Showdowns

RT Fans Crown Halloween the Ultimate Horror Movie

The John Carpenter classic surged from behind on the last day of voting to eke out a victory over The Shining by a mere 20 votes!

by | October 29, 2021 | Comments

(Click to enlarge.)

After six intense rounds of voting on some of the most beloved, most iconic horror films ever, we can finally announce that the winner of the Ultimate Horror Movie Showdown is John Carpenter’s original Halloween! And, appropriately enough, the win came by the narrowest of margins, making it the closest battle of the entire tournament. Stanley Kubrick’s adaptation of Stephen King’s The Shining held a tenuous lead of just under 100 votes as the last day of voting began, but as afternoon came, the tide began to turn. When all was said and done, almost 14,000 votes were cast, and Halloween received a last-minute surge that helped it eke out the victory over The Shining by a mere 20 votes (6917 to 6897, to be exact)!

As always, thanks to everyone who participated and followed along, leaving comments and discussing the results. If nothing else, we hope we’ve reminded you of a few forgotten favorites or a few gems you’ve been meaning to check out that you can place on your Halloween watch list for the weekend. With that said, stay tuned for our next showdown, and have a safe and Happy Halloween!

Round 1 Results | Round 2 Results | Round 3 Results | Round 4 Results | Round 5 Results


Final Round Result

Round 1 Results | Round 2 Results | Round 3 Results | Round 4 Results | Round 5 Results


