Critical Consensus: Pitch Fever Has Edge Over Sahara

by | April 7, 2005 | Comments

With the start of Spring and the coming of Summer, this weekend presents us with a baseball movie and an action-adventure set in the Sahara desert. Baseball or hot desert sand, which will critics choose?

After headlining the surprisingly successful romantic comedy “How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days,” Matthew McConaughey tries his hand at action-adventure with “Sahara.” He takes on the role of a master explorer who embarks on a treasure hunt through some of the most dangerous regions of West Africa. Joining him in the adventure are Penelope Cruz and Steve Zahn. Critics didn’t think much of last year’s similarly themed, Nicolas Cage adventurer “National Treasure,” which only received recommendations from 40% of the critics. “Sahara” didn’t fare much better. As of this writing, its Tomatometer reads 42%. This is a well below Matthew McConaughey’s average Tomatometer of 56%. Some of the national print, online, and broadcast critics think it’s mindless fun; others think its just mindless.

If at first you don’t succeed, try, try again. After his big screen debut with Queen Latifah "Taxi" got hammered by critics with a 10% on the Tomatometer and didn’t make much of an impression at the box office, Jimmy Fallon tries his luck with Drew Barrymore and the Farrelly brothers in a romantic comedy about a man who must choose between the two loves of his life – The Boston Red Sox and his girlfriend. Between “Fever Pitch” and “Taxi,” the choice isn’t as tough for critics though. As of this writing, “Fever Pitch” scored a Fresh 66% on the Tomatometer, a major improvement over “Taxi.” It’s above Drew Barrymore’s average Tomatometer of 56%. Although critics don’t think there are enough laughs or chemistry between the leads to make it a home run, the movie is sweet, likable and does a great job of showing what it means to be an obsessed fan.

While "Fever Pitch" has its share of problems, it looks like the film has the slight edge with critics this weekend.

Tag Cloud

OWN Box Office Disney Horror TCA First Look Rom-Com Watching Series zombie MTV sitcom justice league Extras crime drama Sneak Peek The Arrangement adventure 45 Polls and Games Netflix Lifetime Fall TV Marathons technology Cosplay Animation AMC Kids & Family TLC BET Ellie Kemper Emmys TNT American Society of Cinematographers Holidays CMT cats Martial Arts History BBC Warner Bros. Amazon El Rey E3 TV Land TCM Sci-Fi DC Comics The CW Opinion cops Podcast Showtime Food Network Valentine's Day harry potter Grammys Esquire Logo PaleyFest Calendar Reality Syfy Super Bowl Lionsgate PBS Fantasy Election based on movie SDCC Photos Adult Swim composers Fox News political drama historical drama Hulu 24 frames Awards Comedy science fiction Biopics Cartoon Network cinemax VICE TBS Music Universal Nickelodeon Drama Countdown Video Games Summer Trailer Comedy Central Star Wars 2017 thriller CBS Winter TV Oscars Masterpiece Pop Country 2016 aliens ABC Year in Review Toys VH1 DirecTV Bravo vampires ABC Family Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TV NBC diversity social media Star Trek Red Carpet binge HBO 2015 Pirates dceu Best and Worst medical drama period drama crime WGN Set visit transformers sports boxoffice talk show E! Interview Freeform serial killer Musicals A&E GLAAD Teen Trivia IFC USA 007 BBC America DC Universe Character Guide dc Mary Tyler Moore Starz X-Men Writers Guild of America cooking CNN Premiere Dates Nominations Rocky TCA 2017 Reality Competition CBS All Access FX TIFF dramedy ITV Sundance President Rock Disney Channel discovery politics supernatural GIFs romance what to watch Crackle comiccon Infographic Mystery Ghostbusters biography Western Tomatazos war Schedule Comic Book crime thriller travel GoT ESPN police drama singing competition FXX FOX YA Certified Fresh APB Musical Winners docudrama LGBTQ SundanceTV Dark Horse Comics Spring TV Tumblr Superheroes MSNBC Paramount Nat Geo Thanksgiving Marvel psycho Action NYCC RT History TruTV Mindy Kaling 21st Century Fox