Best Horror Movies 2021

If there’s any genre that produces underseen hidden gems as regularly as it produces shlocky garbage, it’s horror, and thankfully, we got a decent amount of the former in 2021. Of course, the big story is that John Krasinski’s hotly anticipated sequel A Quiet Place Part II was, quite fortunately, a rock-solid follow-up that more than delivered on its promise of creepy action and exciting world-building, winning the Golden Tomato for Best Horror Movie in the process. But this year also gave us a striking vampire tale (My Heart Can’t Beat Unless You Tell It To), a horror-comedy about a killer pair of jeans (Slaxx), and even a once-lost George Romero chiller from 1973 (The Amusement Park) that premiered on streaming for the first time last year. Whether you’re into period thrills (The Delivered) or contemporary ones (Censor), this year’s crop of acclaimed horror flicks ran the gamut.

The order reflects Tomatometer scores (as of December 31, 2021) after adjustment from our ranking formula, which compensates for variation in the number of reviews when comparing movies or TV shows.

Adjusted Score: 109713%
Critics Consensus: A nerve-wracking continuation of its predecessor, A Quiet Place Part II expands the terrifying world of the franchise without losing track of its heart.
Synopsis: Following the deadly events at home, the Abbott family must now face the terrors of the outside world as they... [More]
Directed By: John Krasinski

Adjusted Score: 98858%
Critics Consensus: Unsettling and compelling in equal measure, My Heart Can't Beat Unless You Tell It To casts a visually striking and thought-provoking spell.
Synopsis: Dwight (Patrick Fugit) prowls the streets after dark. He searches each night for the lonely and forlorn, looking for people... [More]
Directed By: Jonathan Cuartas

Adjusted Score: 98733%
Critics Consensus: A tense, terrifying, and all-around outstanding feature debut for its co-directing duo, The Boy Behind the Door should thrill discerning horror fans.
Synopsis: In The Boy Behind the Door, a night of unimaginable terror awaits twelve-year-old Bobby (Lonnie Chavis) and his best friend,... [More]

Adjusted Score: 98262%
Critics Consensus: A blunt yet visceral depiction of society's treatment of the elderly, The Amusement Park sees George A. Romero exploring a different -- yet still chilling -- type of terror.
Synopsis: Recently discovered and restored 46 years after its completion by the George A. Romero Foundation and produced by Suzanne Desrocher-Romero,... [More]
Directed By: George A. Romero


Slaxx (2020)

Adjusted Score: 98029%
Critics Consensus: A slim-cut slice of bizarre horror, Slaxx effectively balances quirk with gore -- and has the good sense to get out before its oddball premise starts showing its seams.
Synopsis: A possessed pair of jeans is brought to life to punish the unscrupulous practices of a trendy clothing company. Shipped... [More]
Directed By: Elza Kephart


Candyman (2021)

Adjusted Score: 102240%
Critics Consensus: Candyman takes an incisive, visually thrilling approach to deepening the franchise's mythology -- and terrifying audiences along the way.
Synopsis: For as long as residents can remember, the housing projects of Chicago's Cabrini-Green neighborhood were terrorized by a word-of-mouth ghost... [More]
Directed By: Nia DaCosta


The Delivered (2019)

Adjusted Score: 96332%
Critics Consensus: Bound together by Maxine Peake's magnetic portrayal of the main character, Fanny Lye Deliver'd offers impactful, richly layered period drama.
Synopsis: In 1657 England, Fanny Lye transcends her oppressive marriage to discover a new world of possibilities -- but at a... [More]
Directed By: Thomas Clay


Lucky (2020)

Adjusted Score: 95029%
Critics Consensus: A rich blend of thrilling horror and sharp social commentary, Lucky acts as a bloody good calling card for director Natasha Kermani and writer-star Brea Grant.
Synopsis: A self-help book author finds herself stalked by a threatening figure who returns to her house night after night. She... [More]
Directed By: Natasha Kermani


Censor (2021)

Adjusted Score: 96215%
Critics Consensus: Occasionally uneven but bold and viscerally effective, Censor marks a bloody good step forward for British horror.
Synopsis: Film censor Enid takes pride in her meticulous work, guarding unsuspecting audiences from the deleterious effects of watching the gore-filled... [More]
Directed By: Prano Bailey-Bond


The Night House (2020)

Adjusted Score: 97010%
Critics Consensus: Led by Rebecca Hall's gripping central performance, The Night House offers atmospheric horror that engages intellectually as well as emotionally.
Synopsis: Reeling from the unexpected death of her husband, Beth (Rebecca Hall) is left alone in the lakeside home he built... [More]
Directed By: David Bruckner

