Marvel Vs. DC on TV: Which Comic Book Giant Reigns Supreme?

Find out which comic book TV universe comes out on top and which series fans prefer in the results from Rotten Tomatoes' Fall TV Survey.

by | November 2, 2018 | Comments

Daredevil keyart and Robin from Titans character poster (Netflix; DC Universe)

When Rotten Tomatoes asked users about their television viewing habits in our Fall TV Survey, we got intel on how much TV they watch, how they watch it, and other details. We also asked them one very important question: Marvel or DC?

In the battle of the comic book titans, the percentage of RT users who prefer Marvel’s shows just barely edged out the diplomatic among you (a.k.a. the ones who prefer both). Interestingly, the number of users who prefer DC to Marvel is far lower. The RT user breakdown is 31.54% Marvel, 31.39% both, 26.63% neither, and just 10.44% DC.

Among Marvel viewers, the most popular show for RT users is also the No. 1-ranked show on the Tomatometer (which means the critics agree!): Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., with 19.85% of users saying it’s their favorite. Marvel’s Daredevil is next, with 14.56% of RT users saying it’s their favorite, followed by Marvel’s Jessica Jones with 11.43%, Legion with 8.10%, and Marvel’s The Punisher with 6.16%. Marvel’s Iron Fist comes in last among RT users (with 0.88% saying it’s their favorite) and on the Tomatometer (with a 37%, followed only by the one-season series Marvel’s Inhumans).

David Lee/Netflix

(Photo by Netflix)

Daredevil also ranks second among RT users’ favorite Netflix series (with 6.24% of users saying it’s their favorite, behind Stranger Things).

On the DC side, 11.64% of RT users said The Flash is their favorite, and 11.16% say they like Gotham best. Interestingly, while Black Lightning is in the top 3 DC shows by Tomatometer (with a 98% score, and a Certified Fresh first season), it comes in second-to-last among RT users’ favorites (with only 3.26% saying it’s their favorite). Krypton comes in second-to-last on the Tomatometer (with a 59% score, followed only by the one-season sitcom Powerless), and last among RT users’ faves (with 1.30% of respondents calling it their favorite).

Gender affected the Marvel vs. DC results by just a few percentage points, but in key ways: more women preferred neither (33.56%), then both (31.39%), then Marvel (24.77%), and finally DC (10.28%). Among male respondents, 34.49% prefer Marvel, 34.03% prefer both, 20.14% prefer neither, and 11.35% prefer DC.

The Flash -- "We Are The Flash" -- Image Number: FLA423b_0449.jpg -- Pictured: Grant Gustin as The Flash -- Photo: Shane Harvey/The CW -- 2018 The CW Network, LLC. All rights reserved

(Photo by The CW)

For DC fans, the top show among women was Lucifer (10.76%), then Gotham (9.26%), then The Flash (7.48%). For men, it was The Flash (16.39%), then Gotham (13.67%), then Preacher (9.45%). For Marvel fans, the top show among women was S.H.I.E.L.D. (19.27%), then Jessica Jones (13.61%), then Daredevil (6.89%). For men, it was S.H.I.E.L.D. (24.87%), Daredevil (19.43%), and Legion (9.02%).

Want to know where the series rank on the Tomatometer? Check out the Marvel and DC guides below!

