Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Solid Public Enemies Doesn't Quite Bring The Noise

Plus, Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs is lumbering.

by | June 30, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got crime and punishment (Public Enemies, starring Johnny Depp and Christian Bale) and prehistoric domesticity (Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs, with voice work from Ray Romano and Queen Latifah). What do the critics have to say?


Public Enemies

Public Enemies hits theaters with an impressive pedigree — it’s directed by Michael Mann and stars two of contemporary cinema’s biggest names, Johnny Depp and Christian Bale. And although critics say the picture offers plenty to admire, it’s strangely muted overall. Depp stars as legendary bank robber John Dillinger, whose daring criminal exploits made him an American folk hero in the 1930s, while Bale plays g-man Melvin Purvis, who’s hell-bent on taking him down. The pundits say Public Enemies has impeccable period ambience, and Depp emits oodles of roguish charm in the lead. However, others say it never makes the leap from good to great; it’s a solid crime picture that never fully explores its characters or its era.)


Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs

Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs is the third film in a series that saw its critical fortunes dwindle from the first movie to the second. And the scribes say that this one’s not much better, despite solid animation and a funny turn from Simon Pegg as a crazed weasel. Mammoth couple Manny and Ellie (Ray Romano and Queen Latifah) are expecting their first kid, but find they must rescue their sloth pal Sid (John Leguizamo), who’s trying to raise some T. Rex babies, from an angry dinosaur. The pundits say Ice Age‘s 3-D visuals are often extraordinary, but the story is tired stuff, and even the irrepressible Scrat, so entertaining in the first two films, brings little levity to the proceedings.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Drama Emmys Awards Martial Arts Certified Fresh APB Cartoon Network cops Starz Watching Series Video Games PBS war Mystery Trivia ITV psycho Extras Year in Review Pirates Reality Competition Universal Opinion Tomatazos Reality vampires Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Esquire Winter TV Comedy Marvel MTV Nat Geo TIFF science fiction politics Lionsgate TCA 2017 Comedy Central docudrama Cosplay 2017 FOX FXX Masterpiece TV Land Logo Nominations Musicals LGBTQ thriller Grammys Countdown historical drama singing competition transformers cats Syfy VICE Comic Book Tumblr TV NYCC crime comiccon Crackle cooking 2016 BBC America TLC Dark Horse Comics Rocky social media Ghostbusters Trailer Rock 007 serial killer President Mindy Kaling Disney Interview Adult Swim diversity biography SDCC technology PaleyFest Spring TV Photos sitcom travel El Rey E3 CNN Toys Freeform VH1 Super Bowl Calendar Writers Guild of America DC Comics TruTV police drama First Look Ellie Kemper History ABC MSNBC CBS crime drama Mary Tyler Moore FX Marathons Holidays GLAAD E! Box Office Netflix HBO Sci-Fi Action Fox News Election GIFs Podcast ABC Family Nickelodeon USA BET TBS YA Star Wars Sneak Peek A&E BBC IFC The Arrangement Fall TV Red Carpet The CW aliens Polls and Games Music Animation Horror X-Men adventure AMC 45 OWN Showtime Biopics Rom-Com crime thriller dramedy NBC Star Trek WGN 2015 political drama Lifetime cinemax GoT TCM Hulu boxoffice TCA Oscars 24 frames Kids & Family Disney Channel Sundance Thanksgiving DirecTV RT History Country CBS All Access Character Guide American Society of Cinematographers Summer Schedule composers Bravo SundanceTV discovery Teen Pop Amazon ESPN Set visit TNT Infographic Fantasy Musical Premiere Dates Food Network harry potter sports based on movie zombie supernatural Winners CMT period drama Valentine's Day Best and Worst Superheroes