Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Fire" Blazes; "Scissors" Isn't Sharp Enough; "Saw III" Not Screened: Guess The Tomatometer!

by | October 26, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got the return of Jigsaw ("Saw III," starring Tobin Bell), a tale of rebellion in apartheid-era South Africa ("Catch a Fire," starring Derek Luke and Tim Robbins), and a story of family dysfunction in the 1970s ("Running with Scissors," starring Annette Bening, Gwyneth Paltrow, and Alec Baldwin). What do the critics have to say?

The sheer awfulness of South Africa’s apartheid system has been grist for Hollywood’s mill in recent years, but Phillip Noyce’s "Catch a Fire" may be one of the subgenre’s strongest entries to date. "Fire" tells the true story of Patrick Chamusso (Derek Luke), a dedicated family man falsely accused of terrorism who in turn becomes a radical rebel fighter against the apartheid government. Critics say the film works as both a political thriller and as a potent history lesson, and it features a particularly strong performance from Luke. At 77 percent on the Tomatometer, you may want to "Catch" this one. (Check out RT editor Jen Yamato’s review from the Toronto Film Fest here.)

"If you are the big tree/ We are the small axe/ Ready to cut you down (well sharp)/ To cut you down."

Augusten Burroughs’ memoir "Running with Scissors" struck a nerve as a bizarre depiction of dysfunctional families and a culture of therapy among the privileged. Unfortunately, it doesn’t appear the movie adaptation will do the same. The film is a coming-of-age story about a young man whose unstable mother sends him to live with her therapist’s family, at which point his life only gets weirder. The critics say the film features some sharp performances — particularly by Annette Bening — but also note the film is too awash with mannered eccentricity and cartoonish caricatures rather than fully developed characters. At 33 percent on the Tomatometer, this one’s "Running" on fumes.

"Listen doc, let me start off by saying I hate your socks."

They say the first cut is the deepest. And if the fact that it hasn’t been screened for critics is any indication, it appears that in the case of "Saw III," the blade’s gotten pretty dull. So kids, it’s time to bust out the old crystal balls and play Guess the Tomatometer!

This guy is especially mad because he’ll be late to the office Halloween party.

Also in theaters this week in limited release: "Cocaine Cowboys," a documentary about drug smuggling in Miami in the late 1970s and early 1980s, is at 100 percent; "Exit: The Right to Die," a documentary about assisted suicide, is at 86 percent; "Shut Up & Sing," a rockumentary about the Dixie Chicks, is at 83 percent; "Babel," Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu‘s globetrotting film about despair and interconnectivity, starring Brad Pitt and Cate Blanchett, is at 72 percent; "The Wild Blue Yonder: A Science Fiction Fantasy," Werner Herzog‘s latest epic journey, is at 70 percent; "The Bridge," a doc about suicides on San Francisco’s Golden Gate Bridge, is at 63 percent; "Climates," an atmospheric Turkish import about the decline of a relationship, is at 46 percent; and "Death of a President," the incendiary mockumentary about a plot against George W. Bush, bombed with the critics, as it’s at 33 percent.

"Babel": "Though the mountains divide/ And the oceans are wide/ It’s a small world after all."

Recent Slasher Movies:
18% — Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning (2006)
57% — Feast (2006)
35% — Calvaire (2006)
20% — Mad Cowgirl (2006)
6% — See No Evil (2006)

Recent Derek Luke Movies:
58% — Glory Road (2006)
82% — Friday Night Lights (2004)
65% — Spartan (2004)
83% — Pieces of April (2003)
22% — Biker Boyz (2003)

Recent Annette Bening Movies:
33% — Mrs. Harris (2005)
76% — Being Julia (2004)
79% — Open Range (2003)
45% — What Planet Are You From? (2000)
89% — American Beauty (1999)

Tag Cloud

politics Summer APB cooking diversity crime Holidays Oscars ITV transformers First Look Toys Warner Bros. Action Writers Guild of America USA Teen serial killer TLC cops Best and Worst Dark Horse Comics A&E Disney Channel President CBS All Access AMC comiccon thriller History Infographic SundanceTV Comic Book Rocky Amazon Music Emmys Bravo Kids & Family The CW The Arrangement historical drama Showtime Sneak Peek GoT Opinion Photos NBC ABC police drama Certified Fresh Paramount Video Games Trailer ESPN MTV Countdown social media Biopics Adult Swim Animation Mystery ABC Family 24 frames Musicals travel dramedy NYCC Comedy Marvel FXX political drama Trivia TCA Extras boxoffice Lifetime X-Men OWN Schedule E! sitcom LGBTQ technology Fantasy Awards based on movie BET YA Premiere Dates Drama Starz Tomatazos TCM Calendar cats Pirates FX RT History CNN Character Guide Fall TV singing competition HBO El Rey Superheroes VICE composers psycho Super Bowl WGN TIFF Nat Geo Star Wars Esquire Set visit American Society of Cinematographers Hulu Crackle BBC America Tumblr discovery DirecTV period drama Reality Competition 007 docudrama 45 Valentine's Day Martial Arts Syfy biography Food Network Grammys Fox News Cosplay Rock E3 Reality CBS crime drama Mary Tyler Moore Interview TV zombie TNT Sundance Red Carpet Pop Marathons Lionsgate Horror FOX Rom-Com Masterpiece Star Trek BBC Cartoon Network Spring TV Netflix Watching Series Podcast Nickelodeon SDCC Nominations Universal DC Universe vampires Polls and Games IFC Mindy Kaling TBS 2015 TCA 2017 science fiction VH1 Election aliens Ghostbusters 2017 Ellie Kemper CMT Freeform Logo Year in Review Sci-Fi adventure Musical Winter TV DC Comics Disney supernatural 2016 harry potter Comedy Central sports TV Land GIFs TruTV Country crime thriller Box Office GLAAD Thanksgiving war PaleyFest Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt cinemax talk show Winners PBS MSNBC