Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Leatherheads Has its Ups and Downs; Nim's Island is Stranded; Guess The Ruins' Tomatometer!

Assessing the week in film criticism.

by | April 3, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got gridiron giggles (Leatherheads, starring George Clooney and Renée Zellweger), isle imagination (Nim’s Island, starring Jodie Foster and Abigail Breslin), and archeological anxiety (The Ruins, starring Shawn Ashmore and Jena Malone). What do the critics have to say?

George Clooney gets compared to Cary Grant all the time, so it’s only natural he would try his hand at Grant’s prime métier — the screwball comedy. Unfortunately, critics say the football laffer Leatherheads, in which Clooney stars and directs, is something of a mixed bag. Set in the early days of pro-pigskin (in the days when college was king), Leatherheads tells the tale of the struggling, ragtag Duluth squad, which has scored a major coup by tapping a college gridiron hero (played by John Krasinski) to team with aging pro Dodge Connolly (Clooney); however, the team is also under fire from an aggressive beat reporter (Renée Zellweger). The pundits say Leatherheads is a funny, amiable affair, but it could take some pointers from the no-huddle offense, which, like screwball comedy, emphasizes quick thinking, deft interaction, and risk. At 54 percent on the Tomatometer, Leatherheads is being thrown for a loss. And it’s Clooney’s worst-reviewed directorial effort to date — well below Good Night and Good Luck‘s 94 percent. (Check out our interview with George Clooney here.)

“Look, we’re running a flea flicker, and that’s final! Do I look like I’m negotiating?

A sort of Swiss Family Robinson crossed with Indiana Jones, the critics say Nim’s Island is solid family fare — with the pros and cons that implies. Abigail Breslin stars as Nim, a precocious girl who lives on a South Pacific island with her father (Gerard Butler), a scientist; when he goes missing, Nim turns to the hero of her favorite book (also played by Butler) — and the tome’s author (Jodie Foster) — for help. Critics say Nim’s Island has an old-fashioned sense of wonder and adventure — as well as a healthy dose of girl power — that makes for an above-average kids’ adventure. But they also note the movie offers a predictable storyline and some hackneyed slapstick. Nim’s Island currently stands at 48 percent on the Tomatomenter. (Take a look at a clip from the film here.)

Abigail Breslin won’t be so joyous when she realizes she’ll need to eat grubs and berries to survive.

It appears the folks behind The Ruins feared its critical reputation would be left in ruins, since it was barely screened before its release. Jonathan Tucker, Jena Malone, and Shawn Ashmore star in this tale of a group of tourists who find danger lurking at a remote archaeological site — an obvious oversight by the Lonely Planet people. Kids, take your noses out of that atlas and guess the Tomatometer!

“We should have brought a tent!”

Also opening this week in limited release:

The French import Water Lilies, a delicate coming-of-age drama involving a trio of middle school girls, is at 90 percent (check out our take from Cannes here);

Jellyfish, which follows three Israeli women as their lives intersect at a wedding reception, is at 87 percent;

Shine a Light, Martin Scorsese‘s document of the Rolling Stones live (with special guests like Jack White and Christina Aguilera), is at 82 percent (check out this week’s Total Recall for a look at some of Scorsese’s lesser-known work);

Flight of the Red Balloon, Hou Hsiao-hsien‘s remake of the French classic starring Juliette Binoche, is at 69 percent;

Wong Kar-Wai‘s latest, My Blueberry Nights starring Norah Jones, Jude Law, and Natalie Portman, is at 49 percent (check out our take here, and our interview with Jones here);

And Sex and Death 101, a black comedy starring Winona Ryder and Simon Baker, is at 40 percent.

“While I’ve got you guys here, I wanted to talk about my vision for Freejack 2…”

And finally, props to Grendel-san for correctly guessing Superhero Movie‘s 17 percent Tomatometer, presumably while doing battle with Beowulf-san. One question for ya, G.S: is it hard to type with only one arm?

Recent Jodie Foster Movies:
43% — The Brave One (2007)
87% — Inside Man (2006)
38% — Flightplan (2005)
77% — A Very Long Engagement (2004)
77% — The Dangerous Lives of Altar Boys (2002)

Recent George Clooney Movies:
91% — Michael Clayton (2007)
70% — Ocean’s Thirteen (2007)
33% — The Good German (2006)
73% — Syriana (2005)
94% — Good Night and Good Luck (2005)

