Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Jack Reacher Features Tom Cruise in Control

Plus, This is 40 is long but funny, The Guilt Trip squanders its cast, Cirque Du Soleil: Worlds Away can?t match the live show, and Monsters, Inc. 3D is Certified Fresh.

by | December 20, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a cool cop (Jack Reacher, starring Tom Cruise and Rosamund Pike); harried marrieds (This is 40, starring Paul Rudd and Leslie Mann); mother-son bonding (The Guilt Trip, starring Barbra Streisand and Seth Rogen); and a fanciful circus (the performance film Cirque Du Soleil: Worlds Away 3D). What do the critics have to say?

Jack Reacher


Sometimes a relatively generic story can be redeemed by a confident central performance. Case in point: Jack Reacher, which critics say is a solid crime thriller that greatly benefits from Tom Cruise’s movie star charisma. Cruise stars as the title character, a former Army M.P. who’s called in to investigate a mass shooting, and soon discovers that he’s up against a dangerous foe. The pundits say Jack Reacher doesn’t lack for clichés, it’s a competent and tense piece of work, and Cruise is cool and compelling. (Check out this week’s 24 Frames for a pictorial overview of Cruise’s career.)

This Is 40


Judd Apatow‘s films frequently balance laughs and pathos with a deft hand, and while critics say This Is 40 is uneven, it’s thought-provoking and occasionally hilarious. Paul Rudd and Leslie Mann reprise their roles from Knocked Up, playing an affluent married couple dealing with the stresses of parenthood, financial insecurity, familial relations, and hard-to-break habits. The pundits say This Is 40 is overlong and sometimes aimless, but it’s buoyed by a terrific cast, a perceptive script, and some very funny moments.

The Guilt Trip


Barbra Streisand is so rarely in films these days that her starring role in The Guilt Trip should be cause for excitement. Unfortunately, the critics say that while she and Seth Rogen share an easy chemistry, it’s largely wasted in a formulaic plot. Rogen stars as an inventor who plans to drive cross-country to pitch his newest product. He invites his overbearing mom along in an attempt to fix her up with an old boyfriend in San Francisco. The pundits say The Guilt Trip is undeniably sweet, and the leads are in fine form, but there are absolutely no surprises to be found in the script.

Cirque Du Soleil: Worlds Away 3D


If those whimsical acrobats from Cirque Du Soleil aren’t making a tour stop in your town, Cirque Du Soleil: Worlds Away is a decent overview; critics say this 3D extravaganza offers thrilling evidence of the troupe’s skills, even if it doesn’t quite match the experience of seeing them live. Producer James Cameron and director Andrew Adamson utilize a minimal narrative — a girl visits a circus and is transported into Cirque Du Soleil’s dreamworld — as an excuse to create a best-of package of the company’s various stage shows. The pundits say Cirque Du Soleil: Worlds Away features plenty of eye-popping imagery, but it may not win over those who don’t already love the group.

Monsters, Inc. 3D


With Monsters University hitting theaters next year, now is as good a time as any to revisit the world of Monsters, Inc. which is getting the rerelease treatment this week in glorious 3D. This tale of a pair of monsters who can’t seem to frighten one tenacious little girl is one of Pixar’s classics; like most of the studio’s output, it’s Certified Fresh.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Writers Guild of America adventure Extras 2017 Fox News diversity Interview Valentine's Day Ellie Kemper Marathons Trivia Logo sitcom ABC X-Men FXX TCA Cartoon Network Hulu FX AMC Super Bowl Winners Mary Tyler Moore SDCC period drama Musical GoT Sci-Fi psycho political drama Box Office Lifetime dramedy boxoffice social media Lionsgate Photos Rock Opinion crime drama BBC cinemax Marvel Country based on movie Teen Pop Showtime singing competition Nickelodeon Esquire CBS All Access Comedy Central TCA 2017 APB VH1 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Drama YA IFC Nominations Disney Channel Netflix Pirates Horror Mindy Kaling FOX Best and Worst biography OWN politics Sneak Peek TIFF Bravo Food Network comiccon docudrama Musicals Freeform 2016 PaleyFest A&E Superheroes aliens Set visit The CW The Arrangement Comedy Action CMT American Society of Cinematographers Universal Adult Swim Animation First Look Calendar CNN 2015 History Disney ITV Oscars VICE vampires Star Wars Countdown Grammys DirecTV Video Games Red Carpet Martial Arts Premiere Dates serial killer MSNBC Music DC Comics Ghostbusters Awards MTV Spring TV Reality USA police drama Infographic RT History science fiction WGN TV 24 frames BBC America Watching Series GLAAD NBC TLC Thanksgiving Election historical drama Amazon Starz Rocky Mystery Toys Nat Geo 007 GIFs Dark Horse Comics Masterpiece SundanceTV Schedule Fantasy TNT Year in Review Reality Competition Polls and Games composers ESPN E! Fall TV cops Kids & Family Winter TV Holidays technology Tumblr harry potter travel Crackle Certified Fresh Emmys Rom-Com Summer BET TCM ABC Family Cosplay crime thriller HBO thriller Comic Book zombie LGBTQ Syfy PBS cooking Tomatazos supernatural sports Sundance crime TBS TV Land TruTV Podcast discovery President Trailer Biopics war El Rey Character Guide NYCC Star Trek CBS