Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Oblivion Looks Great, But Its Story Meanders

Plus, In the House is creepy and witty.

by | April 18, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got only one wide release: the post-apocalyptic sci-fi adventure Oblivion, starring Tom Cruise and Morgan Freeman. What do the critics have to say?



Can a movie get by on good looks alone? Critics say Oblivion is visually striking but narratively thin, a thoughtful sci-fi head trip that starts strong but gets bogged down by its murky storyline. While working as a repairman on an abandoned, post-Apocalyptic Planet Earth, Jack Harper (Tom Cruise) discovers that he’s not alone — and that everything he knows has been a lie. The pundits say Cruise’s strong performance helps to enliven the proceedings, but Oblivion is largely derivative of other, better sci-fi films. (Check out this week’s 24 Frames and Total Recall features for more on post-apocalyptic movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Finally, props to Emilio Rodriguez and Kadeem Stewart for coming the closest to guessing Scary Movie 5‘s five percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

cults Summer BBC America History sitcom war Toys Masterpiece vampires RT History 20th Century Fox Shondaland Certified Fresh thriller medical drama Trailer Sundance dceu Teen MTV Lionsgate Tomatazos Year in Review Interview Holidays Fantasy IFC FXX science fiction FOX zombies Netflix Freeform Bravo spy thriller singing competition Animation cats robots zombie Star Wars cinemax Reality Competition Cartoon Network Ovation golden globes VICE 21st Century Fox 2015 CBS Ghostbusters festivals Lifetime Britbox Crackle Nickelodeon Nat Geo Watching Series finale TCM SDCC BBC First Look Ellie Kemper Marathons Paramount Network Nominations binge E! Esquire Showtime Polls and Games American Society of Cinematographers romance Superheroes Columbia Pictures Infographic Martial Arts Best and Worst composers sports technology CNN MSNBC Musicals DC Comics Valentine's Day A&E OWN ITV Hulu Thanksgiving TNT Kids & Family dc Rock TCA 2017 GIFs Countdown politics VH1 Trivia Podcast travel Spring TV Syfy cops Music Opinion adventure El Rey PaleyFest USA Writers Guild of America crossover NBC DirecTV period drama Spike PBS Country DC streaming service TV Land Star Trek 2016 comiccon Superheroe Winter TV ABC Horror aliens IFC Films transformers Pixar LGBTQ AMC Mindy Kaling Awards Logo diversity ratings TBS Warner Bros. 2017 TCA crime thriller based on movie Fox News TIFF Amazon GoT Super Bowl YA Western Creative Arts Emmys APB Food Network crime Pirates historical drama E3 Box Office USA Network Universal Christmas Action Starz Biopics Apple Paramount Adult Swim 24 frames GLAAD what to watch Acorn TV YouTube Red ESPN Premiere Dates Election political drama Drama Winners social media Comedy 007 Grammys Lucasfilm Calendar The Arrangement WGN NYCC President National Geographic Rocky ABC Family Disney Channel HBO boxoffice psycho Sony Pictures Schedule Disney Walt Disney Pictures X-Men Red Carpet Oscars SXSW Sci-Fi Video Games Marvel Cosplay 45 Photos supernatural hist DC Universe dramedy Mary Tyler Moore TruTV police drama Comedy Central See It Skip It Tumblr SundanceTV docudrama mutant Comic Book Dark Horse Comics Reality Emmys Sneak Peek justice league Fall TV Pop unscripted CMT CW Seed BET Character Guide Rom-Com CBS All Access TLC TV Set visit Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt harry potter cooking FX biography The CW Extras talk show Musical crime drama discovery Mystery serial killer streaming Sundance Now