Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: From Paris With Love Is Not Bon

Plus, critics stamp "return to sender" on Dear John.

by | February 4, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got Gallic gunplay (From Paris With Love, starring John Travolta and Jonathan Rhys Meyers) and some sad pen pals (Dear John, starring Channing Tatum and Amanda Seyfried). What do the critics have to say?


From Paris With Love

It’s been a while since a good cop-buddy action flick has hit screens, a situation that critics say From Paris With Love does little to alleviate. Jonathan Rhys Meyers stars as a low-level CIA agent who’s thrilled to be assigned to a career-making case; too bad his new partner (John Travolta) is a trigger-happy wild man. Together, they must thwart a terrorist attack on Paris — one that’s targeting our heroes as well. The pundits say Paris benefits from Travolta’s gleefully over-the-top performance, but overall the film doesn’t quite find a balance between its laughs and thrills. (Check out our Total Recall countdown of Travolta’s best-reviewed movies.)


Dear John

If you’re in the mood for a tearjerker — or, perhaps a tear-yanker — any movie adapted from a Nicolas Sparks novel will probably do the job (The Notebook and A Walk to Remember are based on his books). But critics say Dear John is overly sappy and melodramatic even by weepie standards. Amanda Seyfried stars as a college student who meets a soldier (played by Channing Tatum) while he’s on temporary leave – over the next few years, their love blooms via snail mail, before tragedy strikes. The pundits say Dear John is schmaltzy, overly manipulative, and generally dull, though the leads are appealing.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • The Israeli import Ajami, about multi-ethnic tension in the wake of a revenge killing, is at 93 percent.

  • Terribly Happy, a Danish drama about a onetime big-city cop who gets tied up in small town affairs, is at 89 percent.

  • Eyes Wide Open, the tale of a married Orthodox Jew who gets involved with a younger man, is at 75 percent.

  • District 13: Ultimatum, the sequel to the movie that popularized the parkour craze, is at 64 percent.

  • The Red Riding Trilogy, a dark made-for-British-TV thriller about the hunt for a serial killer, is at 56 percent.
  • Frozen, a horror flick about three friends trapped on a ski lift, is at 38 percent.

Tag Cloud

Super Bowl crime drama Comedy Musical Podcast Syfy El Rey Character Guide cops Music Oscars IFC Premiere Dates war Trivia TNT TIFF Spring TV crime thriller TBS Comedy Central Hulu VICE Certified Fresh Esquire Pop BET Rom-Com 2016 Photos APB Extras composers Pirates Summer TCA comiccon TV cinemax Winter TV Fall TV Nominations technology 2017 police drama Interview WGN Opinion Action A&E BBC Thanksgiving TV Land Emmys Universal Watching Series Holidays Best and Worst science fiction Ghostbusters PaleyFest Box Office Nat Geo President Reality Competition PBS diversity Grammys GLAAD GIFs Bravo Calendar CBS MSNBC Lifetime First Look aliens ABC Sundance Dark Horse Comics Infographic dramedy travel 2015 singing competition Starz 24 frames Tumblr Biopics Writers Guild of America The Arrangement discovery CBS All Access harry potter NBC FXX Cartoon Network DirecTV Martial Arts Set visit Fox News Awards GoT Rocky ITV Disney Logo social media Sneak Peek RT History Election MTV Winners History Disney Channel AMC FOX SDCC zombie Sci-Fi Musicals biography based on movie serial killer Star Trek Country USA Comic Book Trailer 007 politics Rock Netflix OWN ESPN FX TLC sports Reality TruTV SundanceTV CNN sitcom Food Network Schedule Mystery Valentine's Day supernatural The CW HBO ABC Family E! Marvel Freeform vampires Animation Red Carpet Amazon thriller historical drama Fantasy Marathons BBC America Mary Tyler Moore Kids & Family Drama Adult Swim American Society of Cinematographers Nickelodeon boxoffice Showtime Tomatazos Toys Year in Review Masterpiece X-Men LGBTQ period drama Countdown Cosplay Horror CMT TCA 2017 cooking Video Games NYCC Teen TCM psycho VH1 Superheroes Polls and Games DC Comics Star Wars adventure docudrama Crackle crime Lionsgate