Critical Consensus: "Dick & Jane" Not Much Fun; "Cheaper" Is Bankrupt

by | December 21, 2005 | Comments

This week’s wide releases include a remake ("Fun With Dick and Jane") and a sequel to a remake ("Cheaper By the Dozen 2"). Will critics be laughing at these comedies?

What is "Fun With Dick and Jane?" Is it slapstick? Satire? Social commentary? Dark comedy? Is it… fun? To the last question, the critics have an answer: sometimes, but not often enough. This remake, starring Jim Carrey and Tea Leoni, updates the 1977 Jane Fonda/George Segal comedy about two yuppies who steal to regain their riches. The plot is updated for the Enron era, and it also adds a scene with Mr. Carrey in a ninja costume. Yes, wacky Jim Carrey is back, but the scribes say "Fun’s" tone is too much of a muddle to really hit any of its targets. At 33 percent on the Tomatometer, this one’s a pretty plain "Jane." And it’s Carrey’s worst-reviewed film since "Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls," which scored 26 percent.

The Baker family is back in "Cheaper By the Dozen 2." Steve Martin, Bonnie Hunt, Hilary Duff and Eugene Levy star. There are lots of family hi-jinks. Despite some mild conflict, everyone loves one another. The first one made tons of money. The critics are pretty united in their disdain for "Cheaper By the Dozen 2," a film that, at 11 percent on the Tomatometer, is a point short of a dozen itself. It’s also substantially below the first "Cheaper," which scored two dozen on the Tomatometer.

Recent Jim Carrey Movies
71% — Lemony Snicket’s A Series of Unfortunate Events (2004)
93% — Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (2004)
50% — Bruce Almighty (2003)
42% — The Majestic (2001)
51% — How the Grinch Stole Christmas (2000)

Recent Steve Martin Movies
62% — Shopgirl (2005)
24% — Cheaper By the Dozen (2003)
34% — Bringing Down the House (2003)
37% — Novocaine (2001)
66% — Joe Gould’s Secret (2001)

Tag Cloud

police drama Set visit APB diversity comiccon VICE ABC Spring TV Comedy Central Extras Lifetime Winners thriller based on movie Comic Book CBS Country TIFF Pop FX AMC TBS boxoffice crime drama Food Network Esquire crime social media Podcast Interview ABC Family science fiction NYCC Comedy Sundance Super Bowl Exclusive Video CNN Toys Star Trek Calendar IFC period drama Red Carpet Opinion BBC America Crackle Kids & Family E! Election TV Syfy LGBTQ Freeform Schedule serial killer CMT WGN Martial Arts cinemax politics Bravo Lionsgate ESPN Marvel Biopics HBO NBC American Society of Cinematographers President TruTV harry potter Tumblr discovery 2016 TCM Amazon sitcom Netflix Valentine's Day OWN DirecTV Photos adventure Rock vampires Showtime crime thriller Universal TNT Reality The Arrangement Polls and Games Emmys First Look Action Awards ITV Sneak Peek SundanceTV Mystery TCA 2017 aliens Infographic Reality Competition TLC Masterpiece Music Certified Fresh Fantasy psycho PaleyFest TCA Ghostbusters GoT Cartoon Network Nominations sports X-Men 2017 Holidays Box Office Oscars MTV FXX Superheroes Best and Worst Animation Year in Review Countdown Winter TV TV Land Character Guide Rom-Com 007 FOX Premiere Dates cooking PBS DC Comics Grammys docudrama History Cosplay Fox News biography Dark Horse Comics Marathons war Pirates SDCC Mary Tyler Moore cops Hulu A&E Trailer Tomatazos singing competition Drama Watching Series Summer Thanksgiving GIFs GLAAD Rocky VH1 MSNBC El Rey technology Starz RT History Sci-Fi Star Wars Adult Swim Horror dramedy travel The CW Logo USA BBC Video Games 2015 Nat Geo Disney Teen Disney Channel Trivia Fall TV BET Musicals Writers Guild of America CBS All Access 24 frames zombie Nickelodeon supernatural