Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Secretariat Is A Solid Bet

Plus, Life as We Know It is too predictable, and guess My Soul to Take’s Tomatometer!

by | October 8, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a legendary racehorse (Secretariat, starring Diane Lane and John Malkovich), an unconventional family unit (Life as We Know It, starring Katherine Heigl and Josh Duhamel), and some unhappy birthdays (My Soul to Take, starring Max Thieriot and John Magaro). What do the critics have to say?



Ah, the inspirational sports movie: it’s a subgenre we never seem to tire of, no matter what the athletic pursuit or how conventional the script. And critics say Secretariat, a biopic (horsey-pic?) of the 1973 Triple Crown winner, is a pretty solid wager, with strong performances and thrilling race sequences largely offsetting the fact that little of the story will come as a surprise – even if you don’t have a sports almanac on your shelf. Diane Lane stars as the inheritor of a stable and, with the help of a skilled trainer (John Malkovich), literally bets the farm that the movie’s titular Thoroughbred will win the Derby, the Preakness, and the Belmont Stakes. No points for guessing the outcome, though the pundits say Secretariat is rousing, effectively-acted family fare, and further proof that standard material can be overcome by a sense of panache. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Malkovich’s complete filmography.)


Life as We Know It

First comes love, then comes marriage, then comes a baby in a baby carriage, right? Not in Life as We Know It, a romantic comedy about an unlikely family unit that critics say otherwise adheres slavishly to formula. Katherine Heigl and Josh Duhamel star as friends of a couple that dies in a car crash, and are forced to care for the dead couple’s baby — despite their mutual acrimony. Will the two of them come together to raise the child — and find love in the process? No spoilers will be revealed here, but suffice to say the pundits find the whole thing to be remarkably predictable – though they also note that the cast does its best to inject some energy into the proceedings.


My Soul to Take

Rather than praying for good reviews, the folks behind My Soul to Take decided to keep critics away prior to the film’s release. Directed by horror maestro Wes Craven, the movie tells the story of a serial killer who returns after a 16-year absence to wreak havoc on a small rural community. Kids: brush your teeth, say your prayers, and guess that Tomatometer!

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Reality Competition talk show social media Showtime Universal The Arrangement A&E Comic Book composers Dark Horse Comics comiccon GIFs Superheroes Countdown adventure Podcast biography Tomatazos RT History Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Ellie Kemper History PaleyFest Star Wars FOX Trailer sports Awards TCA 2017 TV Land Music SDCC harry potter DC Universe justice league Country HBO Nickelodeon WGN Extras Thanksgiving Video Games Spring TV Pirates Musical Infographic APB Nat Geo LGBTQ President Interview Martial Arts Set visit YA Emmys Opinion travel Cartoon Network 24 frames Disney Channel cops supernatural CBS All Access Year in Review Action PBS IFC FXX Hulu Tumblr Teen Marvel TBS binge Rocky Writers Guild of America Ghostbusters psycho NYCC dceu Freeform DC Comics historical drama science fiction crime drama Marathons Lionsgate SundanceTV Winners Toys political drama discovery crime thriller transformers Crackle Esquire cats Sundance Starz medical drama VICE Star Trek zombie BET TruTV Mindy Kaling El Rey OWN politics Premiere Dates TCM Winter TV CNN aliens romance Netflix Paramount based on movie DirecTV Oscars USA Polls and Games Biopics 21st Century Fox Kids & Family Red Carpet Pop ABC Family sitcom Super Bowl TNT cinemax Food Network Disney Watching Series 2017 Character Guide Best and Worst cooking BBC America Comedy CBS Reality war Mystery Certified Fresh Horror GoT Comedy Central VH1 CMT First Look Photos Trivia vampires MTV Nominations serial killer what to watch Western FX ITV Drama 2016 Musicals 007 crime X-Men Warner Bros. Adult Swim Rock Rom-Com Box Office Summer 2015 Schedule Calendar Valentine's Day GLAAD Grammys Lifetime Syfy MSNBC ESPN police drama Sci-Fi docudrama thriller BBC The CW Bravo Fox News TV Logo TLC dc period drama AMC Mary Tyler Moore Holidays ABC Animation Fall TV diversity dramedy Fantasy E3 Election NBC Amazon technology boxoffice Masterpiece Sneak Peek singing competition E! TIFF TCA 45 American Society of Cinematographers Cosplay