Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Nativity" Is Too Safe; "Turistas" Not Worth Trip

by | November 30, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a new take on the first Noel ("The Nativity Story," starring Keisha Castle-Hughes), endangered Americans in Brazil ("Turistas," starring Melissa George), and a hard partying expat ("Van Wilder: The Rise of Taj," starring Kal Penn). What do the critics have to say?

It may be based on The Greatest Story Ever Told, but critics say "The Nativity Story" is hardly the greatest movie ever made — or even a particularly good one. In case you need a refresher on the origins of the upcoming holiday that may be the occasion for you to receive a Playstation 3, "The Nativity Story" tells the tale of a teenager named Mary (Keisha Castle-Hughes) who is to give birth to the savior of mankind — all the while dealing with political persecution and lousy hotel service. Critics say the film is too safe (strange, given director Catherine Hardwicke‘s previous films about remarkable young people, "Thirteen" and "Lords of Dogtown"), adding little spark to the most inspirational (and familiar) of sagas. "The Nativity Story" currently stands at 26 percent on the Tomatometer.

Mary, don’t you weep.

"Turistas" continues a mini-trend in slasher films that began with "Hostel": arrogant Americans getting their comeuppance in foreign locales. In this case, a group of youngsters are terrorized in Brazil after they fall into the clutches of a mad organ harvester. While some critics have praised the film’s political undertones and better-than-average tension, most say "Turistas" adds little to a stale genre. At 38 percent on the Tomatometer, this tourist trap may be worth avoiding.

"Turistas": Return I won’t to old Brazil.

"Van Wilder: The Rise of Taj" was not screened for critics, which may indicate that it has the potential to sink like a stone with the scribes. (The original "Van Wilder" garnered a robust 17 percent.) Guess that Tomatometer.

They may not be toasting when the reviews come out….

Opening this week in limited release: "10 Items or Less," a laid-back romance starring Morgan Freeman and Paz Vega, is at 53 percent; "3 Needles," a globe-spanning drama about the toll of the AIDS virus, is at 33 percent; and "The Architect," a tale of two families in conflict over a public housing structure, is at 33 percent.

Notable Biblical Epics:
51% — The Passion of the Christ (2004)
80% — The Last Temptation of Christ (1988)
88% — The Gospel According to St. Matthew (1965)
96% — Ben Hur (1959)
91% — The Ten Commandments (1956)

Recent Slasher Movies:
29% — Saw III (2006)
18% — Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning (2006)
57% — Feast (2006)
35% — Calvaire (2006)
20% — Mad Cowgirl (2006)

Tag Cloud

crime drama DC Comics RT History The Arrangement The CW ITV discovery Animation Comedy Central NBC TruTV Rock crime Pirates comiccon Crackle Marvel travel TNT Adult Swim IFC TCM Warner Bros. BET supernatural Holidays Year in Review Rocky technology Drama Biopics MSNBC Premiere Dates CMT History Oscars based on movie crime thriller Disney GIFs docudrama TV E3 boxoffice Mary Tyler Moore MTV Nat Geo ABC Family Trailer Musicals composers 45 Polls and Games Video Games Bravo political drama Ellie Kemper Character Guide Showtime YA Infographic FX AMC Fall TV APB Podcast Superheroes serial killer dramedy GLAAD PBS Mystery Mindy Kaling Ghostbusters BBC Paramount biography 2016 NYCC Starz zombie A&E Teen TCA Awards Toys Grammys SundanceTV Photos 007 TCA 2017 Opinion Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt cinemax Star Trek Extras Nickelodeon FXX Interview TBS ABC Super Bowl Tomatazos Star Wars WGN Sci-Fi adventure singing competition CBS Writers Guild of America science fiction DirecTV Freeform Schedule Reality Nominations 2017 DC Universe Country Certified Fresh PaleyFest ESPN Action El Rey BBC America Masterpiece TV Land talk show Lifetime period drama Summer politics Watching Series Calendar diversity Reality Competition Winners Universal Comedy Cartoon Network psycho Election Netflix sports Thanksgiving 24 frames transformers aliens First Look Valentine's Day Winter TV Fantasy Amazon Horror Hulu CNN USA Kids & Family Disney Channel war TLC OWN 2015 Esquire X-Men LGBTQ Music Cosplay Trivia Lionsgate Tumblr Red Carpet cops Martial Arts Box Office Sundance harry potter Fox News Marathons VH1 Countdown Syfy American Society of Cinematographers GoT Sneak Peek Set visit police drama cooking sitcom VICE HBO Rom-Com Spring TV historical drama thriller President Best and Worst E! Comic Book Logo Emmys vampires Dark Horse Comics FOX CBS All Access SDCC cats social media TIFF Pop Musical Food Network