6 Things To Know About the Writers of Amazon's Lord of the Rings Series

JD Payne and Patrick McKay are running the show, but you probably haven't heard of them. Here's what we found out - and what it could mean for the series.

by | July 29, 2018 | Comments

(Photo by Courtesy of Amazon)

This weekend, Amazon revealed the writers they hired to create their Lord of the Rings streaming series. Viewers still have not seen any credited work by JD Payne and Patrick McKay, so a lot of fans are still wondering just who are these guys who are going to take us back to Middle Earth?

Rotten Tomatoes did some research on the writing team of Payne and McKay. Through the latest announcements and some previous interviews with the writers, here is everything we found out the two men charged with brining Middle Earth to streaming.


(Photo by © Amazon)

Normally when a Network buys a show, they green light a creator’s take; to snag Lord of the Rings, Amazon won the bidding (rumored at $250 million) without any concept in place. Then they interviewed writers and creators to entertain different takes on the franchise. Payne and McKay won.

“It’s such a vast world, there are so many different ways to go with that property,” Head of Amazon Studios Jennifer Salke (pictured) said. “We had an abundance of enthusiasm in the creator/writer community for the project. So there was a lot of time spent talking about different takes. The next phase is a big development process as they build out this world.”


(Photo by © Paramount)

They’re not only writing the next Star Trek but have been attached to adaptations of Flash Gordon, Godzilla Vs. King Kong, Micronauts, Midas, Goliath, The Deadliest Warrior, and Boilerplate. They also worked on Star Trek: Beyond with Roberto Orci on a script so this will not be their first ride on the Starship Enterprise, although Doug Jung and Simon Pegg ended up finishing Beyond.

Payne and McKay wrote the upcoming Jungle Cruise movie for Dwayne Johnson, based on the Disneyland ride. Now, if they can get a whole movie out of a ride, then the Tolkien trilogy – plus prequel and appendices – should be more than enough source material for a long-running TV series.


(Photo by Courtesy of Amazon)

Payne gave an interview in 2014 to discuss his faith and his screenwriting career. Tolkien is a text often related to the Mormon Church, so perhaps he can bring that angle to the series.

During college Payne served in a mission in Rome. It was there he truly fell in love with telling stories. “While in Italy, in the hours and days and months of interacting incessantly with thousands of people, I became fixated upon the power of story,” McKay told MormonArtist.

Of course, many have cited religious parallels between Tolkien’s work and Mormonism and other religions. Since the show will not be adapted directly from the book, perhaps Payne will have a chance to draw new connections between religion in our world and in the world of Middle Earth, if he chooses to.


(Photo by © New Line)

According to Amazon’s press release, Payne and McKay met in a high school debate club. The 2014 interview puts their meeting in 1997. That’s two decades of writing and developing together, and by 2014 they had written 15 screenplays together, according to the Payne interview.

“Our worldviews are sometimes contrasting, but always complementary,” Payne told MormonArtist. “Between the two of us, we almost never get stuck, be it in brainstorming, pitching, drafting, revising, or any other part of the process.”

In an interview with TrekCore, McKay detailed more of their high school collaborations. They directed a play and then began wrrting one together. Payne went to Yale for engineering and McKay went to a creative writing grad school in Washington, D.C. but they remained partners.


Various sources report that the series will take place before The Fellowship of the Ring, with Tolkien site reporting that their sources say it will be about a young Aragorn, Viggo Mortensen’s character in the trilogy.

So, they’ll be called on to write original work – of sorts. Some of the original screenplays the duo have written include The Black List screenplay Escape. Law Zero was also to be an original futuristic sci-fi action movie for Warner Brothers, but it never got made.


(Photo by © New Line)

In the press release announcing their gig on Lord of the Rings, Payne and McKay said, “We feel like Frodo, setting out from the Shire, with a great responsibility in our care. It is the beginning of the adventure of a lifetime. The rich world that J.R.R. Tolkien created is filled with majesty and heart, wisdom and complexity.”

Now do those sound like guys to follow into Mordor or what?

