Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Divergent Disappoints

Plus, Muppets Most Wanted is Certified Fresh.

by | March 21, 2014 | Comments


This week at the movies, we’ve got individuality under attack (Divergent, starring Shailene Woodley and Kate Winslet) and Kermit under lock and key (Muppets Most Wanted, starring Ricky Gervais and Tina Fey). What do the critics have to say?



Based on a series of popular young adult novels, Divergent is a sci-fi allegory about the dangers of conformity. Ironically, critics say the biggest problem with the film is that it borrows too heavily from the likes of The Hunger Games and Harry Potter, leaving its terrific cast stranded in a sea of exposition. In a dystopian future, teenagers are forced to chose one of five factions with which they’ll associate for life. However, Beatrice Prior (Shailene Woodley) doesn’t fit neatly into any one group, and her independent streak makes her a target when two rival tribes prepare for war. The pundits say Woodley gives a star-making performance, and her supporting cast is top-notch, but Divergent is too grim and jumbled to fully resonate. (Check out our gallery of co-star Kate Winslet in some of her most memorable roles.)

Muppets Most Wanted


“Everybody knows that the sequel’s never quite as good,” sing Kermit and Fozzie in the opening scene of Muppets Most Wanted. The operative word here is “quite,” for the critics say that while this caper comedy lacks the breezy charm of The Muppets, it’s got enough laughs and catchy tunes to entertain in its own right. Hot off their successful reunion show, the Muppets decide to take their act on the road, but things quickly go amiss when they sign up with a fast-talking booking agent (Ricky Gervais) who’s in league with a wanted criminal mastermind — and who looks exactly like Kermit the Frog. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Muppets Most Wanted maintains the anarchic spirit of the Muppets, and if the story isn’t as strong this time out, the rapid-fire gags are reliably witty and inventive. (Check out our video interviews with the cast, as well as our rundown of the best films from the Jim Henson Company.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Finally, props to Vicente Torres and Nat Brautigam for coming the closest to guessing The Single Moms Club‘s 17 percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

BBC America Box Office cooking Starz discovery Reality diversity sitcom boxoffice Election SundanceTV Apple Red Carpet Polls and Games Spike President CW Seed Sundance Now SDCC MSNBC Video Games cults Mindy Kaling TCA 2017 Sony Pictures Pixar Trailer cinemax Podcast Sundance Star Trek Writers Guild of America biography Kids & Family robots Superheroe Ellie Kemper Fantasy Biopics period drama TV Animation Grammys Ghostbusters Photos Opinion Countdown golden globes NYCC Lucasfilm 007 20th Century Fox Schedule mutant crime drama FXX CBS All Access Comedy GLAAD based on movie Fall TV historical drama E! transformers DC streaming service medical drama PaleyFest FOX Christmas PBS Pirates Walt Disney Pictures Masterpiece Nickelodeon Esquire DC Universe Creative Arts Emmys YouTube Premium zombies 2017 Infographic Watching Series Comic Book travel Disney hist FX spy thriller Certified Fresh BET Rock IFC ratings Holidays politics Valentine's Day Set visit dceu Ovation YouTube Red TBS Nat Geo romance ESPN cats Oscars CBS X-Men Hulu Cartoon Network political drama Marvel finale Dark Horse Comics WGN Trivia Mary Tyler Moore harry potter The CW IFC Films crime thriller Logo MTV Pop OWN Sci-Fi binge Lionsgate Emmys Musical Acorn TV NBC Showtime police drama Adult Swim Netflix HBO Music Sneak Peek festivals Toys Mystery Crackle comiccon TNT First Look BBC technology National Geographic Drama aliens Year in Review 21st Century Fox History Marathons Action Teen Superheroes APB crossover Rom-Com VH1 DirecTV 2016 Premiere Dates Paramount Freeform 45 See It Skip It USA Network TIFF Bravo Extras Western 24 frames blaxploitation CNN SXSW Paramount Network Shondaland VICE adventure Best and Worst USA Musicals LGBTQ ITV Calendar A&E Tomatazos Country GoT Awards social media TCM vampires TLC Cosplay Thanksgiving Star Wars TCA unscripted 2015 ABC Family Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Disney Channel Winners The Arrangement thriller Interview composers ABC Columbia Pictures Syfy psycho E3 Warner Bros. Lifetime GIFs justice league serial killer Fox News Character Guide Comedy Central cops zombie RT History American Society of Cinematographers Spring TV streaming CMT singing competition AMC talk show crime Nominations science fiction Britbox Rocky Tumblr YA Super Bowl dramedy Horror Universal Song of Ice and Fire Food Network TruTV Summer Winter TV sports TV Land DC Comics El Rey what to watch dc docudrama supernatural Reality Competition war Amazon Martial Arts