Critics Consensus

The Nun Is No Fun

Plus, Peppermint lacks flavor, Mayans M.C. is solid, USA's The Purge is bloated, and God Bless the Broken Road is too earnest for its own good.

by | September 6, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we have a cloistered demon (The Nun, starring Taissa Farmiga and Demian Bechir), one super ticked off widow (Peppermint, starring Jennifer Garner), and a country song come to life (God Bless the Broken Road, starring Lindsay Pulsipher and Makenzie Moss). What are the critics saying?


The Nun (2018) 26%

Taking something ostensibly safe, trustworthy, or benign and turning it sinister is one of the oldest and most effective tricks in the horror movie playbook. The suburbs, babies, grandparents — they’ve all been twisted in genre cinema’s chilly grasp, and given the deep-seated emotions many people have regarding religion, it’s no surprise that its tenets and imagery have long ranked among filmmakers’ favorite nightmare fuel. With this weekend’s The Nun, producer James Wan expands his burgeoning Conjuring cinematic universe by giving the demon Valak, one of The Conjuring 2‘s scarier creatures, her own standalone feature — and explaining the backstory of the wimpled menace along the way. Of course, as horror fans are all too aware, it’s often what we can’t see, don’t know, and don’t understand that proves scariest; go back to one boogeyman too often, and its effectiveness can rapidly diminish. According to the critics, that’s exactly what’s happened with The Nun, which hurls a series of jump scares at the audience in order to try and cover up for a slow and familiar story. We’ve seen Conjuring spinoff franchises struggle out of the gate before, so here’s hoping if there’s a follow-up, the reviews are kinder; overall, this is still one of the better mainstream horror series going, and it’d be a real shame if it made a (cough) habit of earning disappointing Tomatometers.


Peppermint (2018) 13%

As the star of the long-running hit series Alias, Jennifer Garner proved herself more than capable of playing a believable action hero — but when she started cracking skulls on the big screen in Daredevil and its spinoff Elektra, the results were less than spectacular. More than a decade after the latter film crashed and burned in theaters, Garner’s got a shot at genre redemption with Peppermint, in which she plays a woman who nearly dies in an attack that kills her husband and daughter — and after emerging from a yearlong coma, dedicates herself to exacting revenge on the people responsible. Sadly, critics say she needn’t have bothered; while Garner remains a charismatic screen presence, and more than a few reviews have given her credit for her clear commitment to the role, it still doesn’t add up to much besides reheated Death Wish, with all the borderline irresponsible fearmongering that goes with the territory. If you’re seriously in the mood to watch some bad guys get thunked this weekend, Peppermint might do the trick — but then again, you could also just watch a better-made vigilante thriller instead.


God Bless the Broken Road (2018) 18%

While one wide release uses religious iconography to give filmgoers the willies this weekend, God Bless the Broken Road takes an altogether different faith-based direction. Helmed by God’s Not Dead director Harold Cronk, this drama — which takes its title from Marcus Hummon’s oft-covered country single — adapts the Jennifer Dornbush novel of the same name to tell the story of a single mom (Lindsay Pulsipher) struggling to put her life back together after her husband is killed in action during a tour of duty with the U.S. Army in Afghanistan. When her nine-year-old daughter (Makenzie Moss) befriends a racecar driver (Andrew Walker), love starts to bloom… only to be threatened by our grieving protagonist’s fear of losing another beau to a dangerous vocation. You pretty much know where this is all heading, which is a big part of why the target demographic responds to it — and why critics tend to turn up their noses at it. We’ve still only seen a handful of reviews for Broken Road, but early returns suggest this will be yet another earnest, religion-tinged drama that hits a hard dead end with the pundits. If it’s in your wheelhouse, odds are that won’t make much of a difference.


What’s New on TV

Mayans M.C.: Season 1 (2018) 72%

Mayans M.C. is a thrilling drama with compelling characters, but it struggles to find its pace and the Tellers are hard to forget.


