Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Transformers: Dark of the Moon is Less Than Meets the Eye

Plus, Larry Crowne and Monte Carlo succumb to predictability.

by | June 30, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got robots in disguise (Transformers: Dark of the Moon, starring Shia LaBeouf and Rosie Huntington-Whiteley), a recession romance (Larry Crowne, starring Tom Hanks and Julia Roberts), and a royal mix-up (Monte Carlo, starring Selena Gomez and Leighton Meester). What do the critics have to say?

Transformers: Dark of the Moon


Three films into the franchise, we pretty much know what we’re getting with a Transformers movie: tons of hyperkinetic robot action, with little in the way of character development or coherent plotting. So it is with Transformers: Dark of the Moon; critics say this latest installment is a marked improvement over Revenge of the Fallen, but it’s still an exercise in sensory overload that favors special effects over storytelling. This time out, the Autobots and Decepticons are both gunning for the remains of Sentinel Prime, which were discovered on the moon and contain important secrets; as usual, the Autobots’ buddy Sam (Shia LaBeouf) finds himself in the line of fire. The pundits say Transformers: Dark of the Moon has admittedly impressive special effects and a few solid action sequences, but the whole thing becomes numbing after a while – it’s just spectacle, with few (if any) compelling characters, a manufactured product that impresses with sheer bombast but stretches its thin plot way past the breaking point.

Larry Crowne


Tom Hanks and Julia Roberts are two of the biggest movie stars we have, so it’s fair to assume that any film with both of them is going to be pretty good, right? Well, not necessarily. Critics say despite the stars’ relaxed, easy chemistry, Larry Crowne is surprisingly bland and conventional. Hanks stars as a middle-aged Navy vet who loses his job and decides to enroll in community college. There he becomes a motor scooter enthusiast and starts a relationship with one of the school’s professors. Hanks and Roberts were terrific together in Charlie Wilson’s War (and Hanks won high praise for his previous directorial outing, That Thing You Do!), but the pundits say Larry Crowne is remarkably generic and inauthentic, a pleasant trifle that brings smiles from time to time but never hums with dramatic urgency or l’amour fou. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Hanks’s best-reviewed movies.)

Monte Carlo


There’s nothing wrong with movies about wish fulfillment — heck, that’s one of the main things that draws us to the theater. But you have to do more than just surround your protagonists with riches, and critics say Monte Carlo misses plenty of opportunities to explore beyond its premise, though it’s got its charms, thanks to some decent performances and overall good spirits. Selena Gomez and Leighton Meester star as vacationers who get mistaken for royalty, and soon, their dull European vacation becomes a luxurious, whirlwind tour of the continent. But what will happen when our heroines get found out? The pundits say Monte Carlo is decent tween fare, but it’s silly, predictable stuff that never pushes the boundaries of its formula.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Crime After Crime, a documentary about a woman’s long legal battle after a murder sentence many felt was unjust, is at 100 percent.
  • Delhi Belly, a Bollywood comedy about three average dudes who find themselves in the crosshairs of a crime boss, is at 80 percent.
  • Terri, starring John C. Reilly in a comedy about a teen misfit who befriends his school’s vice principal, is at 73 percent.
  • The Romanian import Aurora, a murder mystery that painstakingly examines a killer’s psyche, is at 71 percent.
  • The Perfect Host, starring David Hyde Pierce in a psychological thriller about a wanted bank robber who crashes a dinner party, is at 41 percent.
  • Love Etc., a doc about five New York couples and the complexities of their romantic relationships, is at 38 percent.

Tag Cloud

Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Mystery Cartoon Network diversity 2017 Kids & Family transformers Musicals CBS adventure Lionsgate Starz Horror TNT Star Wars USA OWN Spring TV Dark Horse Comics LGBTQ Interview political drama Reality BBC America 2016 Food Network Mary Tyler Moore APB Certified Fresh HBO Polls and Games crime Schedule Extras X-Men Valentine's Day zombie Nickelodeon Lifetime Rocky Tomatazos Sneak Peek NYCC Trailer TCA 2017 Opinion Amazon crime drama historical drama IFC The CW Cosplay Disney Winners Winter TV ABC Family Fall TV Rom-Com Set visit TBS El Rey Pirates NBC Election sports Emmys Video Games TIFF Year in Review sitcom aliens based on movie BBC 007 ITV Teen Comedy Central cinemax Thanksgiving politics TV SDCC Netflix Nat Geo thriller ESPN police drama GLAAD Photos cooking Super Bowl Tumblr Animation Comic Book Ellie Kemper Toys Drama TCA Freeform TruTV Nominations Grammys Esquire Trivia PaleyFest RT History Comedy A&E WGN VH1 Mindy Kaling MTV AMC BET Red Carpet Syfy Awards cops Martial Arts ABC Ghostbusters The Arrangement vampires Writers Guild of America crime thriller docudrama Marvel TLC Hulu science fiction biography DC Comics Adult Swim Sundance Character Guide Rock E3 dramedy History comiccon SundanceTV Disney Channel Logo boxoffice FOX Bravo Music Star Trek Fox News Infographic Reality Competition psycho TV Land technology Calendar MSNBC period drama Marathons Crackle Fantasy serial killer FX PBS Musical Showtime Premiere Dates war CNN Summer Podcast First Look Country Superheroes Pop E! harry potter travel Action Masterpiece 24 frames Best and Worst CBS All Access Watching Series VICE Biopics FXX discovery Box Office Holidays CMT TCM Countdown GIFs supernatural YA 2015 President Sci-Fi Oscars DirecTV GoT Universal singing competition American Society of Cinematographers composers social media