lacks both excitement and a sense of wonder. Once again, the Pevensie children are back in Narnia, and this time they must journey across the sea and collect seven swords in order to save Narnia from certain destruction. The pundits sayDawn Treader isn’t bad, and some of the creature designs are remarkable, but it’s short on urgency, wide-eyed marvel, and a sense of fun.


The Tourist

Everybody loves a caper picture, the kind in which beautiful people get in and out amidst picturesque locales. Right? Not necessarily in the case of The Tourist; critics say the seemingly can’t-miss proposition of Johnny Depp and Angelina Jolie trying to escape danger amidst the splendor of Europe’s most iconic cities is a serious letdown, a slow-moving bagatelle with minimal chemistry between its superstar leads. Depp stars as a lovelorn American who meets the mysterious, beautiful Jolie on a train. It turns out she’s caught up in an international game of cat-and-mouse, and Depp is caught in the crossfire. A certain level of absurdity is inherent in this sort of thing, but the pundits say The Tourist is too slackly paced to keep audiences from suspending disbelief, and the romance between Depp and Jolie is a nonstarter. (Check this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some other noteworthy superstar duos in the same movie.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Finally, props to Harrison M. for coming the closest to guessing The Warrior’s Way‘s 38 percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

Netflix french summer TV ghosts AMC Plus Paramount Plus Superheroes Vudu football Stephen King E3 Apple TV Plus Mary poppins TV One scary movies critics YouTube Red sag awards Polls and Games The Purge Tumblr spy thriller ABC OWN reboot BBC One feel good Women's History Month Television Critics Association toy story scary Image Comics Certified Fresh Toys Best and Worst WGN comiccon dc SDCC Year in Review Opinion 2017 DC Comics The Witch game show Pop TV kaiju james bond Trivia Best Actor Quiz Awards Tour obi wan adenture Calendar saw 4/20 Teen cars cartoon Emmy Nominations japan BBC cops stoner new star wars movies National Geographic canceled movies Neflix Paramount Network hist monster movies SundanceTV BBC America Amazon animated Universal Universal Pictures Trailer live action Geeked Week Legendary chucky USA zombies documentary asian-american cancelled technology crime Marvel Studios black comedy nbcuniversal Disney Plus Freeform name the review Nominations slashers royal family jurassic park BET Awards Best Director blockbuster video on demand Masterpiece Turner Classic Movies CBS All Access cancelled TV series Disney+ Disney Plus sports MSNBC A&E pirates of the caribbean Spectrum Originals space olympics BAFTA Epix Esquire toronto richard e. Grant biography Walt Disney Pictures Best Picture cinemax facebook green book spider-verse The Academy Premiere Dates all-time TruTV spider-man 2016 2018 theme song psychological thriller Endgame lord of the rings Horror king kong Dark Horse Comics 2019 best Box Office Fox News Cosplay MTV Interview E! Trophy Talk adventure versus Travel Channel cancelled television PaleyFest australia Comic Book singing competition Nat Geo TV target scene in color archives RT21 Television Academy child's play directors Summer Hallmark Christmas movies El Rey Martial Arts IFC harry potter Watching Series Wes Anderson Acorn TV Apple NBC serial killer halloween tv Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt LGBTQ robots heist movie Infographic Columbia Pictures Netflix Christmas movies scorecard casting christmas movies HBO Max Winter TV 90s Pixar streamig natural history Film Festival Classic Film book adaptation crossover vampires worst First Reviews Paramount Pictures stop motion Kids & Family Food Network Rom-Com movie boxing legend Cartoon Network blockbusters dexter 93rd Oscars Holiday Action Paramount 73rd Emmy Awards reviews rom-coms series foreign Black Mirror dragons 2015 AMC tv talk rt labs TV renewals USA Network ESPN binge Funimation witnail nfl 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards OneApp dogs TBS HFPA werewolf festival CMT Apple TV+ marvel cinematic universe Photos