Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Playing for Keeps Misses the Mark

Plus, Hyde Park on Hudson is a little too soapy.

by | December 7, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies brings only one new release: Playing for Keeps, a romantic comedy starring Gerard Butler, Jessica Biel, and Uma Thurman. What do the critics have to say?

Playing for Keeps


Some bad movies are aggressive in their awfulness, while others are simply uninspired or clichéd. Critics say Playing for Keeps falls into the latter category, squandering an attractive cast on a script that offers plenty of jarring tonal shifts but no surprises. Gerard Butler stars as a washed-up soccer pro who decides that coaching his kid’s soccer team will help make up for all the time he’s been out of his son’s life. However, the other players’ moms immediately take a shine to the hunky new coach, and complications ensue. The pundits say Playing for Keeps is slavishly devoted to the romantic comedy playbook without exuding much personality of its own, and at times it’s surprisingly sexist. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Butler’s best-reviewed movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

007 Sundance TBS Hulu TCM AMC Exclusive Video Photos Lionsgate Marathons Cartoon Network vampires Thanksgiving President Spring TV CBS All Access Extras ABC Family crime thriller WGN FXX Crackle Trivia Horror Reality comiccon Mystery Ghostbusters Reality Competition Interview Toys MSNBC DirecTV Polls and Games Drama Certified Fresh Fall TV Winter TV American Society of Cinematographers Tumblr Logo TCA Disney Channel El Rey SundanceTV Martial Arts BBC History FOX DC Comics 2017 Cosplay ABC travel singing competition BBC America Opinion GIFs 2015 GoT Video Games Comedy CNN Writers Guild of America VICE HBO Character Guide NBC harry potter Musicals Nominations CBS Set visit TCA 2017 Schedule Esquire Podcast Fox News Oscars cooking Biopics PBS Disney Sci-Fi Marvel Showtime Nickelodeon Rom-Com Election Premiere Dates PaleyFest BET Calendar LGBTQ Star Wars sports Countdown Box Office Awards Fantasy thriller Amazon Music boxoffice sitcom Action Netflix VH1 Summer Trailer Superheroes MTV Emmys Holidays Animation FX Lifetime 24 frames Adult Swim Nat Geo TruTV period drama IFC Kids & Family dramedy E! Freeform Grammys Pop diversity discovery Country Rock Rocky science fiction Pirates Starz Teen Infographic CMT Masterpiece First Look Red Carpet ESPN adventure 2016 Valentine's Day Syfy Universal serial killer Bravo ITV NYCC TV Land SDCC TIFF Winners OWN TNT crime drama The CW social media docudrama Watching Series Comedy Central Food Network Tomatazos politics cinemax USA Best and Worst A&E Sneak Peek Year in Review GLAAD