Tag Cloud

docuseries crime drama mcc Pirates unscripted RT History Sundance Now Calendar Anna Paquin Lionsgate Binge Guide game show TV One Amazon versus IFC Films thriller HBO Go Freeform blaxploitation rotten sitcom Turner Rocketman GLAAD spain TCM canceled TV shows VH1 mockumentary NYCC australia Reality Disney Plus Amazon Studios disaster technology Comic-Con@Home 2021 Emmy Nominations suspense MTV cooking know your critic ViacomCBS zero dark thirty Rom-Com DC streaming service Paramount football Family ABC Family reboot asian-american Funimation south america LGBTQ Showtime OneApp Tubi Television Academy Legendary police drama joker Marathons USA hollywood DGA Film Festival Bravo 2017 Marvel jurassic park venice stoner Instagram Live Spike crime thriller boxoffice romantic comedy The CW Paramount Plus Film Starz adaptation History dreamworks E! Comics on TV psychological thriller black comedy Mystery 007 casting Fargo zombies Exclusive Video BAFTA rom-coms Christmas halloween tv posters chucky canceled PaleyFest robots period drama worst movies space Toys Emmys Women's History Month TIFF 94th Oscars Spring TV Country Musical black marvel comics 1990s Dark Horse Comics WGN critics wonder woman japanese Teen ABC Nat Geo children's TV razzies Shudder rt labs 2019 2021 Adult Swim TV jamie lee curtis singing competition Hollywood Foreign Press Association 45 summer TV preview Interview Trailer Brie Larson Baby Yoda biopic APB Best Director Masterpiece Apple TV+ discovery streaming movies critic resources Pop TV SXSW 2022 Premiere Dates blockbusters italian aliens target Paramount Network South by Southwest Film Festival travel YouTube Red AMC cults action-comedy hispanic BBC free movies Disney streaming service cats Lifetime Christmas movies spanish MGM french Infographic boxing Hallmark CMT Britbox The Witch USA Network 20th Century Fox high school Opinion PlayStation 90s Comic Book science fiction E3 Pop Oscars elevated horror Holidays medical drama cops Disney TLC ghosts hispanic heritage month Star Trek Peacock Apple Columbia Pictures HBO VICE Rock Star Wars zombie diversity miniseries DirecTV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt trophy Chilling Adventures of Sabrina gangster Mindy Kaling deadpool toronto Hear Us Out dceu doctor who adenture slashers sag awards Epix Best and Worst based on movie werewolf The Academy book adaptation Drama Hulu Rocky adventure concert festival Apple TV Plus Tags: Comedy satire Discovery Channel summer preview Netflix Christmas movies Awards SundanceTV psycho green book SXSW Superheroes Tarantino telelvision breaking bad Mary poppins Grammys Lifetime monster movies PBS festivals vampires true crime 71st Emmy Awards debate Sneak Peek Polls and Games CNN YouTube Premium popular Best Actress DC Comics Writers Guild of America kong anthology cinemax series foreign obi wan sports RT21 Thanksgiving halloween 4/20 transformers Hallmark Christmas movies rt labs critics edition Fox News sequel Nominations Action scene in color broadcast Reality Competition spy thriller die hard archives nature A&E legend documentaries Pet Sematary Sundance TV Red Carpet finale fresh basketball El Rey 79th Golden Globes Awards Paramount Pictures 72 Emmy Awards Crackle Avengers composers vs. Focus Features superhero dc MSNBC NBA Disney Channel American Society of Cinematographers TNT hist cars GIFs A24 trailers Certified Fresh 24 frames japan 99% Turner Classic Movies TCA comedies 2016 obituary 2015 Alien Music animated Cartoon Network Shondaland stop motion mutant scary Oscar Neflix Election Fantasy Disney+ Disney Plus Lucasfilm richard e. Grant royal family Netflix live action stand-up comedy Tokyo Olympics TBS comic book movies Winter TV cancelled TV series rotten movies we love remakes what to watch serial killer revenge NBC The Walt Disney Company Wes Anderson Prime Video reviews Ghostbusters Marvel Television Cosplay Summer all-time ITV witnail tv talk TV renewals scorecard FXX name the review worst aapi CW Seed Schedule Creative Arts Emmys LGBT Esquire book Warner Bros. political drama Super Bowl The Walking Dead San Diego Comic-Con rt archives latino dark feel good Winners olympics Countdown Mary Tyler Moore independent slasher Sci-Fi Food Network VOD comic book movie Black Mirror summer TV Heroines docudrama natural history teaser Amazon Prime Video Marvel Studios Black History Month video television Martial Arts quibi Amazon Prime The Purge talk show emmy awards kids Awards Tour Broadway art house new star wars movies supernatural Photos comic streaming Arrowverse FX Trivia Walt Disney Pictures laika politics ID cancelled TV shows Ovation YA nfl king arthur President Kids & Family crime ESPN Year in Review Comedy Central Song of Ice and Fire spider-verse spider-man CBS Chernobyl Stephen King prank international news young adult Endgame screen actors guild Mudbound Comedy social media Box Office toy story strong female leads WarnerMedia award winner Sony Pictures Watching Series Universal Pictures TV Land james bond Character Guide Biopics spinoff romance Extras Fox Searchlight video on demand Captain marvel 21st Century Fox ratings Mary Poppins Returns MCU films comics dogs TruTV blockbuster fast and furious christmas movies ABC Signature YouTube GoT Video Games dexter Travel Channel BET Awards Best Picture dragons documentary marvel cinematic universe Horror parents cancelled new york golden globe awards X-Men classics The Arrangement batman Spectrum Originals Best Actor BBC One Quiz king kong universal monsters DC Universe Tomatazos kaiju genre Nickelodeon Cannes heist movie scary movies Acorn TV best Pixar Valentine's Day movies saw HFPA Set visit Image Comics Television Critics Association Universal FOX movie hidden camera live event comiccon dramedy Syfy facebook First Look OWN National Geographic superman New York Comic Con lord of the rings See It Skip It women streamig 2020 leaderboard mission: impossible spanish language HBO Max IFC AMC Plus anime war Logo Holiday comic books 73rd Emmy Awards FX on Hulu 2018 Crunchyroll golden globes Sundance SDCC pirates of the caribbean 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards BET indiana jones BBC America Tumblr Pacific Islander TV movies new zealand Academy Awards TCA Awards TCA 2017 cancelled television twilight cartoon Elton John Vudu game of thrones child's play criterion Musicals CBS All Access Trophy Talk historical drama sequels mob binge Animation Fall TV a nightmare on elm street justice league TCA Winter 2020 directors crossover harry potter Pride Month IMDb TV Superheroe First Reviews sopranos Classic Film 93rd Oscars franchise screenings Podcast biography renewed TV shows indie Western nbcuniversal theme song Ellie Kemper godzilla