Tag Cloud

Awards Tour legend SundanceTV ratings Walt Disney Pictures RT History Sci-Fi YouTube Red First Reviews stoner TCA 2017 women Brie Larson romantic comedy diversity unscripted Fox News MGM comic Sneak Peek Peacock Premiere Dates Amazon Prime Video Family Marathons rt archives PlayStation superman worst movies Turner Classic Movies Spectrum Originals Reality Competition batman zero dark thirty CNN AMC discovery DirecTV slashers CW Seed miniseries Film Festival Watching Series SXSW 2022 worst FOX nbcuniversal golden globe awards sitcom The Walking Dead BBC America space cancelled TV series Nickelodeon ABC Signature Women's History Month TV One Red Carpet Pacific Islander Emmy Nominations Best Actor The Witch 73rd Emmy Awards ABC Family Animation PaleyFest comic book movie concert based on movie BET 1990s Alien feel good ESPN stand-up comedy canceled Showtime 007 Star Wars remakes indie Tags: Comedy Cartoon Network Neflix police drama psycho Sony Pictures dceu comics VOD trophy independent Holiday Oscars LGBTQ obi wan ID popular golden globes Arrowverse OWN Nominations new york Emmys boxoffice rotten black comedy composers war richard e. Grant television Tarantino screenings Television Critics Association genre singing competition spain Masterpiece ITV 24 frames nature docudrama Drama festivals sequel directors TCM finale hidden camera OneApp deadpool aliens Rock National Geographic FX 90s Pirates book adaptation Academy Awards name the review TV movies Cosplay President TCA Awards basketball adventure biopic elevated horror pirates of the caribbean boxing Christmas doctor who Food Network 21st Century Fox theme song Disney ViacomCBS fresh X-Men live action TBS Schedule Netflix Christmas movies Crunchyroll Mystery HBO Max cancelled television cancelled TV shows young adult Tomatazos Legendary Mary Tyler Moore HBO mutant 2016 know your critic dark movies transformers justice league royal family Syfy Best Actress Universal Pictures Instagram Live obituary Rocketman book Horror Amazon Studios PBS cults Fox Searchlight Holidays facebook dexter Esquire Biopics kaiju Western The Walt Disney Company jamie lee curtis American Society of Cinematographers revenge Best Picture Creative Arts Emmys Opinion Video Games blockbuster art house Stephen King LGBT serial killer Mudbound social media scary Paramount cinemax anthology streaming movies Music Hallmark BBC One kong hispanic heritage month USA canceled TV shows Reality Apple TV Plus SXSW venice 20th Century Fox festival Calendar comedies spinoff Disney+ Disney Plus foreign green book Mary Poppins Returns chucky Amazon dragons true crime strong female leads Superheroe MCU politics docuseries aapi NBA Quiz Comic Book 45 cartoon supernatural best historical drama Lifetime E3 rotten movies we love spanish Discovery Channel dramedy 2018 harry potter Trivia razzies Captain marvel renewed TV shows Song of Ice and Fire cars blockbusters breaking bad high school Year in Review Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt heist movie new star wars movies crime thriller classics anime SDCC slasher spider-man olympics E! 2015 Action Comic-Con@Home 2021 godzilla Wes Anderson talk show prank comiccon NYCC binge dreamworks documentary APB Grammys FX on Hulu vs. Universal Exclusive Video DC Universe marvel cinematic universe MSNBC ABC TV Star Trek spy thriller natural history archives TNT biography Writers Guild of America medical drama satire The Purge 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Shudder technology die hard spanish language halloween tv Valentine's Day Logo 72 Emmy Awards Martial Arts blaxploitation rt labs critics edition christmas movies Columbia Pictures emmy awards Fall TV psychological thriller Apple See It Skip It Black Mirror award winner Anna Paquin Image Comics Avengers Britbox latino Baby Yoda YouTube what to watch italian Toys disaster TLC reboot kids nfl GIFs critics Cannes child's play Comedy Central films video on demand Chernobyl rom-coms free movies universal monsters Rom-Com Vudu cooking GoT 79th Golden Globes Awards Tokyo Olympics BAFTA TruTV french jurassic park Superheroes sequels Sundance Now Musicals Film monster movies cancelled Pop TV VICE Nat Geo RT21 Hollywood Foreign Press Association Winter TV Fargo BET Awards Lucasfilm laika Thanksgiving casting dc Tumblr WGN hispanic action-comedy Disney Plus mob scene in color Extras Disney streaming service a nightmare on elm street robots halloween Netflix joker 2017 2021 2019 Freeform CBS All Access japan Disney Channel Paramount Plus rt labs superhero The Arrangement Summer Adult Swim TCA Winter 2020 target scary movies A24 Kids & Family Teen Pet Sematary adenture Ovation mcc Broadway stop motion zombie Super Bowl Trailer HBO Go ghosts asian-american Character Guide series international sopranos Set visit Oscar Binge Guide quibi Marvel Television parents DC Comics Musical Turner versus San Diego Comic-Con fast and furious Prime Video hollywood Funimation lord of the rings video VH1 Elton John twilight trailers DGA crime Trophy Talk black Marvel Studios Travel Channel Bravo Ellie Kemper children's TV Marvel Election news debate Fantasy werewolf vampires saw NBC japanese south america Epix cats king arthur australia TCA Classic Film wonder woman posters documentaries Polls and Games indiana jones scorecard suspense El Rey Certified Fresh Heroines Podcast Lifetime Christmas movies HFPA hist Best and Worst Pride Month tv talk DC streaming service Hallmark Christmas movies teaser thriller Mary poppins The CW Comics on TV MTV Pixar football Amazon Prime Endgame Spike critic resources GLAAD New York Comic Con king kong Shondaland adaptation Sundance IFC Films Interview sag awards WarnerMedia IMDb TV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Box Office travel new zealand Crackle BBC Spring TV Black History Month Dark Horse Comics Comedy reviews Best Director franchise streamig james bond 99% 93rd Oscars Tubi 2020 Pop 71st Emmy Awards Warner Bros. Hulu game show mockumentary Acorn TV comic book movies Winners science fiction Television Academy AMC Plus TV Land Sundance TV CMT spider-verse 4/20 Starz History dogs sports Paramount Network romance Photos TIFF IFC criterion A&E toronto YA Infographic all-time screen actors guild Lionsgate streaming Mindy Kaling Rocky mission: impossible South by Southwest Film Festival period drama YouTube Premium game of thrones toy story animated zombies crime drama political drama telelvision gangster Awards Ghostbusters Hear Us Out FXX movie marvel comics 94th Oscars The Academy Country TV renewals CBS Countdown First Look Apple TV+ witnail cops leaderboard crossover live event comic books USA Network