Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Narnia Looks Great, but Lacks Magic

Plus, The Tourist isn't worth the trip, and The Fighter is Certified Fresh.

by | December 10, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a spiritual journey (The Chronicles of Narnia: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, starring Georgie Henley and Skandar Keynes) and some European intrigue (The Tourist, starring Johnny Depp and Angelina Jolie). What do the critics have to say?


The Chronicles of Narnia: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader

Thus far, the Chronicles of Narnia movies have generated respectful enthusiasm from audiences and critics – in contrast to the rabid culthood surrounding the Lord of the Rings or Harry Potter movies. And critics say that’s not likely to change with the franchise’s latest outing, (The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, which they say is visually striking but lacks both excitement and a sense of wonder. Once again, the Pevensie children are back in Narnia, and this time they must journey across the sea and collect seven swords in order to save Narnia from certain destruction. The pundits sayDawn Treader isn’t bad, and some of the creature designs are remarkable, but it’s short on urgency, wide-eyed marvel, and a sense of fun.


The Tourist

Everybody loves a caper picture, the kind in which beautiful people get in and out amidst picturesque locales. Right? Not necessarily in the case of The Tourist; critics say the seemingly can’t-miss proposition of Johnny Depp and Angelina Jolie trying to escape danger amidst the splendor of Europe’s most iconic cities is a serious letdown, a slow-moving bagatelle with minimal chemistry between its superstar leads. Depp stars as a lovelorn American who meets the mysterious, beautiful Jolie on a train. It turns out she’s caught up in an international game of cat-and-mouse, and Depp is caught in the crossfire. A certain level of absurdity is inherent in this sort of thing, but the pundits say The Tourist is too slackly paced to keep audiences from suspending disbelief, and the romance between Depp and Jolie is a nonstarter. (Check this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some other noteworthy superstar duos in the same movie.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Finally, props to Harrison M. for coming the closest to guessing The Warrior’s Way‘s 38 percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

PBS FX TNT historical drama Drama ABC Family Fantasy SundanceTV diversity Extras Oscars supernatural Masterpiece Musical Amazon First Look Writers Guild of America CMT Nominations police drama 007 social media Emmys DC Comics Summer PaleyFest Lionsgate psycho BBC America Music Martial Arts RT History VICE Universal Sneak Peek IFC zombie composers Winter TV Crackle Rom-Com El Rey History The Arrangement Country Netflix MSNBC Hulu Biopics DirecTV BET travel Horror TCA 2017 Holidays Food Network cinemax Lifetime Star Trek NBC American Society of Cinematographers Sundance GoT cooking Rocky sitcom Mary Tyler Moore NYCC X-Men CBS discovery SDCC Logo Reality adventure Photos TCM FXX HBO Premiere Dates crime TBS Syfy thriller BBC crime thriller 24 frames Schedule Awards Watching Series Starz Esquire Best and Worst Reality Competition technology E! Spring TV A&E 2017 Pirates war singing competition ESPN Infographic Dark Horse Comics APB USA sports Election Comedy Superheroes Cosplay TV Marvel TruTV Marathons Countdown Character Guide Animation Valentine's Day CNN Teen Disney Channel ITV TLC Super Bowl Fall TV Freeform science fiction President Showtime Interview cops Polls and Games LGBTQ WGN Video Games FOX Musicals Trivia Tumblr Kids & Family Comic Book period drama 2015 Pop OWN Tomatazos crime drama Nickelodeon Thanksgiving Certified Fresh CBS All Access Podcast AMC Cartoon Network based on movie Set visit docudrama Toys ABC biography vampires Disney Grammys Box Office harry potter Calendar Opinion Rock TIFF Winners Comedy Central boxoffice Action Bravo GIFs Red Carpet GLAAD TV Land MTV politics Nat Geo dramedy Fox News serial killer The CW Trailer Sci-Fi Adult Swim aliens Mystery 2016 VH1 comiccon TCA Ghostbusters Star Wars Year in Review