Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Surrogates Is A Passable Thriller

Plus, Fame isn't so glamorous, and Pandorum passes on screenings.

by | September 24, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got robot clones (Surrogates, starring Bruce Willis and Radha Mitchell), artistic-minded freshmen (Fame, starring Kelsey Grammer and Megan Mullally), and scared spacemen (Pandorum, starring Dennis Quaid and Ben Foster). What do the critics have to say?



Surrogates was barely screened for critics prior to its release, which is usually a bad sign. However, those who have seen the film say it’s a decent dystopian sci-fi flick, filled with enough fast-paced action to distract audiences from its cliches. Bruce Willis and Radha Mitchell star as FBI agents who, in the course of solving a murder, stumble upon a vast clone-manufacturing operation. The pundits say Surrogates is visually sleek and exciting, as long as you don’t think too hard about the leaps in logic. (And don’t forget to check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Bruce Willis’ best-reviewed films.)



Given the massive popularity of the High School Musical franchise, it was probably inevitable that Fame would get dusted off and remade. However, critics mostly wish it could be reworked with more passion and inspiration than this tepid, chaste treatment. As with the original, Fame follows the trials and tribulations of students at the New York City High School of Performing Arts. Lessons are learned, self-doubts are faced, songs are sung. The pundits say that while the original attempted to deal with important social issues while delivering show-stopping numbers, this new version is far less ambitious, featuring tepid set pieces and skin-deep characterization.



It appears that the folks behind Pandorum feared that allowing the critics to see their film would open a Pandora’s box, since it wasn’t screened prior to release. Pandorum is the story of two astronauts who find themselves stranded on a spacecraft — and they’ve got some sinister company. Kids, forestall watching 2001 for the 50th time and guess that Tomatometer!

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Trailer TIFF Nat Geo Starz CBS GLAAD BBC America Box Office thriller Winter TV Election BET Year in Review Best and Worst Netflix 2017 crime drama Polls and Games diversity FX comiccon DirecTV cooking El Rey Ghostbusters sports USA Star Wars Biopics Marvel docudrama Reality Competition Calendar Lifetime Pirates social media Action MTV travel Food Network Cartoon Network Masterpiece Grammys First Look NBC Tumblr Winners VH1 Esquire Oscars TV Land Red Carpet HBO Sneak Peek Adult Swim CNN Drama TNT Toys singing competition PaleyFest Pop Premiere Dates CMT Character Guide Trivia ABC Horror MSNBC Countdown Logo TCM E! BBC GIFs Spring TV Lionsgate vampires TBS Mystery Schedule Disney Channel ESPN Amazon crime thriller Rom-Com Freeform Reality 2015 SundanceTV 24 frames Fantasy discovery Podcast VICE Infographic AMC Animation Universal The CW Superheroes Nominations TCA TruTV Sundance Tomatazos Rocky Music A&E Hulu ITV American Society of Cinematographers boxoffice science fiction Watching Series period drama Thanksgiving Opinion dramedy Disney Kids & Family Rock Fall TV Musicals serial killer Cosplay Exclusive Video Certified Fresh LGBTQ Awards sitcom Photos 2016 Marathons PBS GoT 007 Extras Nickelodeon Showtime IFC Comedy Set visit FOX Writers Guild of America Video Games Sci-Fi adventure Bravo TCA 2017 Comedy Central President SDCC WGN politics Emmys cinemax Holidays Interview Summer harry potter Valentine's Day NYCC ABC Family FXX OWN CBS All Access Fox News DC Comics History Martial Arts Syfy Crackle Country