How Does "The Departed" Rank Among Oscar's Best?

by | February 26, 2007 | Comments

So Martin Scorsese finally has his long-overdue, much-deserved Oscar. But where does "The Departed" stack up in the annals of Academy history?

Pretty well, actually. "The Departed" is the 30th best-reviewed Best Picture of all time, placing it in between "The Lost Weekend" and "Lord of the Rings: Return of the King."


"I just won an Oscar! Drinks are on me!"

Though few doubt Scorsese‘s preeminence in the pantheon of filmmakers, until now, he’s been the Susan Lucci of directors: oft-nominated, but never victorious. "Taxi Driver" (100 percent) lost to "Rocky" (93 percent); "Raging Bull" (100 percent) was beaten by "Ordinary People" (88 percent); "GoodFellas" (98 percent) fell to "Dances with Wolves" (77 percent); "Gangs of New York" (77 percent) was defeated by "Chicago" (86 percent); and "The Aviator" (89 percent) lost to "Million Dollar Baby" (92 percent).

In addition, Scorsese was a five-time also ran for the Best Director statuette: for "Raging Bull," he lost to "Ordinary People"’s Robert Redford; Barry Levinson ("Rain Man") topped him for his work on "The Last Temptation of Christ"; Kevin Costner ("Dances with Wolves") beat him for "GoodFellas"; Roman Polanski ("The Pianist") won over his work on "Gangs"; and Clint Eastwood took home the statue for "Million Dollar Baby," trumping "The Aviator."


"I’m gonna clear off my shelf to make room for that Oscar."

Scorsese didn’t have any better luck in the Best Adapted Screenplay category; he was nominated twice but didn’t win, for "GoodFellas" (with Nicholas Pileggi) and for "The Age of Innocence" (with Jay Cocks).

Click here to see the complete Best of the Best Pictures list!

Tag Cloud

TruTV 2016 politics Musicals aliens First Look TCA 2017 technology composers Watching Series boxoffice GoT ABC Family diversity NYCC Biopics The CW Pop Netflix CNN ABC BBC Comedy VICE Freeform Starz ITV DC Comics TV Ghostbusters war Summer Bravo Awards Teen crime Character Guide Warner Bros. Election Amazon Calendar ESPN X-Men Logo Lionsgate Spring TV Masterpiece IFC travel science fiction Universal 007 biography Countdown DirecTV CBS Podcast 24 frames psycho Mindy Kaling transformers VH1 Hulu Star Wars FXX talk show Nat Geo social media Cosplay Nominations Writers Guild of America Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt AMC Interview crime drama Cartoon Network singing competition 2017 TLC Red Carpet Rock Martial Arts Esquire Oscars what to watch crime thriller TBS Photos Toys MTV Holidays Winners 2015 The Arrangement Comedy Central serial killer HBO Winter TV NBC cats Best and Worst supernatural Sundance Mystery Reality History Grammys TV Land Year in Review discovery CMT Adult Swim docudrama Tumblr Video Games Valentine's Day TCM Trailer political drama historical drama Disney Channel BET A&E Star Trek Trivia E3 romance 45 Country sitcom Sneak Peek cooking WGN zombie TIFF Dark Horse Comics based on movie OWN Musical YA Tomatazos Opinion comiccon SDCC Reality Competition E! President Mary Tyler Moore TCA Premiere Dates Schedule Ellie Kemper Marvel Sci-Fi cops Rom-Com PaleyFest Drama Music Extras Rocky MSNBC Superheroes Horror Fall TV Fantasy period drama Super Bowl Emmys BBC America police drama LGBTQ Box Office TNT CBS All Access FX PBS Infographic FOX cinemax harry potter Showtime Crackle Disney USA Pirates Lifetime El Rey adventure sports Action Nickelodeon Kids & Family GIFs vampires Fox News American Society of Cinematographers Comic Book Certified Fresh thriller Paramount Marathons SundanceTV Set visit Polls and Games RT History Food Network Thanksgiving Animation DC Universe APB Syfy dramedy GLAAD