Tag Cloud

DC Comics medical drama singing competition PlayStation NBC children's TV video on demand WarnerMedia Comics on TV dceu golden globes nature nfl biography Stephen King technology 20th Century Fox Syfy TCA Awards 2018 Instagram Live book adaptation aliens independent Action versus PaleyFest Crackle transformers godzilla directors pirates of the caribbean ViacomCBS war 21st Century Fox Film science fiction Summer blockbusters Mary poppins Drama streaming Sneak Peek Apple TV+ obituary National Geographic Mudbound cancelled TV series fresh Musicals discovery italian king kong 2019 Quiz trailers Star Wars Freeform GIFs saw Emmy Nominations Martial Arts BET Awards FXX satire Family scary movies BBC One The Witch Mary Tyler Moore rotten movies we love Epix hist Marathons GLAAD Black Mirror james bond dragons NBA marvel cinematic universe Music rt archives disaster Universal Pictures vs. ghosts Dark Horse Comics Hulu ID Black History Month Mindy Kaling 2016 cartoon BBC Peacock political drama 2020 indiana jones zero dark thirty adenture dreamworks spider-verse 72 Emmy Awards Comedy scorecard Logo American Society of Cinematographers mcc Crunchyroll kong 93rd Oscars Sony Pictures nbcuniversal Ghostbusters critic resources Anna Paquin FOX TCM cancelled TV shows VOD Elton John Marvel Studios Comedy Central based on movie Starz psychological thriller popular YouTube Premium MCU worst movies zombies criterion child's play sag awards Disney streaming service Universal cults telelvision screen actors guild Christmas 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards TV renewals Lionsgate politics documentary football BAFTA LGBTQ A24 SXSW Song of Ice and Fire rt labs all-time Superheroes latino Chilling Adventures of Sabrina sports laika Box Office See It Skip It RT History ABC ESPN legend canceled live event blockbuster zombie justice league 2015 spinoff christmas movies kaiju Mary Poppins Returns Teen superhero Nickelodeon cats Pet Sematary fast and furious police drama Country TCA 2017 cancelled television japan Disney Plus ABC Family series Reality Competition toronto scary First Reviews Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Spring TV screenings finale gangster Academy Awards foreign Rocky USA Network sitcom CNN TruTV Fantasy parents game show films dexter lord of the rings action-comedy Cosplay docudrama comic book movies debate Holidays TCA Winter 2020 HBO X-Men Grammys Brie Larson The Arrangement Netflix Christmas movies CW Seed french Awards adventure Year in Review japanese 24 frames Holiday mutant TV Land Sundance Schedule Film Festival asian-american Disney NYCC Hallmark critics batman name the review cars prank 99% Alien El Rey romance Character Guide unscripted Women's History Month Exclusive Video Watching Series die hard new zealand Rocketman crime drama MSNBC TV One The CW HBO Go posters IMDb TV Paramount Network HFPA Neflix Premiere Dates TLC Emmys australia anime E! Trophy Talk Turner 1990s Writers Guild of America Avengers A&E natural history cops social media TV movies Apple TV Plus CBS All Access south america CBS Tarantino Musical comics DC Universe Winter TV canceled TV shows game of thrones Shudder IFC Awards Tour Tokyo Olympics spider-man Nat Geo binge live action SDCC Extras Pixar Apple travel Masterpiece OneApp Sundance Now Election superman Chernobyl The Walt Disney Company hispanic heritage month chucky Acorn TV joker hollywood basketball emmy awards LGBT Amazon Prime Video remakes movies reboot thriller Superheroe Funimation crime thriller ITV Classic Film ratings know your critic IFC Films new star wars movies Podcast miniseries FX on Hulu Reality animated Ovation 73rd Emmy Awards Legendary psycho worst USA Pacific Islander richard e. Grant dramedy Lucasfilm witnail Television Critics Association Netflix stop motion Ellie Kemper vampires Comic Book Fox News crossover Bravo black Cartoon Network FX high school Marvel Binge Guide Tags: Comedy doctor who boxoffice Rom-Com jamie lee curtis Super Bowl green book Travel Channel jurassic park Tomatazos Cannes The Purge TIFF international women comic Best and Worst halloween tv Calendar Valentine's Day comic book movie Hallmark Christmas movies space Tubi robots sopranos heist movie dogs YouTube Polls and Games spain San Diego Comic-Con HBO Max Television Academy Kids & Family award winner DirecTV anthology VH1 Mystery PBS universal monsters talk show elevated horror cinemax crime franchise Pride Month 2017 theme song sequel GoT Spectrum Originals Pop TV Paramount Countdown Nominations E3 venice BET mockumentary twilight AMC Plus hidden camera cooking supernatural spy thriller rom-coms TNT Lifetime Christmas movies Western Hollywood Foreign Press Association tv talk rt labs critics edition hispanic Hear Us Out quibi cancelled archives spanish language period drama The Walking Dead stand-up comedy Vudu mission: impossible slasher Trailer video Walt Disney Pictures classics Lifetime New York Comic Con ABC Signature Esquire Disney+ Disney Plus news serial killer TBS reviews Baby Yoda Comic-Con@Home 2021 Sci-Fi toy story what to watch Paramount Plus indie wonder woman Image Comics Video Games spanish SundanceTV art house President TCA true crime Fall TV Discovery Channel historical drama 007 Thanksgiving festivals Photos royal family Captain marvel comedies suspense Opinion blaxploitation Spike Prime Video sequels DC streaming service composers Fox Searchlight adaptation History Creative Arts Emmys Showtime Heroines stoner biopic Shondaland halloween Infographic docuseries Toys Adult Swim diversity aapi Pirates 45 Marvel Television a nightmare on elm street Animation target golden globe awards Food Network DGA Horror VICE Pop facebook BBC America casting APB Endgame YouTube Red Tumblr book The Academy young adult Star Trek romantic comedy Interview 2021 TV Biopics genre dc Wes Anderson comiccon trophy werewolf streaming movies MTV AMC harry potter comic books 79th Golden Globes Awards boxing olympics YA mob Fargo television documentaries First Look razzies Rock rotten new york Set visit Arrowverse deadpool revenge 4/20 king arthur teaser Sundance TV Amazon movie 90s renewed TV shows Trivia marvel comics festival best Warner Bros. leaderboard kids 71st Emmy Awards RT21 Disney Channel Red Carpet Winners Britbox WGN CMT monster movies scene in color breaking bad Amazon Studios Turner Classic Movies slashers black comedy Broadway Oscars concert strong female leads Amazon Prime dark Certified Fresh free movies feel good OWN Columbia Pictures