Critical Consensus: "Dick & Jane" Not Much Fun; "Cheaper" Is Bankrupt

by | December 21, 2005 | Comments

This week’s wide releases include a remake ("Fun With Dick and Jane") and a sequel to a remake ("Cheaper By the Dozen 2"). Will critics be laughing at these comedies?

What is "Fun With Dick and Jane?" Is it slapstick? Satire? Social commentary? Dark comedy? Is it… fun? To the last question, the critics have an answer: sometimes, but not often enough. This remake, starring Jim Carrey and Tea Leoni, updates the 1977 Jane Fonda/George Segal comedy about two yuppies who steal to regain their riches. The plot is updated for the Enron era, and it also adds a scene with Mr. Carrey in a ninja costume. Yes, wacky Jim Carrey is back, but the scribes say "Fun’s" tone is too much of a muddle to really hit any of its targets. At 33 percent on the Tomatometer, this one’s a pretty plain "Jane." And it’s Carrey’s worst-reviewed film since "Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls," which scored 26 percent.

The Baker family is back in "Cheaper By the Dozen 2." Steve Martin, Bonnie Hunt, Hilary Duff and Eugene Levy star. There are lots of family hi-jinks. Despite some mild conflict, everyone loves one another. The first one made tons of money. The critics are pretty united in their disdain for "Cheaper By the Dozen 2," a film that, at 11 percent on the Tomatometer, is a point short of a dozen itself. It’s also substantially below the first "Cheaper," which scored two dozen on the Tomatometer.

Recent Jim Carrey Movies
71% — Lemony Snicket’s A Series of Unfortunate Events (2004)
93% — Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (2004)
50% — Bruce Almighty (2003)
42% — The Majestic (2001)
51% — How the Grinch Stole Christmas (2000)

Recent Steve Martin Movies
62% — Shopgirl (2005)
24% — Cheaper By the Dozen (2003)
34% — Bringing Down the House (2003)
37% — Novocaine (2001)
66% — Joe Gould’s Secret (2001)

Tag Cloud

biography ITV Podcast Crackle cops Martial Arts SundanceTV MTV DirecTV Certified Fresh 2016 BET travel MSNBC Logo Netflix Red Carpet aliens Watching Series Rom-Com sports sitcom Disney Calendar Superheroes PaleyFest political drama Biopics Best and Worst 007 science fiction SDCC Nominations E3 TCM Pop Masterpiece Interview First Look Fantasy The CW CBS All Access Showtime Valentine's Day Sci-Fi dramedy docudrama Nat Geo cinemax GLAAD diversity Toys Adult Swim Ghostbusters Polls and Games Extras crime Hulu social media composers cats FX boxoffice Starz Opinion NBC Emmys FXX Comedy Reality vampires transformers TIFF Star Trek FOX Comic Book Rocky Amazon Universal Set visit Winners Sundance WGN BBC America Musicals Esquire Syfy TNT TCA VH1 PBS Marathons Premiere Dates VICE 45 comiccon Tumblr Box Office Action President Spring TV Sneak Peek The Arrangement Trailer LGBTQ Rock RT History zombie Mindy Kaling CMT harry potter thriller TBS Teen war ABC Family El Rey Reality Competition Warner Bros. crime drama talk show historical drama supernatural Video Games HBO CBS ESPN 24 frames politics Fall TV TV Country Winter TV APB Thanksgiving period drama Fox News Writers Guild of America Dark Horse Comics Music DC Universe OWN Cosplay Kids & Family based on movie Lionsgate TLC Tomatazos adventure TV Land 2017 Comedy Central Mary Tyler Moore Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Horror Disney Channel USA Holidays IFC GIFs NYCC DC Comics Pirates CNN Marvel technology psycho Cartoon Network A&E discovery Nickelodeon X-Men serial killer GoT Trivia Character Guide Musical Paramount Animation Oscars Lifetime cooking E! Year in Review YA Grammys Super Bowl crime thriller 2015 History TruTV AMC ABC Star Wars Food Network TCA 2017 Drama Awards Election Photos singing competition Countdown American Society of Cinematographers Schedule Mystery police drama Summer Bravo BBC Freeform Ellie Kemper Infographic