Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Leatherheads Has its Ups and Downs; Nim's Island is Stranded; Guess The Ruins' Tomatometer!

Assessing the week in film criticism.

by | April 3, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got gridiron giggles (Leatherheads, starring George Clooney and Renée Zellweger), isle imagination (Nim’s Island, starring Jodie Foster and Abigail Breslin), and archeological anxiety (The Ruins, starring Shawn Ashmore and Jena Malone). What do the critics have to say?

George Clooney gets compared to Cary Grant all the time, so it’s only natural he would try his hand at Grant’s prime métier — the screwball comedy. Unfortunately, critics say the football laffer Leatherheads, in which Clooney stars and directs, is something of a mixed bag. Set in the early days of pro-pigskin (in the days when college was king), Leatherheads tells the tale of the struggling, ragtag Duluth squad, which has scored a major coup by tapping a college gridiron hero (played by John Krasinski) to team with aging pro Dodge Connolly (Clooney); however, the team is also under fire from an aggressive beat reporter (Renée Zellweger). The pundits say Leatherheads is a funny, amiable affair, but it could take some pointers from the no-huddle offense, which, like screwball comedy, emphasizes quick thinking, deft interaction, and risk. At 54 percent on the Tomatometer, Leatherheads is being thrown for a loss. And it’s Clooney’s worst-reviewed directorial effort to date — well below Good Night and Good Luck‘s 94 percent. (Check out our interview with George Clooney here.)

“Look, we’re running a flea flicker, and that’s final! Do I look like I’m negotiating?

A sort of Swiss Family Robinson crossed with Indiana Jones, the critics say Nim’s Island is solid family fare — with the pros and cons that implies. Abigail Breslin stars as Nim, a precocious girl who lives on a South Pacific island with her father (Gerard Butler), a scientist; when he goes missing, Nim turns to the hero of her favorite book (also played by Butler) — and the tome’s author (Jodie Foster) — for help. Critics say Nim’s Island has an old-fashioned sense of wonder and adventure — as well as a healthy dose of girl power — that makes for an above-average kids’ adventure. But they also note the movie offers a predictable storyline and some hackneyed slapstick. Nim’s Island currently stands at 48 percent on the Tomatomenter. (Take a look at a clip from the film here.)

Abigail Breslin won’t be so joyous when she realizes she’ll need to eat grubs and berries to survive.

It appears the folks behind The Ruins feared its critical reputation would be left in ruins, since it was barely screened before its release. Jonathan Tucker, Jena Malone, and Shawn Ashmore star in this tale of a group of tourists who find danger lurking at a remote archaeological site — an obvious oversight by the Lonely Planet people. Kids, take your noses out of that atlas and guess the Tomatometer!

“We should have brought a tent!”

Also opening this week in limited release:

The French import Water Lilies, a delicate coming-of-age drama involving a trio of middle school girls, is at 90 percent (check out our take from Cannes here);

Jellyfish, which follows three Israeli women as their lives intersect at a wedding reception, is at 87 percent;

Shine a Light, Martin Scorsese‘s document of the Rolling Stones live (with special guests like Jack White and Christina Aguilera), is at 82 percent (check out this week’s Total Recall for a look at some of Scorsese’s lesser-known work);

Flight of the Red Balloon, Hou Hsiao-hsien‘s remake of the French classic starring Juliette Binoche, is at 69 percent;

Wong Kar-Wai‘s latest, My Blueberry Nights starring Norah Jones, Jude Law, and Natalie Portman, is at 49 percent (check out our take here, and our interview with Jones here);

And Sex and Death 101, a black comedy starring Winona Ryder and Simon Baker, is at 40 percent.

“While I’ve got you guys here, I wanted to talk about my vision for Freejack 2…”

And finally, props to Grendel-san for correctly guessing Superhero Movie‘s 17 percent Tomatometer, presumably while doing battle with Beowulf-san. One question for ya, G.S: is it hard to type with only one arm?

Recent Jodie Foster Movies:
43% — The Brave One (2007)
87% — Inside Man (2006)
38% — Flightplan (2005)
77% — A Very Long Engagement (2004)
77% — The Dangerous Lives of Altar Boys (2002)

Recent George Clooney Movies:
91% — Michael Clayton (2007)
70% — Ocean’s Thirteen (2007)
33% — The Good German (2006)
73% — Syriana (2005)
94% — Good Night and Good Luck (2005)

