Girls Season Finale: What Did Critics Think?

Tomatometer Watch for Girls season three ender

by | March 25, 2014 | Comments

Girls

Warning: Spoilers ahead.

That went fast, didn’t it? Season three of Girls is over and so, possibly, is the New York chapter of the Hannah Horvath story.

The critics weighed in on whether or not “Two Plane Rides” was a satisfying end to the season. For some, the finale corrected the course of an otherwise shaky string of episodes — and for others, season three never quite found its way.

Tyler Kane, Paste Magazine: Bravo Girls. You’ve taken twists and turns that kill me inside all season and still have me glued in anticipation for the fourth installment. I can’t wait to see what Lena Dunham and company do next year. Here’s to hoping we don’t have to see a quarter of the storyline set in Iowa, but if that’s the case, I think Hannah’s made a wonderful career choice, too.

Cara Buckley, New York Times: After enduring an eye-roller of a season that often seemed lost to the quick sands of narcissism and solipsism, we were treated to some heartbreakingly open moments in tonight’s season finale of Girls.

Caroline Preece, TV Equals: These characters have grown, changed and regressed through these twelve episodes and, as meandering as it sometimes seems, it’s satisfying in the end.

Willa Paskin, Slate: Girls has taken its time finding a tone that’s not too sweet and not too sour but just right, and over the course of its just-finished third season it finally got there. The girls of Girls have not entirely matured, but the show they appear on has. It was there to see in Sunday’s season finale, which skewered and applauded Hannah Horvath not too much or too little, but just as much as deserved.

Aly Semigran, Television Without Pity: Who could have guessed we’d be here? Who could have guessed that Season 3, which got off to such an ugly and joyless and borderline unwatchable start (if anything ever trumps “Dead Inside” as the worst episode of Girls ever, I’ll be legitimately surprised and horrified), would end on such a touching and effective and funny note?

Todd VanDerWerff, A.V. Club: What’s nice about “Two Plane Rides” is that it’s the kind of season finale that makes so much else in the season snap into place, thus reminding us of how good this show can be … “Two Plane Rides” reveals so much more about what was really going on this season that it manages to tug some things together I didn’t dream the show would be able to.

Alan Sepinwall, HitFix: This finale, like the last one, pulled enough of the season together to make the whole journey feel satisfying. This remains a weird, at times maddening show that on occasion I feel the need to watch while I’m inside a sensory deprivation tank and the TV is outside it, and yet the writing and direction remain so sharp, and Hannah remains such a well-drawn character — even with her knack for being spectacularly irritating at times — that I’m in it for the long haul, even if that haul takes us to Iowa for a while.

Emily Yoshida, Grantland: The third season of Girls felt like it was frantically grasping around for something to “be about,” and that, combined with its occasional spurts of all-out sitcom antics, left it without a sense of identity at all. On paper that all sounds brilliantly thematically appropriate for a show about finding yourself in your twenties, but the experience of watching it was completely empty, offering the viewer nothing to hold on to and get comedically or dramatically invested in from week to week. It was like watching a troupe of amnesiacs do a weekly Brooklyn-lifestyle improvised LARP session.

Rebecca Nicholson, The Guardian: The comedy was fleeting in this finale episode, but in a way, so was the drama … The cracks that have been growing for 11 episodes finally became entrenched. That last shot of Hannah, smiling, alone in her selfishness and not entirely unhappy for it, acted as confirmation of this season’s maturity. It didn’t feel like a showy way to play out the run, but then, it didn’t need to be showy. Girls is becoming more and more comfortable with its subtleties, and I thought this was an impressively underplayed way to see the season out.

Matt Zoller Seitz, Vulture: It’s too bad that “Two Plane Rides” was such a mess, and that its predecessor, “I Saw You,” was a mess as well. We had every right to expect another lively, intricately crafted season-ender, but Girls stumbled near the finish line, then stumbled again.

What did you think of “Two Plane Rides?” What’s going to happen next season?



Tag Cloud

Best and Worst CBS All Access FX 2015 FXX Masterpiece Character Guide Martial Arts Mindy Kaling Disney Channel AMC Infographic Awards Star Trek Summer PBS Box Office Pirates Trailer serial killer Paramount Trivia Disney DirecTV crime thriller IFC Marvel Fox News Premiere Dates BBC Star Wars cooking Lionsgate Year in Review cinemax Super Bowl DC Universe YA Musicals TV Land Action OWN Opinion biography Grammys Writers Guild of America ITV Country American Society of Cinematographers based on movie psycho GoT crime HBO science fiction Logo Sundance Sci-Fi Calendar Amazon sports Comedy Central Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt discovery SundanceTV Thanksgiving CMT Animation The Arrangement boxoffice TBS Schedule ESPN talk show Photos Podcast Sneak Peek APB politics diversity Red Carpet TCM Superheroes ABC Adult Swim Tumblr Universal TCA 2017 Cosplay 2016 Watching Series Showtime Certified Fresh Biopics Crackle Oscars period drama Reality Competition Horror Rock 007 Toys First Look SDCC TLC Netflix Freeform Nat Geo History TIFF transformers Fall TV DC Comics social media cops Pop war BET Valentine's Day E! Emmys Reality Spring TV thriller vampires NBC cats Ghostbusters Tomatazos travel X-Men police drama Music Mary Tyler Moore Drama Esquire Extras Rom-Com E3 USA GLAAD CBS comiccon Winter TV Comedy Kids & Family Comic Book Ellie Kemper Fantasy Rocky Starz Nickelodeon Teen technology Lifetime dramedy singing competition FOX Interview composers Musical LGBTQ Set visit ABC Family MTV Warner Bros. supernatural Polls and Games MSNBC crime drama Dark Horse Comics zombie docudrama TV GIFs TruTV Marathons Cartoon Network 24 frames TNT President historical drama A&E harry potter NYCC Countdown Election CNN WGN Video Games aliens VICE adventure political drama Food Network Nominations VH1 BBC America 45 Holidays RT History Syfy sitcom The CW Bravo Mystery PaleyFest TCA Hulu El Rey Winners 2017