Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: Water Horse is Refreshing, Debaters is Great, Juno is Certifed Fresh

Plus: Guess Alien vs. Predator: Requiem's Tomatometer.

by | December 25, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we have galactic monsters (Alien vs Predator: Requiem), ol’ Nessie (The
Water Horse: Legend of the Deep
), big talkers (The Great Debaters,
starring Denzel Washington), and preggered pubescents (Juno, starring
Ellen Page
and Michael Cera). What do the critics have to say?

The story of a youngster who befriends a mythical beast, The
Water Horse: Legend of the Deep
makes for occasionally magical family
entertainment, critics say. Sorta like E.T but with a thicker brogue, The
Water Horse
tells the story of Angus (Alex Atel), who stumbles upon a
mysterious egg that contains a creature that grows up to be the Loch Ness
Monster. Pundits say that while it feels familiar and doesn’t stray too from
coming-of-age story conventions, The Water Horse is loaded with charm and
a sense of majesty, carried by strong CGI work. At 71 percent on the Tomatometer, this Water is safe to wade in for the whole family.

Denzel Washington directs and stars in
The Great Debaters, the based-on-truth
account of a group of African American college students from Texas that
challenged the status quo. While the film follows the inspirational drama
formula to a tee, critics were willing to forgive its conservative plot and be
inspired by the rousing performances and Washington’s unobtrusive direction. At
74 percent, Debaters is Great indeed.

Teen pregnancy is not generally a topic that lends itself to hilarity.
However, critics say Juno
is a touching, intelligent, and laugh-out-loud
exception to the rule. Juno stars
Ellen Page as
a smart, headstrong teenager who finds herself pregnant after a one night stand
with her best friend (Michael Cera) and tries to deal with the repercussions. The pundits say Juno
is full of quirk and heart, featuring fine performances from Page, Cera,
Jennifer Garner, and
Jason Bateman, as well as fine direction from
Jason Reitman
and a precociously smart script from first-time writer
Diablo Cody. At 94
percent on the Tomatometer, Juno is not only Certified Fresh, it’s one of the
best-reviewed films of the year. (Check out our interview with Page

The very presence of Alien vs Predator: Requiem in theaters this week
begs an important question: is there any better way to celebrate the holiday
season than with a cataclysmic throwdown between two of sci fi’s most iconic
monsters? Unfortunately, we’ll have to wait and see, since this one wasn’t shown
to critics prior to release (probably a wise move, since the first

notched a lusty 22 percent on the Tomatometer). AVP:R finds the action has
moved from outer space to Colorado, where Predator and the aliens duke it out.
Kids, take time out from celebrating the fact that you received a Nintendo Wii
and guess that Tomatometer.


Also opening in limited release this week:

Tag Cloud

NBC Trailer Logo Disney Thanksgiving Winners YA Star Trek 2016 Trivia Fantasy Lifetime Red Carpet Countdown CNN SundanceTV Valentine's Day History FX Disney Channel Emmys aliens Character Guide Awards crime Interview composers period drama Star Wars A&E Martial Arts The Arrangement supernatural Kids & Family adventure social media Country Universal technology comiccon Biopics vampires Infographic Action Tumblr Starz historical drama Oscars Nickelodeon Schedule Food Network BET travel First Look Cosplay TLC discovery cinemax RT History CMT Sneak Peek Rock HBO USA science fiction crime drama Superheroes Hulu GLAAD Netflix BBC America Amazon police drama sports Reality Summer Opinion Masterpiece Premiere Dates Musical Animation Marathons cooking Grammys Comedy Central crime thriller NYCC Crackle Lionsgate politics singing competition GIFs GoT Adult Swim Reality Competition MSNBC Extras ITV OWN AMC Teen diversity IFC Best and Worst DC Comics Election LGBTQ Toys Certified Fresh TCA 2017 TCM CBS All Access American Society of Cinematographers zombie Polls and Games Ellie Kemper FXX Comic Book Calendar TruTV Cartoon Network CBS TBS Marvel Fall TV El Rey Ghostbusters thriller harry potter PBS Musicals FOX TNT Mindy Kaling serial killer Holidays Nominations E! Tomatazos President Box Office 24 frames Year in Review Podcast Rom-Com psycho The CW BBC boxoffice SDCC 007 based on movie Horror sitcom MTV war Photos Music docudrama TIFF DirecTV VICE Rocky Showtime Set visit Dark Horse Comics Mary Tyler Moore TV Land cops Comedy Drama Esquire APB TV TCA Nat Geo Sci-Fi Freeform Pop Winter TV Sundance Video Games Watching Series Pirates Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Super Bowl VH1 Spring TV Bravo PaleyFest 2015 2017 dramedy ESPN Syfy X-Men ABC biography Mystery WGN Fox News Writers Guild of America ABC Family