Marvel Movie Madness! Part 30: Iron Man

by | July 15, 2011 | Comments

Enter Marvel Movie Madness, wherein Rotten Tomatoes watches all of the significant Marvel movies ever made. Full Marvel Movie Madness list here. Tune in! We give you our thoughts, and you give us yours.

[rtimage]siteImageId=10244711[/rtimage]

Part 30: Iron Man (2008, 94% @ 234 reviews)

Directed by Jon Faverau, starring Robert Downey Jr., Terrence Howard, Jeff Bridges, Gwyneth Paltrow

Tim: Hands down, Iron Man is my favorite Marvel movie. For me, Robert Downey Jr.’s performance as Tony Stark — a cross between Steve Jobs and James Bond — is pitch-perfect. He’s a charming rogue with a conscience, someone who you can relate to and dream of being. (And unlike most wiseacre heroes, Tony Stark’s witty bon mots seem to come more from the mouth of someone who’s supremely self-confident — not a screenwriter.) Downey’s performance is the highlight, but Iron Man gets just about everything else right as well. Too many blockbusters feel the need to throw everything at the screen in clumps, but Iron Man is remarkably well-paced; it gives the story and its characters room to breathe, and its (admittedly awesome) special effects never overwhelm the narrative. The action sequences are stupendous, but never arbitrary — this is a movie that trusts the audience will stay entertained without resorting to explosions every five minutes.

A lot of filmmakers seemed hamstrung by the wars in the Middle East, but Iron Man is one of the few films that successfully asked important questions about American foreign policy without resorting to didacticism or bludgeoning the audience with agitprop. At heart, Iron Man is the tale of a man who seems to really question his place in the world and use his energy and intellect to make things right. I love the scene where Tony is watching a news documentary on a terrorized Afghan village and immediately springs into action; who hasn’t been weighted down by the struggles of decent people around the world? Who hasn’t wished they could do something — anything — to make a difference? Fortunately, Iron Man leavens its geo-political commentary with plenty of good humor and some terrific musical cues (AC/DC’s “Back in Black,” Suicidal Tendencies’ “Institutionalized”). It all adds up to a terrific good time, one of the best comic book adaptations ever.

[rtimage]siteImageId=10244712[/rtimage]

Alex: 2008 was my favorite year for comic book movies. I think many would incline to agree. By then, the comic book movie industry was in full steam — we’ve been watching a lot of superhero movies, with entire trilogies opened and closed. I look back in 2008 with particular fondness since, as the comic book movie threatened to fall into a pattern, two movies released which foresaw two different visions for the future of the genre: The Dark Knight (serious and elegant) and Iron Man (bright and zippy), with both telling their type of story to maximum effect.

The Iron Man movies challenge themselves to get by on the least amount of action possible, driving instead on its high-tech world and sheer cast charisma, especially and obviously Robert Downey Jr. I like Iron Man as middle age wish fulfillment cinema: There’s something joyous in watching a dude (albeit a millionaire genius dude) come to the realization that, yes, he can fit into this world as a superhero. The action scenes exhibit a cool restraint, avoiding the showy flash that would obscure Iron Man’s key simple fact: underneath all the armor is just a man who at last discovers his sense of peace and justice.

And the ending — “I am Iron Man” — is perfection.

[rtimage]siteImageId=10244713[/rtimage]

Jeff: I think we’re all at least a little ambivalent about the way Hollywood’s gotten drunk on special effects over the last 10 to 15 years or so, but Iron Man is a great example of a movie that couldn’t have been made before the CGI invasion. And we all would have been poorer for it — this is a funny, exciting, effortlessly entertaining burst of superhero action.

Plenty of people had their doubts about Iron Man going in, and for good reason — Tony Stark has been a Marvel keystone for decades, but he was never really absorbed into pop culture the way Spider-Man, Superman, or Batman were, and on top of that, Iron Man doesn’t have the most cinema-ready villains. But as you pointed out, Alex, Iron Man is less dependent on big action set pieces than it is on human drama — and it’s carried by an absolutely stellar cast.


More Marvel Movie Madness:

Tag Cloud

Certified Fresh Action Toys TCM travel USA Network medical drama Premiere Dates Super Bowl sitcom comiccon Amazon Nat Geo Western Netflix CMT Winter TV Best and Worst NYCC BBC crime drama Box Office Grammys Reality Competition discovery boxoffice golden globes Dark Horse Comics Character Guide RT History First Look History Disney Hulu Sci-Fi Comic Book crime serial killer 2016 Holidays Music Christmas cinemax Valentine's Day dc Showtime Opinion Thanksgiving Country Schedule CW Seed Ghostbusters Superheroe cults 2017 Infographic President Countdown Universal GoT zombie 20th Century Fox vampires Rocky politics Reality TV Land Star Wars Set visit dceu Extras Rom-Com GIFs Drama BBC America Disney Channel ABC Family science fiction Fox News Tumblr adventure Crackle crime thriller Kids & Family CNN 21st Century Fox Paramount Network Rock ITV based on movie Star Trek sports Red Carpet dramedy Mindy Kaling Nickelodeon X-Men 24 frames Sundance FXX DirecTV Musicals WGN Fantasy romance Esquire TIFF DC streaming service Nominations Cosplay 2015 psycho Winners Ellie Kemper Warner Bros. biography Superheroes E3 Bravo Musical El Rey Sneak Peek SDCC YouTube Red cops SundanceTV Calendar Emmys LGBTQ APB HBO American Society of Cinematographers ratings police drama Comedy Pop VICE transformers justice league thriller Masterpiece Acorn TV TCA 2017 Polls and Games The CW Tomatazos supernatural Writers Guild of America technology Freeform MSNBC Adult Swim DC Comics Logo Spring TV Martial Arts Trailer VH1 PaleyFest Oscars Comedy Central Video Games Food Network composers spy thriller Spike TCA CBS All Access TBS historical drama TLC Photos Teen Cartoon Network Summer Election CBS IFC diversity FOX Podcast Awards cooking unscripted OWN docudrama Trivia IFC Films Fall TV aliens Lucasfilm period drama TruTV YA Creative Arts Emmys Pirates Mystery Biopics binge ABC Mary Tyler Moore Lifetime Lionsgate ESPN Britbox PBS Sony Pictures FX Marvel Marathons Syfy E! AMC war Pixar Horror social media Paramount GLAAD Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Starz Year in Review singing competition Animation See It Skip It 007 cats BET Sundance Now A&E TV USA harry potter The Arrangement 45 MTV Interview political drama talk show DC Universe what to watch TNT Watching Series NBC