Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Leatherheads Has its Ups and Downs; Nim's Island is Stranded; Guess The Ruins' Tomatometer!

Assessing the week in film criticism.

by | April 3, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got gridiron giggles (Leatherheads, starring George Clooney and Renée Zellweger), isle imagination (Nim’s Island, starring Jodie Foster and Abigail Breslin), and archeological anxiety (The Ruins, starring Shawn Ashmore and Jena Malone). What do the critics have to say?

George Clooney gets compared to Cary Grant all the time, so it’s only natural he would try his hand at Grant’s prime métier — the screwball comedy. Unfortunately, critics say the football laffer Leatherheads, in which Clooney stars and directs, is something of a mixed bag. Set in the early days of pro-pigskin (in the days when college was king), Leatherheads tells the tale of the struggling, ragtag Duluth squad, which has scored a major coup by tapping a college gridiron hero (played by John Krasinski) to team with aging pro Dodge Connolly (Clooney); however, the team is also under fire from an aggressive beat reporter (Renée Zellweger). The pundits say Leatherheads is a funny, amiable affair, but it could take some pointers from the no-huddle offense, which, like screwball comedy, emphasizes quick thinking, deft interaction, and risk. At 54 percent on the Tomatometer, Leatherheads is being thrown for a loss. And it’s Clooney’s worst-reviewed directorial effort to date — well below Good Night and Good Luck‘s 94 percent. (Check out our interview with George Clooney here.)

“Look, we’re running a flea flicker, and that’s final! Do I look like I’m negotiating?

A sort of Swiss Family Robinson crossed with Indiana Jones, the critics say Nim’s Island is solid family fare — with the pros and cons that implies. Abigail Breslin stars as Nim, a precocious girl who lives on a South Pacific island with her father (Gerard Butler), a scientist; when he goes missing, Nim turns to the hero of her favorite book (also played by Butler) — and the tome’s author (Jodie Foster) — for help. Critics say Nim’s Island has an old-fashioned sense of wonder and adventure — as well as a healthy dose of girl power — that makes for an above-average kids’ adventure. But they also note the movie offers a predictable storyline and some hackneyed slapstick. Nim’s Island currently stands at 48 percent on the Tomatomenter. (Take a look at a clip from the film here.)

Abigail Breslin won’t be so joyous when she realizes she’ll need to eat grubs and berries to survive.

It appears the folks behind The Ruins feared its critical reputation would be left in ruins, since it was barely screened before its release. Jonathan Tucker, Jena Malone, and Shawn Ashmore star in this tale of a group of tourists who find danger lurking at a remote archaeological site — an obvious oversight by the Lonely Planet people. Kids, take your noses out of that atlas and guess the Tomatometer!

“We should have brought a tent!”

Also opening this week in limited release:

The French import Water Lilies, a delicate coming-of-age drama involving a trio of middle school girls, is at 90 percent (check out our take from Cannes here);

Jellyfish, which follows three Israeli women as their lives intersect at a wedding reception, is at 87 percent;

Shine a Light, Martin Scorsese‘s document of the Rolling Stones live (with special guests like Jack White and Christina Aguilera), is at 82 percent (check out this week’s Total Recall for a look at some of Scorsese’s lesser-known work);

Flight of the Red Balloon, Hou Hsiao-hsien‘s remake of the French classic starring Juliette Binoche, is at 69 percent;

Wong Kar-Wai‘s latest, My Blueberry Nights starring Norah Jones, Jude Law, and Natalie Portman, is at 49 percent (check out our take here, and our interview with Jones here);

And Sex and Death 101, a black comedy starring Winona Ryder and Simon Baker, is at 40 percent.

“While I’ve got you guys here, I wanted to talk about my vision for Freejack 2…”

And finally, props to Grendel-san for correctly guessing Superhero Movie‘s 17 percent Tomatometer, presumably while doing battle with Beowulf-san. One question for ya, G.S: is it hard to type with only one arm?

Recent Jodie Foster Movies:
43% — The Brave One (2007)
87% — Inside Man (2006)
38% — Flightplan (2005)
77% — A Very Long Engagement (2004)
77% — The Dangerous Lives of Altar Boys (2002)

Recent George Clooney Movies:
91% — Michael Clayton (2007)
70% — Ocean’s Thirteen (2007)
33% — The Good German (2006)
73% — Syriana (2005)
94% — Good Night and Good Luck (2005)

