How Does "The Departed" Rank Among Oscar's Best?

by | February 26, 2007 | Comments

So Martin Scorsese finally has his long-overdue, much-deserved Oscar. But where does "The Departed" stack up in the annals of Academy history?

Pretty well, actually. "The Departed" is the 30th best-reviewed Best Picture of all time, placing it in between "The Lost Weekend" and "Lord of the Rings: Return of the King."


"I just won an Oscar! Drinks are on me!"

Though few doubt Scorsese‘s preeminence in the pantheon of filmmakers, until now, he’s been the Susan Lucci of directors: oft-nominated, but never victorious. "Taxi Driver" (100 percent) lost to "Rocky" (93 percent); "Raging Bull" (100 percent) was beaten by "Ordinary People" (88 percent); "GoodFellas" (98 percent) fell to "Dances with Wolves" (77 percent); "Gangs of New York" (77 percent) was defeated by "Chicago" (86 percent); and "The Aviator" (89 percent) lost to "Million Dollar Baby" (92 percent).

In addition, Scorsese was a five-time also ran for the Best Director statuette: for "Raging Bull," he lost to "Ordinary People"’s Robert Redford; Barry Levinson ("Rain Man") topped him for his work on "The Last Temptation of Christ"; Kevin Costner ("Dances with Wolves") beat him for "GoodFellas"; Roman Polanski ("The Pianist") won over his work on "Gangs"; and Clint Eastwood took home the statue for "Million Dollar Baby," trumping "The Aviator."


"I’m gonna clear off my shelf to make room for that Oscar."

Scorsese didn’t have any better luck in the Best Adapted Screenplay category; he was nominated twice but didn’t win, for "GoodFellas" (with Nicholas Pileggi) and for "The Age of Innocence" (with Jay Cocks).

Click here to see the complete Best of the Best Pictures list!

Tag Cloud

Bravo FOX Best and Worst OWN RT History Horror AMC BBC Nat Geo ABC Oscars docudrama American Society of Cinematographers PBS CNN VICE Adult Swim Dark Horse Comics Election Teen Masterpiece Pop TCA 2017 Photos Certified Fresh TCA USA dramedy political drama aliens composers Tomatazos CMT technology Reality Competition Disney Channel 2015 Animation sitcom El Rey NBC MTV LGBTQ based on movie TV supernatural Cartoon Network thriller Fantasy Calendar Mary Tyler Moore Winter TV Grammys DC Comics Thanksgiving cops Ellie Kemper Hulu Crackle 2017 SDCC Premiere Dates History Red Carpet Logo Rocky Action Spring TV 2016 Comedy Central FX boxoffice biography NYCC Superheroes psycho TruTV Reality Ghostbusters Musicals Mystery crime drama Character Guide vampires VH1 Showtime Holidays Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Drama Universal Fall TV Netflix Tumblr Awards GoT singing competition APB harry potter Video Games Kids & Family FXX IFC crime Star Wars period drama Rock The Arrangement HBO Biopics police drama Winners discovery Trivia Musical Valentine's Day Infographic The CW crime thriller 007 comiccon Summer Amazon Countdown TBS CBS All Access TIFF Disney ITV Mindy Kaling Nominations adventure Set visit TV Land Emmys Polls and Games TNT zombie First Look Star Trek Schedule war Lionsgate Marathons CBS Esquire historical drama PaleyFest Martial Arts Sci-Fi Trailer Sundance Syfy cooking science fiction TLC YA X-Men serial killer Rom-Com travel President Lifetime Marvel A&E sports Opinion Pirates E! Fox News diversity BBC America BET GLAAD DirecTV Interview Super Bowl Box Office Country Comic Book Year in Review Toys Starz cinemax Extras TCM politics Cosplay Sneak Peek Comedy WGN social media ABC Family ESPN Freeform Writers Guild of America Food Network MSNBC Music Podcast Watching Series GIFs SundanceTV Nickelodeon 24 frames