Tag Cloud

72 Emmy Awards TV One feel good WarnerMedia Extras halloween tv talk show travel sag awards Acorn TV Superheroes james bond Election Comedy Central Family versus TNT Polls and Games zombies sitcom serial killer Tubi archives 1990s FX Fox News Thanksgiving 4/20 disaster know your critic theme song TCA Winter 2020 TBS comedies Masterpiece BBC America laika technology Anna Paquin RT21 royal family Turner DGA based on movie Netflix Endgame VOD FX on Hulu VICE vampires docuseries police drama crime drama marvel cinematic universe Spectrum Originals Countdown dragons sequels Bravo Chernobyl renewed TV shows Winter TV stand-up comedy criterion Tarantino Summer comic book movies Nickelodeon Ovation genre indiana jones godzilla Marathons TruTV ghosts Valentine's Day mob Black Mirror cancelled television Amazon Prime Character Guide anime Turner Classic Movies The Academy Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt A24 toronto Columbia Pictures OneApp Fox Searchlight Star Wars golden globe awards Apple TV+ Freeform screenings Lifetime asian-american sequel jamie lee curtis boxing Comics on TV PaleyFest cars movies crime thriller biopic legend batman Reality ViacomCBS Amazon spider-man cancelled TV series new star wars movies romantic comedy olympics Schedule 20th Century Fox 2018 ABC Family Photos Rock X-Men CNN deadpool CMT Funimation TV renewals Television Academy strong female leads Premiere Dates Western USA Network concert 2017 Exclusive Video 90s Emmy Nominations Peacock BBC superman Infographic crime Trophy Talk debate social media foreign biography tv talk dark E3 Sony Pictures 71st Emmy Awards Legendary obituary Sundance Toys PBS stoner Neflix nfl Set visit Trivia Crunchyroll doctor who Mary Poppins Returns Shondaland Pixar supernatural Hallmark Christmas movies streaming movies period drama The Arrangement Image Comics Calendar MSNBC nbcuniversal screen actors guild boxoffice mission: impossible DirecTV 2015 robots Crackle Paramount Network dexter 99% Elton John casting kong National Geographic Lucasfilm San Diego Comic-Con Comic-Con@Home 2021 DC streaming service video CBS Fantasy adenture rt labs critics edition binge docudrama Shudder 24 frames BBC One Cartoon Network vs. VH1 facebook Marvel festival animated CW Seed documentaries Alien blockbuster Teen satire spanish Musicals lord of the rings twilight worst quibi marvel comics Awards diversity Mary Tyler Moore GoT Netflix Christmas movies award winner Universal Pictures LGBTQ AMC Plus Starz rt archives Rocky jurassic park miniseries cancelled 2020 Creative Arts Emmys emmy awards Black History Month blockbusters romance HBO BAFTA ABC Pirates Showtime hidden camera Chilling Adventures of Sabrina comic dceu hispanic heritage month richard e. Grant streaming women what to watch king kong A&E spain FOX Opinion NYCC a nightmare on elm street Emmys young adult 2021 Nominations mutant new york FXX psychological thriller Amazon Prime Video comics HBO Max aliens Hear Us Out Writers Guild of America BET Awards adaptation critics Cosplay Wes Anderson halloween Amazon Studios Comic Book Comedy fast and furious composers comic book movie anthology mcc book Pet Sematary Mystery Sci-Fi Adult Swim Britbox fresh American Society of Cinematographers Star Trek venice japan Esquire independent name the review book adaptation Drama E! science fiction rom-coms Academy Awards Interview 007 comiccon Super Bowl telelvision Reality Competition Sundance Now TCA 73rd Emmy Awards video on demand Disney harry potter The Walking Dead Film Festival Broadway Arrowverse true crime dramedy slasher prank Sneak Peek Paramount Plus unscripted Spike christmas movies rt labs Pop TV finale Grammys Year in Review 21st Century Fox YouTube Box Office political drama Best and Worst Baby Yoda Biopics films stop motion wonder woman universal monsters SDCC Ellie Kemper dreamworks New York Comic Con heist movie television suspense monster movies The CW kaiju spinoff CBS All Access parents DC Comics spy thriller Musical french 93rd Oscars justice league IFC TV movies south america DC Universe crossover NBC TV Land Pop Video Games black comedy psycho Hallmark canceled TV shows Awards Tour international australia remakes Tokyo Olympics Trailer Heroines razzies witnail TCA 2017 die hard dc Sundance TV thriller black GIFs documentary Superheroe art house 45 scary Spring TV Horror sopranos 2016 First Reviews Marvel Television blaxploitation medical drama The Witch Red Carpet worst movies USA hollywood rotten Hulu Paramount Tomatazos OWN Warner Bros. Quiz football Discovery Channel Oscars nature WGN ESPN zero dark thirty live event Instagram Live The Walt Disney Company El Rey cinemax First Look Martial Arts critic resources Holiday reboot revenge ratings hispanic YouTube Red GLAAD movie posters Travel Channel Dark Horse Comics Music Winners RT History mockumentary Rocketman Pride Month adventure Classic Film ITV TV pirates of the caribbean kids aapi child's play toy story AMC space IMDb TV war YA Nat Geo SundanceTV Film werewolf reviews gangster trailers MTV saw Ghostbusters Podcast elevated horror indie Logo action-comedy scene in color APB Apple TV Plus LGBT politics Fall TV target Universal scorecard Vudu Epix joker Country Stephen King superhero rotten movies we love latino cats cooking Brie Larson golden globes italian hist Syfy best cartoon sports cults king arthur Song of Ice and Fire transformers Animation spanish language news all-time Disney Plus Disney streaming service Pacific Islander Christmas discovery President TCA Awards 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Disney+ Disney Plus Lionsgate festivals Tumblr game show high school franchise Certified Fresh History slashers Women's History Month japanese green book basketball scary movies zombie Food Network singing competition Disney Channel Watching Series Avengers new zealand historical drama TLC NBA Captain marvel Cannes Mindy Kaling children's TV series Binge Guide ABC Signature spider-verse Apple cancelled TV shows natural history See It Skip It TIFF canceled YouTube Premium TCM breaking bad HBO Go cops teaser PlayStation free movies SXSW dogs classics popular The Purge live action directors Kids & Family Walt Disney Pictures Holidays MCU Lifetime Christmas movies chucky Mary poppins IFC Films Marvel Studios 2019 game of thrones BET comic books Rom-Com Television Critics Association Action Mudbound ID