Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Coraline Is Certified Fresh

Plus, the critics just aren't that into He's Just Not That Into You, Pink Panther 2, and Push, to varying degrees.

by | February 5, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got dark whimsy (Coraline, with voice work by Dakota Fanning and Teri Hatcher); love mishaps (He’s Just Not That Into You, starring Jennifer Aniston and Scarlett Johansson); a bumbling detective (The Pink Panther 2, starring Steve Martin and Aishwarya Rai) and some paranormal antagonists (Push, starring Chris Evans and Djimon Hounsou). What do the critics have to say?



If any proof were needed that 3-D movies have entered a bold new era, the critics say Coraline is it; this stylistically bold, emotionally resonant stop-motion flick is a twisted marvel. Directed by Henry Selick (who helmed the bewitchingly macabre The Nightmare Before Christmas) and based upon the best seller by Neil Gaiman, Coraline follows the phantasmagoric exploits of the title character (voiced by Dakota Fanning), a bored 11-year-old who discovers a door in her house that leads to a parallel version of her life — one that at first is enchanting, but soon threatens to entrap our hero. The pundits say Coraline is one of the most visually dazzling pictures to come along in many a moon, and it’s anchored by a delightfully twisted storyline. It’s not only Certified Fresh, it’s also the best-reviewed wide release of the year so far. (Be forewarned, however; the scribes say this film may be too scary for small children.)


He’s Just Not That Into You

He’s Just Not That Into You is the latest in a long line of romantic comedies that attempt to navigate the complexities of modern relationships. The movie’s problem, critics say, is that by juggling so many plot threads it ends up giving a short shrift to characterization and insight. An embarrassment of talented actors (including Jennifer Aniston, Drew Barrymore, Scarlett Johansson, Ben Affleck, and Jennifer Connelly) play Baltimore residents who are attempting to find the perfect match, but are regularly stymied by self-questioning and unreturned phone calls. The pundits say the film is bogged down by the fact that there’s too much going on for the characters to emerge as three-dimensional personalities, thus reducing its talented thespians (despite their best efforts) to playing stereotypes.


The Pink Panther 2

As the self-important, supremely incompetent, and impenetrably-accented Inspector Clouseau, Peter Sellers created one of the most memorable comic characters of modern times. Steve Martin is a very funny guy too, but critics say that’s not enough to redeem The Pink Panther 2‘s uninspired script and tired gags. In the second installment starring Martin, Clouseau is enlisted into a team of super detectives in order to track down some priceless cultural artifacts that have been purloined by a rogue named the Tornado. The pundits say that like its predecessor, The Pink Panther 2 is a “beumb”; it’s aimlessly plotted and emphasizes lame slapstick gags at the expense of the considerable talents of Martin, John Cleese, Lily Tomlin, Jeremy Irons, and Aishwarya Rai, among others. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we explore Martin’s best-reviewed movies, and click here for co-star Jean Reno‘s five favorite films.)



Establishing a credible science fiction world — especially one containing characters with super abilities — is a tall order. Unfortunately, critics say Push isn’t up to it, squandering an intriguing premise with hyperkinetic pacing and a general lack of coherence. Chris Evans plays Nick, who has remarkable paranormal powers and finds himself on the run from unseemly government agents, including the dangerous Henry (Djimon Hounsou), who want to utilize his abilities for their own means. The pundits say that despite director Paul McGuigan‘s visual flair, Push is really hard to follow, with a convoluted script and an excess of style. (Check out our interview with McGuigan, in which he shares his five favorite films with RT.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Chocolate, a bizarre Thai martial arts flick about an autistic girl with remarkable fighting skills, is at 71 percent.
  • Our City Dreams, a documentary about a year in the life of five female artists in New York City, is at 67 percent.
  • The road trip comedy Fanboys, which follows several Star Wars fanatics on their quest to see The Phantom Menace before its release, is at 27 percent.
  • Memorial Day, a mockumentary about a group of hard-partying soldiers and their bad behavior on leave and in Iraq, is at 14 percent.

Tag Cloud

Musicals WGN Kids & Family Spike Adult Swim BBC Action 45 BBC America RT History FOX composers Sci-Fi cooking NYCC Mystery MSNBC SundanceTV cinemax Starz spy thriller Trailer Rom-Com Music TruTV singing competition TV Land discovery Awards ABC Family Tomatazos Horror Western Certified Fresh Nominations Marvel IFC Teen Cosplay TIFF TCA DC Comics TNT DirecTV comiccon historical drama Hulu CBS E3 Sundance zombie boxoffice crime thriller Nat Geo Universal Oscars cops medical drama Winners Schedule Fantasy USA Network Watching Series GoT Winter TV sitcom Mindy Kaling Photos Paramount supernatural Emmys Super Bowl 2015 Reality Competition crime drama YA Logo Mary Tyler Moore psycho SDCC Fall TV NBC travel Video Games Comedy talk show Red Carpet Extras Christmas politics Interview Pirates ITV CBS All Access dceu AMC Country Fox News docudrama Bravo El Rey period drama DC Universe Food Network Opinion PaleyFest 007 FX Lifetime Masterpiece romance aliens Toys X-Men binge CNN Character Guide Star Wars Spring TV transformers Esquire Star Trek Showtime LGBTQ FXX serial killer 2016 ESPN Rock golden globes based on movie Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt OWN science fiction vampires Superheroes Infographic Warner Bros. PBS social media Writers Guild of America Dark Horse Comics VICE TBS Netflix Holidays Martial Arts History adventure 21st Century Fox Year in Review Animation CMT Pop war HBO Calendar Ghostbusters First Look Valentine's Day biography Disney Summer VH1 political drama APB harry potter Grammys Cartoon Network diversity Comedy Central 2017 Sneak Peek thriller Thanksgiving Disney Channel TCA 2017 Ellie Kemper Best and Worst TV MTV Musical Syfy Countdown dc The CW technology cats USA Podcast American Society of Cinematographers Box Office crime ABC police drama BET Amazon Premiere Dates E! The Arrangement sports ratings Lionsgate Set visit Trivia Election Biopics Tumblr See It Skip It Reality Comic Book GLAAD TCM 24 frames TLC justice league GIFs Drama Polls and Games dramedy what to watch Rocky Nickelodeon A&E President Marathons Crackle Freeform Creative Arts Emmys