The Purge: Season 1 (2018) 42%

Bloated and boring, The Purge kills its own fleetingly fun premise and proves that not all stories work better on the small screen.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • I Am Not a Witch (2018) , about a young Zambian girl accused of witchcraft after an incident in her school, is Certified Fresh at 100%.
  • Bisbee '17 (2018) , a documentary about a town’s reckoning with a painful chapter in its past, is at 95%.
  • Hal (2018) , a documentary tribute to the filmmaking career of director Hal Ashby, is at 90%.
  • Kusama: Infinity (2018) , a documentary about the life and career of artist Yayoi Kusama, is at 82%.
  • Diane (2018) , a supernatural horror outing in which a war veteran crosses paths with a corpse and quickly regrets it, is at 80%.
  • Five Fingers for Marseilles (2018) , an apartheid-era drama about the battles fought by the members of a small South African gang, is at 80%.
  • The Apparition (L'apparition) (2018) , in which a French journalist is sent to investigate reports of a supernatural occurrence in a small village, is at 70%.
  • Cold Skin (2018) , a sci-fi/horror story about a meteorologist whose remote assignment is far more dangerous than he realized, is at 53%.

Tag Cloud

Amazon Musicals justice league SXSW elevated horror IFC AMC E3 YouTube Premium USA Shondaland biography PaleyFest HBO Hulu SundanceTV Drama comiccon golden globes CW Seed miniseries Action Country police drama ratings toy story CNN Disney Channel binge medical drama mutant CBS All Access Syfy Oscars doctor who Spring TV TruTV talk show award winner true crime Super Bowl Britbox Mystery Year in Review Ellie Kemper Infographic Election Star Wars richard e. Grant San Diego Comic-Con vampires Watching Series Universal Comics on TV Sundance LGBTQ Trailer RT History 20th Century Fox politics TBS Animation Opinion TV Mary Poppins Returns MSNBC theme song Starz Fox News romance ABC Family Rom-Com The Arrangement NYCC space aliens casting History 2016 2019 Pirates Comic Book Freeform Countdown Lucasfilm BBC America based on movie Calendar anthology Horror facebook crime drama composers psycho mockumentary A&E cops Sneak Peek Pride Month MCU OWN TCA Set visit New York Comic Con YouTube Red Vudu IFC Films Trivia The CW TCA 2017 Captain marvel TCM Cartoon Network spinoff green book social media 007 nature spider-man Cosplay MTV sequel Acorn TV cults DGA PBS teaser Pop boxoffice NBC Kids & Family Musical X-Men Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Emmys Toys spy thriller Winter TV Photos transformers Rocky APB Western Summer adventure DC streaming service science fiction Fantasy FOX Thanksgiving blaxploitation finale thriller natural history dc Martial Arts Quiz Bravo 2018 DirecTV Holidays streaming Schedule Apple Superheroe TV Land BET Tomatazos discovery First Look Logo Red Carpet Chilling Adventures of Sabrina what to watch Amazon Prime USA Network El Rey hist American Society of Cinematographers comic ABC Extras Interview political drama Film Festival Masterpiece Ovation CMT Reality Competition crossover Food Network singing competition animated Reality SDCC WGN Music 45 Best and Worst strong female leads 2015 Mudbound witnail zombies zero dark thirty See It Skip It Trophy Talk VICE President 24 frames Spike Fall TV Heroines Tumblr Cannes Shudder TNT FX Black Mirror game show cooking Spectrum Originals CBS Esquire Awards Walt Disney Pictures FXX Winners festivals Teen historical drama Sci-Fi Podcast Stephen King Christmas psychological thriller Premiere Dates Anna Paquin E! Crackle sports Tarantino Valentine's Day Women's History Month Comedy Central crime thriller Polls and Games Paramount Song of Ice and Fire war Epix serial killer diversity adaptation zombie anime Ghostbusters Rock harry potter Nickelodeon Lifetime Creative Arts Emmys Pixar television Paramount Network DC Comics National Geographic Nominations DC Universe unscripted Writers Guild of America Character Guide Disney travel 21st Century Fox The Witch Brie Larson TIFF Mary Tyler Moore docudrama Elton John Superheroes GLAAD TLC RT21 Biopics ITV Awards Tour Marathons Marvel Rocketman cats Comedy GoT jamie lee curtis robots GIFs dragons 2017 Sundance Now Mary poppins period drama Certified Fresh supernatural Lionsgate Showtime Columbia Pictures Chernobyl Sony Pictures technology Nat Geo disaster Adult Swim Netflix crime BBC Box Office Star Trek Video Games ESPN LGBT Mindy Kaling YA Dark Horse Comics sitcom cinemax VH1 dceu Pet Sematary dramedy Grammys Warner Bros.