Breaking News: Movies Not Screened For Critics Aren't Very Good

by | April 5, 2006 | Comments

After some furious debate over David Germain‘s discussion of films "not screened for critics," RT takes a look at the Tomatometers and respective B.O. performances of the flicks withheld from critics so far this year.

Films Not Screened For Critics In 2006:
29% — Tyler Perry’s Madea’s Family Reunion (Feb. 24)
17% — Grandma’s Boy (Jan. 6)
16% — Underworld: Evolution (Jan. 20)
10% — When a Stranger Calls (Feb. 3)
9% — Ultraviolet (Mar. 3)
8% — Date Movie (Feb. 17)
7% — BloodRayne (Jan. 6)
6% — Stay Alive (Mar. 24)
5% — Doogal (Feb 24)
4% — Larry the Cable Guy: Health Inspector (Mar. 24)
Average Tomatometer not screened for critics: 11%

As Germain noted, this is becoming a common trend; in 2006, 10 films have already been withheld from those mean old scribes, with "The Benchwarmers" and "Phat Girlz" joining that illustrious list this week. Apparently, the whole of the studio system is terrified that the following exchange will take place within the coveted teen and young adult demographic:

Teen No. 1: "Man, am I ever stoked to be first in line to see ("Date Movie"/ "Underworld: Evolution"/ "The Benchwarmers," etc.)! This film will certainly be off the chain! Oh look, there’s my friend!"

Teen No. 2 (running, looking frantic): "Bad news, homie. David Denby, Andrew Sarris, AND Stephanie Zacharek all dissed ("Date Movie"/ "Underworld: Evolution"/ "The Benchwarmers," etc.). They say it’s really stupid."

Teen No. 1: "Curses! I’m getting out of the line for this movie, and I shall not be seeing it on its opening weekend. Dear fellow, perchance is ‘The Best of Youth‘ still playing in the local arthouse?"

The phrase "critic-proof" has entered the lexicon for a reason: it perfectly sums up a certain type of move, one that the studios still feel is necessary not to screen.

And what do the critics have to say about these films? Unsurprisingly, the average is an 11 percent on the Tomatometer. Of the twenty worst reviewed wide releases of the year so far, these ten films occupy the top slots. Still, that doesn’t mean too much; "Big Momma’s House 2" was screened for critics, got a six percent on the Tomatometer, and still made a lot of money. So while the films that aren’t screened are by no means cinematic gems, there’s an excellent chance they will make lots of money regardless.

When the staff of Rotten Tomatoes is not meticulously analyzing the films of Bergman, Ozu, and Bresson, we’ve been known to watch (and unironically enjoy) such critically drubbed flicks as "Stealth," "Black Knight," and the collected works of Jean-Claude Van Damme. Some movies aren’t "good" per se, but that doesn’t mean they don’t have potential audiences. Studios should know this better than anyone; they made the movies.

See Also:
"Not Screened For Press" Trend Growing in 2006

Tag Cloud

SXSW Mindy Kaling Martial Arts Sony Pictures Bravo Ellie Kemper CNN BBC American Society of Cinematographers OWN TBS dramedy VH1 Shondaland CBS Set visit political drama harry potter Sci-Fi Comedy YA RT History TV Land technology 2017 First Look Certified Fresh medical drama Syfy Mary Tyler Moore period drama USA Network social media Photos singing competition ratings Winners TCA 2017 Country Kids & Family Emmys Paramount Marvel Trailer Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt PaleyFest Sundance The CW History Super Bowl cats based on movie dceu talk show Calendar USA Podcast Trivia Lionsgate hist justice league DirecTV BET 2015 Esquire Fox News binge romance crime thriller comiccon FXX Extras robots Dark Horse Comics TIFF DC streaming service 20th Century Fox PBS 24 frames discovery ABC Family GIFs Character Guide Best and Worst Comedy Central Schedule Cartoon Network IFC APB Comic Book Summer Biopics Sundance Now Box Office CW Seed zombie biography Opinion vampires Action Tomatazos Paramount Network cinemax Marathons Acorn TV Pop Horror Winter TV sitcom NBC Musical NYCC Year in Review composers Nat Geo FOX Spring TV CMT Tumblr Superheroes GoT Watching Series Starz what to watch ABC Christmas docudrama transformers aliens historical drama war Mystery Creative Arts Emmys Reality Crackle See It Skip It DC Comics boxoffice Lucasfilm Rocky Premiere Dates DC Universe Showtime serial killer Ghostbusters Rock 45 Rom-Com cooking finale Teen Toys Food Network SundanceTV Red Carpet cults unscripted Netflix Hulu police drama Interview Britbox Freeform SDCC Music Masterpiece thriller spy thriller Logo politics Awards science fiction Amazon Lifetime AMC GLAAD Pixar The Arrangement President VICE Drama CBS All Access El Rey Spike TCM 2016 E3 Sneak Peek 21st Century Fox MTV Star Trek supernatural Countdown Infographic Writers Guild of America ITV WGN zombies Election Fall TV Cosplay Western Star Wars Polls and Games Superheroe Fantasy TLC diversity IFC Films Warner Bros. Universal TNT E! YouTube Red Grammys crossover psycho festivals X-Men Oscars dc TV Disney Channel National Geographic Pirates Valentine's Day crime 007 TCA Animation Thanksgiving Video Games Nickelodeon FX BBC America Disney Adult Swim adventure Reality Competition TruTV crime drama Musicals cops sports golden globes ESPN travel A&E HBO MSNBC LGBTQ Nominations Holidays