Tag Cloud

Opinion Marvel Studios Funimation technology Baby Yoda Apple TV+ Mary Poppins Returns mockumentary Summer international medical drama NYCC hispanic 4/20 Polls and Games Elton John ABC superman Travel Channel TV Land children's TV series cooking Logo Lifetime Christmas movies Schedule football indiana jones Peacock dark CW Seed Extras new star wars movies 2021 TCA Awards Comedy 24 frames IFC Films Acorn TV scary movies Mystery Ovation black CBS National Geographic DC Comics talk show Fall TV Box Office dogs doctor who Rocky zero dark thirty Awards Tour godzilla comic classics WarnerMedia Emmys child's play canceled lord of the rings PBS period drama target hollywood Rocketman Emmy Nominations 2015 Christmas BBC Biopics FX Western PaleyFest 2018 Crunchyroll RT History VICE Film Mudbound FXX king kong Captain marvel kids reviews Photos die hard 45 Adult Swim Binge Guide AMC Certified Fresh cancelled TV shows Amazon Studios Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt marvel cinematic universe VH1 serial killer golden globes Trivia DGA Amazon Musicals Chilling Adventures of Sabrina films Discovery Channel Trophy Talk sag awards foreign 72 Emmy Awards Reality Competition Superheroes screen actors guild TCM Character Guide new york TIFF justice league comedies breaking bad Toys anime crime thriller American Society of Cinematographers OneApp Martial Arts zombie Columbia Pictures toronto FX on Hulu Song of Ice and Fire video on demand Rom-Com nfl The Walt Disney Company Walt Disney Pictures Image Comics ABC Family asian-american stoner DirecTV Horror Premiere Dates game of thrones italian chucky australia Awards space book adaptation travel harry potter anthology Endgame YouTube Premium sports singing competition crime The CW dragons Film Festival Teen book rom-coms TV movies fast and furious Paramount Plus cults Black History Month Freeform james bond First Reviews 2019 spain streaming A&E Superheroe casting monster movies crossover saw Trailer SundanceTV halloween tv Anna Paquin robots Netflix Christmas movies BAFTA cars BBC One scorecard Countdown Paramount Network Tumblr Pet Sematary Nat Geo BET Awards golden globe awards Alien screenings Grammys ratings nature romantic comedy dceu Red Carpet First Look psychological thriller 71st Emmy Awards Marvel Television diversity TV Hallmark Christmas movies science fiction telelvision Family women Disney Plus discovery remakes Country Winter TV unscripted Mindy Kaling Winners Pixar composers President boxing Sundance Now richard e. Grant A24 werewolf Tubi criterion Women's History Month Action Apple TV Plus ABC Signature cartoon 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards worst spanish Star Wars animated Tarantino blockbusters Crackle Thanksgiving Comics on TV SDCC kaiju south america heist movie halloween award winner Kids & Family a nightmare on elm street Shondaland docudrama Sneak Peek TV renewals kong stop motion Star Trek christmas movies sitcom Hulu green book deadpool Dark Horse Comics boxoffice jamie lee curtis Warner Bros. CBS All Access transformers Comedy Central festival YA Avengers Comic Book The Academy rt archives Set visit The Purge Broadway FOX festivals slashers Pride Month WGN psycho aliens strong female leads high school ghosts japanese CNN TNT Holiday war OWN spanish language DC Universe Lifetime sequels movie all-time Pirates latino joker 2020 21st Century Fox Disney Channel IFC free movies Esquire hist Fantasy laika Bravo GIFs critics Hallmark TruTV Pop TV ID Music 007 PlayStation Video Games Creative Arts Emmys Vudu natural history razzies Lionsgate disaster LGBTQ E3 jurassic park mutant Cartoon Network Valentine's Day Hear Us Out Oscars thriller spider-man movies USA Network twilight cancelled television universal monsters fresh docuseries true crime what to watch canceled TV shows renewed TV shows Disney adaptation Fox News ESPN The Witch Exclusive Video TLC politics tv talk See It Skip It Black Mirror venice scene in color Paramount crime drama game show revenge Showtime Ellie Kemper Masterpiece HBO Max indie parents teaser Heroines Pacific Islander Nickelodeon social media elevated horror Rock spy thriller Watching Series cinemax HBO Go Turner Classic Movies dramedy MCU SXSW Amazon Prime concert X-Men Marathons toy story El Rey Sundance TV GLAAD historical drama superhero sequel blaxploitation cops 2017 Best and Worst hidden camera best Sci-Fi quibi Lucasfilm Spike Academy Awards directors ITV NBC Musical Universal Stephen King rotten Disney streaming service emmy awards E! The Walking Dead 93rd Oscars APB Drama television Super Bowl USA Food Network versus political drama based on movie Starz 20th Century Fox HBO Classic Film Ghostbusters TBS Sundance 2016 satire binge adventure vampires spinoff blockbuster Holidays popular Cosplay miniseries video batman obituary facebook GoT pirates of the caribbean TCA romance supernatural BET Spring TV dc comic books name the review The Arrangement Tomatazos Amazon Prime Video nbcuniversal streaming movies Syfy worst movies documentaries Arrowverse stand-up comedy zombies Election new zealand franchise Pop YouTube Television Academy Infographic Legendary witnail RT21 Animation Apple CMT prank Podcast Epix New York Comic Con documentary live action MSNBC History Cannes Marvel Television Critics Association Quiz archives BBC America independent cancelled TV series finale cats biography aapi reboot police drama MTV 99% ViacomCBS Turner comiccon Disney+ Disney Plus Interview DC streaming service Shudder San Diego Comic-Con Writers Guild of America Britbox Spectrum Originals Reality Netflix know your critic LGBT french YouTube Red rotten movies we love Calendar TV One comics Mary Tyler Moore news Nominations cancelled Year in Review TCA 2017 mission: impossible theme song TCA Winter 2020 trailers Mary poppins Brie Larson Chernobyl VOD Fox Searchlight Sony Pictures