Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Secretariat Is A Solid Bet

Plus, Life as We Know It is too predictable, and guess My Soul to Take’s Tomatometer!

by | October 8, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a legendary racehorse (Secretariat, starring Diane Lane and John Malkovich), an unconventional family unit (Life as We Know It, starring Katherine Heigl and Josh Duhamel), and some unhappy birthdays (My Soul to Take, starring Max Thieriot and John Magaro). What do the critics have to say?



Ah, the inspirational sports movie: it’s a subgenre we never seem to tire of, no matter what the athletic pursuit or how conventional the script. And critics say Secretariat, a biopic (horsey-pic?) of the 1973 Triple Crown winner, is a pretty solid wager, with strong performances and thrilling race sequences largely offsetting the fact that little of the story will come as a surprise – even if you don’t have a sports almanac on your shelf. Diane Lane stars as the inheritor of a stable and, with the help of a skilled trainer (John Malkovich), literally bets the farm that the movie’s titular Thoroughbred will win the Derby, the Preakness, and the Belmont Stakes. No points for guessing the outcome, though the pundits say Secretariat is rousing, effectively-acted family fare, and further proof that standard material can be overcome by a sense of panache. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Malkovich’s complete filmography.)


Life as We Know It

First comes love, then comes marriage, then comes a baby in a baby carriage, right? Not in Life as We Know It, a romantic comedy about an unlikely family unit that critics say otherwise adheres slavishly to formula. Katherine Heigl and Josh Duhamel star as friends of a couple that dies in a car crash, and are forced to care for the dead couple’s baby — despite their mutual acrimony. Will the two of them come together to raise the child — and find love in the process? No spoilers will be revealed here, but suffice to say the pundits find the whole thing to be remarkably predictable – though they also note that the cast does its best to inject some energy into the proceedings.


My Soul to Take

Rather than praying for good reviews, the folks behind My Soul to Take decided to keep critics away prior to the film’s release. Directed by horror maestro Wes Craven, the movie tells the story of a serial killer who returns after a 16-year absence to wreak havoc on a small rural community. Kids: brush your teeth, say your prayers, and guess that Tomatometer!

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Esquire travel Oscars 2017 Adult Swim 24 frames Comedy Central 2015 CNN zombie Extras Sundance TruTV Set visit WGN Country cinemax Nat Geo thriller social media biography discovery Emmys Nickelodeon Trailer TCA 2017 Mystery Biopics RT History war Cosplay Amazon Nominations cops sports FOX harry potter period drama Kids & Family Reality BBC ESPN Disney Channel Mindy Kaling First Look VH1 Bravo Ghostbusters Cartoon Network crime Marathons GIFs Video Games technology Comic Book Certified Fresh CBS All Access Comedy Fox News Premiere Dates NBC TBS ABC E! dramedy vampires President TV Land Star Wars Opinion historical drama Photos Watching Series Interview Animation AMC USA Holidays Winners Teen Food Network Logo adventure VICE Pirates Trivia History Box Office The Arrangement ABC Family Tumblr El Rey CMT Reality Competition science fiction Lifetime SundanceTV crime thriller X-Men GLAAD LGBTQ Horror The CW American Society of Cinematographers Freeform Rock Mary Tyler Moore MTV Fall TV composers Starz Grammys TIFF YA Year in Review police drama ITV psycho Masterpiece Sneak Peek singing competition DC Comics Netflix BBC America PaleyFest comiccon TLC Musicals cooking A&E Countdown Lionsgate Hulu CBS Drama Showtime APB Thanksgiving Podcast OWN Pop Calendar Red Carpet NYCC crime drama Valentine's Day serial killer TCM Best and Worst SDCC IFC Toys Summer Crackle PBS aliens TNT based on movie Universal Election Polls and Games TCA Superheroes FX Music BET Martial Arts Fantasy supernatural boxoffice Rocky Star Trek Writers Guild of America Infographic politics Schedule Disney Character Guide Super Bowl Action Awards Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt FXX Tomatazos HBO Musical DirecTV Rom-Com GoT TV Dark Horse Comics Syfy diversity Spring TV Sci-Fi 2016 Marvel Winter TV sitcom docudrama MSNBC Ellie Kemper 007