Tag Cloud

Interview Adult Swim Discovery Channel psychological thriller breaking bad television classics Family Crackle NBC See It Skip It WarnerMedia Nominations BBC One Spectrum Originals animated technology crime Sony Pictures MCU E3 Arrowverse worst movies comiccon Teen facebook The Purge indie Fall TV Red Carpet binge Lifetime Christmas movies Mary Poppins Returns indiana jones Toys BBC children's TV justice league Podcast child's play Elton John miniseries A&E golden globes DirecTV nbcuniversal kids Pirates CNN superhero Warner Bros. ITV festivals spider-man adaptation MSNBC FXX GIFs ESPN Star Wars Academy Awards parents PBS The Arrangement Star Trek Syfy sports Amazon Prime Video Ghostbusters social media Black History Month rotten BBC America films Year in Review 2016 TNT game show talk show National Geographic The Witch Thanksgiving emmy awards Pet Sematary witnail Paramount Women's History Month Mindy Kaling theme song Character Guide Epix Mudbound Ellie Kemper Reality Competition Premiere Dates supernatural free movies TV renewals Film 20th Century Fox canceled TV shows game of thrones Pop MTV science fiction true crime toy story Binge Guide 4/20 FOX Creative Arts Emmys Rom-Com crossover Anna Paquin Set visit south america History Nickelodeon 2015 nature 72 Emmy Awards Walt Disney Pictures 71st Emmy Awards Christmas IFC Films mutant Marathons Best and Worst Television Critics Association TLC teaser NYCC Action Sneak Peek cats tv talk chucky Mary poppins anthology dceu VH1 asian-american WGN VICE Sundance werewolf directors Travel Channel Bravo OneApp Countdown Fantasy Columbia Pictures Paramount Network Disney Plus Holidays Pop TV comics Cosplay strong female leads ratings El Rey period drama Extras 2018 Grammys Film Festival X-Men best criterion Apple Comedy Central Election 2017 adventure YA harry potter movies Disney streaming service San Diego Comic-Con Turner foreign DC streaming service Sci-Fi medical drama Spring TV documentary Ovation Video Games New York Comic Con CBS Sundance TV Superheroes blaxploitation quibi Television Academy Food Network diversity movie Mystery casting screen actors guild batman critics political drama SXSW 2019 DC Universe Tomatazos Baby Yoda ABC hist Netflix Winners independent rotten movies we love Logo Infographic Fox News hollywood sitcom die hard Rocky First Look comic CBS All Access stop motion Lionsgate finale award winner Endgame Awards Tour Apple TV Plus Mary Tyler Moore sag awards mission: impossible Chilling Adventures of Sabrina USA aliens BAFTA PlayStation Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt cartoon A24 festival APB YouTube Red Britbox worst Comics on TV crime drama HBO Go serial killer Turner Classic Movies TCA 2017 sequels scary movies war renewed TV shows HBO dramedy HBO Max ghosts Netflix Christmas movies venice revenge TV Land sequel Sundance Now nfl satire fast and furious composers Superheroe Box Office TV Shudder Disney Channel scorecard stand-up comedy GoT USA Network SundanceTV toronto unscripted spy thriller CMT disaster Music BET vampires 21st Century Fox Rock BET Awards transformers Horror TruTV news canceled Classic Film Holiday dragons OWN DC Comics elevated horror jamie lee curtis historical drama Emmy Nominations Funimation book GLAAD hispanic a nightmare on elm street RT History travel Hallmark concert Certified Fresh cinemax Calendar Drama spinoff FX screenings Esquire christmas movies reboot Song of Ice and Fire Country cooking 007 Disney Super Bowl Shondaland anime Chernobyl Valentine's Day Amazon Prime Reality Captain marvel cops slashers Vudu Polls and Games Rocketman Marvel Television Quiz police drama Pride Month Musicals SDCC Watching Series latino Hallmark Christmas movies Avengers Cannes singing competition spanish language American Society of Cinematographers LGBT boxoffice based on movie YouTube Premium 24 frames natural history twilight spain streaming zombies video crime thriller comedies Cartoon Network DGA Martial Arts biography Trivia First Reviews TBS cancelled Peacock Kids & Family Amazon Studios Musical series cancelled television Nat Geo Starz Trailer Acorn TV Comic Book Black Mirror Marvel Writers Guild of America doctor who TCA Winter 2020 Tubi richard e. Grant blockbuster TCM Tumblr what to watch Summer politics LGBTQ zero dark thirty FX on Hulu dark Hear Us Out Spike dc Comedy Amazon RT21 documentaries halloween Western TCA Awards AMC joker cults Animation reviews PaleyFest cancelled TV series Showtime franchise Lucasfilm green book YouTube Tarantino remakes The CW Masterpiece VOD Stephen King universal monsters stoner Photos Lifetime name the review robots E! Dark Horse Comics Oscars video on demand psycho Apple TV+ zombie Heroines 45 Hulu Marvel Studios Crunchyroll Brie Larson IFC CW Seed space Winter TV Opinion Freeform cars President cancelled TV shows 2020 laika The Walking Dead Biopics TCA football mockumentary dogs romantic comedy discovery Universal Trophy Talk all-time Disney+ Disney Plus TIFF Emmys obituary Pixar romance Schedule docudrama thriller Awards versus ABC Family