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next

Tag Cloud

chucky 4/20 Emmys Music cinemax ghosts comedies dramedy Sneak Peek FOX Women's History Month stoner batman young adult worst movies rotten movies we love dogs marvel cinematic universe Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt WGN war french new star wars movies OneApp TV movies First Look BAFTA CNN 24 frames rt archives japan godzilla true crime Spike social media asian-american anthology HFPA Comedy Central Dark Horse Comics Cartoon Network medical drama Family cancelled TV shows new zealand quibi spider-man finale CMT hispanic heritage month Best and Worst stop motion australia Tarantino vampires disaster The Academy Nominations MCU Mary Poppins Returns FX on Hulu CW Seed 007 canceled TV shows Musical Christmas documentaries Showtime Reality Competition Syfy festival Shudder 20th Century Fox Pop Character Guide children's TV laika comiccon Countdown king arthur women rotten Song of Ice and Fire Rock jamie lee curtis hollywood a nightmare on elm street Netflix kaiju cooking TV Land Mystery binge HBO Go The Witch emmy awards Valentine's Day Mudbound deadpool kids rt labs casting Video Games DC Universe strong female leads Polls and Games Logo 2021 satire Heroines archives Hollywood Foreign Press Association Travel Channel award winner 2020 1990s DC streaming service child's play leaderboard Disney Channel Superheroe prank miniseries Black Mirror 2015 Amazon Prime Video Bravo USA Quiz NYCC CBS Amazon Pacific Islander joker Schedule Year in Review Mary Tyler Moore Holiday Black History Month golden globes composers toronto name the review IFC Films Legendary Fargo Avengers discovery razzies Reality universal monsters Tubi robots TCA Awards Warner Bros. Epix Comedy diversity Calendar Television Critics Association Paramount Ovation Rocky Wes Anderson dark blaxploitation king kong festivals Captain marvel Thanksgiving Photos Super Bowl DC Comics book screenings aapi ID live action docudrama blockbusters Sony Pictures basketball Election Amazon Prime trailers fresh Spring TV Action Anna Paquin venice Tags: Comedy American Society of Cinematographers stand-up comedy crime Extras cats movies Paramount Plus cancelled critics 2019 Masterpiece First Reviews YouTube Premium TBS reboot Brie Larson nature halloween Ellie Kemper comic book movies black comedy suspense Turner Classic Movies Nat Geo PaleyFest news debate ABC Signature FXX TV renewals best wonder woman lord of the rings Cosplay Pirates Crackle Television Academy PBS biography Classic Film GIFs ABC teaser rom-coms twilight dexter Amazon Studios Baby Yoda spain Esquire Superheroes FX aliens Horror Drama reviews History Mary poppins Infographic jurassic park Funimation thriller new york marvel comics Freeform Universal Pictures historical drama independent Martial Arts DGA pirates of the caribbean sequel streaming movies Lionsgate Alien Tokyo Olympics scorecard Lucasfilm sitcom Stephen King Acorn TV Academy Awards dreamworks Binge Guide Instagram Live Grammys Disney Plus Broadway Paramount Network Premiere Dates TNT Endgame game show YouTube Marvel Studios Exclusive Video cartoon San Diego Comic-Con VICE live event concert Film superhero 93rd Oscars OWN cults HBO Trailer renewed TV shows vs. Winter TV Sundance know your critic high school criterion boxing boxoffice 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards ESPN rt labs critics edition APB BBC Oscars Elton John game of thrones RT21 movie A&E Comic-Con@Home 2021 target Pride Month anime ITV 2017 halloween tv AMC Plus TruTV HBO Max technology popular Marathons Winners WarnerMedia Box Office natural history period drama Turner spanish royal family Holidays Creative Arts Emmys Opinion BBC America black franchise GoT MSNBC AMC telelvision comic latino USA Network Trophy Talk Lifetime El Rey heist movie zombie harry potter dragons CBS All Access Fox News feel good PlayStation Peacock sopranos nfl GLAAD Disney+ Disney Plus Hallmark mob south america book adaptation tv talk video NBA cops BET A24 canceled Adult Swim Vudu Tumblr LGBTQ monster movies Tomatazos italian Teen TLC E! MTV legend psycho Apple TV+ biopic Columbia Pictures Trivia animated international IFC all-time Emmy Nominations Country comic books 45 psychological thriller crossover X-Men hidden camera Marvel Television Image Comics 90s Fantasy gangster LGBT parents adaptation TCA Winter 2020 YouTube Red what to watch golden globe awards streaming ratings posters BET Awards facebook films spy thriller The Arrangement football The CW video on demand National Geographic slashers TCA 2017 Star Wars Awards saw Interview crime drama Disney streaming service hispanic comic book movie fast and furious Britbox indiana jones politics zero dark thirty E3 ABC Family ViacomCBS revenge 2018 series Set visit scene in color james bond adenture Biopics 73rd Emmy Awards The Walking Dead theme song kong sequels mcc zombies DirecTV versus talk show Shondaland witnail 21st Century Fox die hard 72 Emmy Awards TCM TV obituary Netflix Christmas movies Red Carpet indie SDCC Western Pixar science fiction Chernobyl VH1 Food Network mission: impossible elevated horror VOD olympics remakes slasher SXSW Pet Sematary Animation comics TCA Ghostbusters Watching Series critic resources Fall TV BBC One action-comedy political drama SundanceTV spinoff trophy Certified Fresh blockbuster Fox Searchlight transformers free movies 71st Emmy Awards art house Hulu Prime Video japanese sports Musicals NBC Starz dceu mutant Marvel Sci-Fi Hallmark Christmas movies documentary Walt Disney Pictures directors Spectrum Originals adventure breaking bad Sundance Now Nickelodeon classics Comics on TV Awards Tour Apple TV Plus dc television The Walt Disney Company Mindy Kaling supernatural Pop TV spider-verse Arrowverse travel genre IMDb TV unscripted Podcast Summer singing competition hist crime thriller werewolf green book 79th Golden Globes Awards Discovery Channel The Purge Sundance TV TIFF mockumentary Universal christmas movies RT History richard e. Grant toy story foreign Apple President Film Festival spanish language YA scary movies cancelled television See It Skip It TV One Writers Guild of America based on movie Toys Crunchyroll justice league romantic comedy cancelled TV series Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Neflix worst screen actors guild Kids & Family Star Trek Hear Us Out Rocketman sag awards Rom-Com serial killer Lifetime Christmas movies police drama Cannes space Comic Book romance cars superman Disney 2016 New York Comic Con nbcuniversal docuseries 99% scary doctor who