Elton John composers classics finale scene in color series sopranos FX Sci-Fi criterion 20th Century Fox Amazon Prime Video Alien crime drama war CW Seed Mary Tyler Moore comic books popular Set visit sequel summer preview streaming FOX Sony Pictures spinoff Grammys police drama Countdown superhero 94th Oscars Heroines golden globes revenge obituary women TCA Winter 2020 Arrowverse Comic-Con@Home 2021 Hallmark Disney Channel Nickelodeon Creative Arts Emmys The Walking Dead comics zombie Marvel Television scene in color hollywood cancelled TV shows Holidays godzilla Avengers Lifetime leaderboard NBA WarnerMedia Song of Ice and Fire cults GoT TLC Bravo FX on Hulu sitcom Reality Competition VICE President ABC Signature Peacock Fantasy video DC Universe travel Mindy Kaling SXSW 2022 venice New York Comic Con unscripted Shondaland spanish language Pride Month YouTube Premium discovery TV Land genre screen actors guild Film Anna Paquin breaking bad Broadway supernatural stand-up comedy Sundance Now anthology vs. gangster films Crackle 21st Century Fox mutant Captain marvel Drama indie 79th Golden Globes Awards ITV RT History The CW summer TV preview aliens talk show Ellie Kemper Valentine's Day doctor who action-comedy debate PlayStation blaxploitation Crunchyroll Turner Starz diversity Tomatazos Shudder South by Southwest Film Festival Hulu docudrama Sundance Warner Bros. 99% Pet Sematary Instagram Live Reality teaser comic book movies CNN strong female leads HBO Comedy Central Rocketman jamie lee curtis Chernobyl slasher APB new york Star Wars dceu X-Men a nightmare on elm street 007 know your critic Spike Family children's TV Awards golden globe awards Lucasfilm crime thriller adaptation rt archives Pacific Islander Britbox young adult TNT Adult Swim news live event TCA 2017 true crime wonder woman Star Wars Celebration 2021 Fall TV broadcast worst movies rotten movies we love parents IMDb TV laika trailers Emmys Comics on TV interviews Disney streaming service Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Exclusive Video deadpool Fargo VOD disaster mcc Pop anime kong DGA cooking Cannes joker Extras Writers Guild of America universal monsters Oscars Amazon Prime period drama king arthur telelvision Podcast Sony Lifetime Christmas movies emmy awards Christmas science fiction die hard japanese Tokyo Olympics romantic comedy YA Oscar marvel comics Musicals docuseries Showtime suspense Marvel franchise hidden camera CBS Best Actress Focus Features critic resources twilight The Arrangement screenings American Society of Cinematographers Ovation basketball festivals Tarantino latino Country Comedy DC streaming service zero dark thirty independent VH1 Fox Searchlight spanish batman book TV movies 72 Emmy Awards prank Star Trek HBO Go Pirates San Diego Comic-Con Sundance TV hispanic Mudbound nature 24 frames medical drama rt labs critics edition concert based on movie MCU See It Skip It TCA historical drama Rock Binge Guide Thanksgiving italian social media GIFs GLAAD Hollywood Foreign Press Association aapi streaming movies transformers thriller elevated horror miniseries Marathons justice league trophy ABC Family ID Lionsgate Brie Larson hispanic heritage month The Walt Disney Company Red Carpet south america FXX target Baby Yoda ViacomCBS Black History Month television Western 45 Music psycho comedies Mary Poppins Returns game of thrones Election Rocky documentaries ratings dreamworks Schedule free movies black LGBT political drama Prime Video Sneak Peek cats Syfy NYCC Animation Musical Spring TV TIFF rotten comic Hear Us Out Mystery Video Games politics 1990s Super Bowl Tubi posters international 71st Emmy Awards romance canceled TV shows Disney Amazon Studios new zealand BET dark spain razzies high school PBS biopic scene in color film series mission: impossible Logo Academy Awards satire kids quibi YouTube remakes sequels superman Superheroe First Look Ghostbusters art house comic book movie fast and furious renewed TV shows SXSW what to watch fresh award winner halloween IFC Films Native A24 TCM Indigenous Winners dramedy Tags: Comedy Biopics mockumentary Discovery Channel TCA Awards boxoffice Character Guide DirecTV MGM 2020 mob History indiana jones