Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: No To Yes Man; Seven Pounds Is Too Heavy

Plus, The Tale of Despereaux is so-so, while The Wrestler electrifies.

by | December 18, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got self-improvement (Yes Man, starring Jim Carrey and Zooey Deschanel), mysterious altruism (Seven Pounds, starring Will Smith and Rosario Dawson), and rodent adventures (The Tale of Despereaux, with voice work by Matthew Broderick and Dustin Hoffman). What do the critics have to say?

After a disastrous detour to dramatic territory with The Number 23, Jim Carrey is back to the realm of wacky comedy. Unfortunately, critics say his return is only sporadically successful in Yes Man. Carrey plays Carl, a man gripped by depression who enters a self-help program that encourages its devotees to say yes to each and every question. However, Carl finds answering in the affirmative can sometimes have negative consequences. The pundits say the film has its moments, thanks to Carrey’s manic energy, but it’s ultimately little more than a series of comedic set-pieces that don’t build or cohere; worse, we’ve already seen Carrey do a pretty fine variation on this theme in Liar Liar. At 40 percent on the Tomatometer, you may want to say “no” to Yes Man. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Carrey’s best-reviewed films.)

“What’s it called? Gallipoli? Sounds hilarious!”

It’s unsurprising that Will Smith would want to shed his blockbuster baggage every once in a while and throw himself into a smaller, more dramatically weighty role; unfortunately, critics say his latest, Seven Pounds, is more leaden than anything else. Smith stars as Ben, an IRS agent haunted by past misdeeds. As a way of making amends, he decides to practice random acts of kindness on strangers, a plan that goes in intriguing directions when he falls in love with terminally-ill Emily (Rosario Dawson). Some pundits have given Smith credit for attempting riskier material, but they also say Seven Pounds doesn’t follow the rules of logic very closely, and its tone is somber and portentous. At 35 percent on the Tomatometer, Seven Pounds may not be worth your 10 dollars.

“I’m really sorry that I said girls ain’t nothin’ but trouble.”

Another week, another so-so animated feature. The Tale of Despereaux is a fantasy tale about a heroic little mouse who becomes an outcast for refusing to conform; he befriends a group of rats, with whom he shares a journey of self-discovery and adventure. The pundits say Despereaux looks pretty good, and is mercifully free of the toilet humor and pop culture references that have become commonplace in animated features. However, it’s also lacking a sense of magic, and doesn’t really take dramatic flight. At 42 percent on the Tomatometer, this mouse is a tail’s-length behind Ratatouille.

“Man, it’s taking forever to read this book!””

Also opening this week in limited release:

Recent Jim Carrey Movies:

Tag Cloud

Christmas Teen PaleyFest TV Land 2017 IFC OWN Watching Series CMT Fantasy Pop X-Men Showtime TLC Universal 2016 Oscars sitcom Hulu Interview TIFF BBC America President political drama 007 Character Guide The Arrangement Grammys dceu Music Comedy Lionsgate Syfy Tomatazos Box Office crime DC Comics NYCC discovery Lifetime war Trailer Esquire Cartoon Network Opinion Star Trek cats Star Wars Warner Bros. crime thriller Election History Year in Review Sneak Peek Valentine's Day justice league E3 Sci-Fi based on movie Fall TV Reality zombie Tumblr Polls and Games historical drama Winter TV Mindy Kaling VICE Schedule Action Superheroes CNN Adult Swim The CW what to watch Dark Horse Comics Nickelodeon cops 24 frames WGN Masterpiece Paramount USA binge Infographic Awards TBS dramedy FOX CBS romance TNT Amazon adventure Marvel ITV thriller harry potter 45 Calendar BBC Rocky Rock Disney Channel comiccon TCM Crackle Musical vampires Comedy Central politics GoT travel Photos ABC Family Nominations Sundance E! USA Network Disney Bravo 2015 Freeform Set visit Starz Pirates Nat Geo FX period drama science fiction police drama dc HBO Comic Book Netflix TruTV GLAAD Super Bowl Video Games Podcast American Society of Cinematographers cooking diversity Best and Worst Reality Competition Red Carpet El Rey A&E Writers Guild of America 21st Century Fox TCA 2017 APB spy thriller RT History Cosplay AMC MSNBC Ellie Kemper biography psycho Holidays Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Horror Fox News sports Martial Arts Logo cinemax GIFs See It Skip It Summer technology talk show boxoffice transformers Marathons crime drama Biopics SDCC Drama CBS All Access ABC Ghostbusters medical drama Musicals Premiere Dates docudrama serial killer Country Trivia Spring TV Countdown Certified Fresh Winners Extras TCA Emmys LGBTQ DC Universe SundanceTV First Look Food Network aliens PBS Animation composers DirecTV social media Toys Rom-Com FXX TV YA VH1 ESPN Mystery singing competition NBC supernatural BET Kids & Family MTV Thanksgiving Mary Tyler Moore Western